Wolf Trek: When the Bough Breaks

Captain’s log, stardate 79250.9: Wesley and other Enterprise children are kidnapped by the powerful Aldeans whose race is sterile. Picard’s attempts at negotiation only result in conflict, leaving Wesley to formulate an escape plan.


Let’s just be honest: “When the Bough Breaks” is an exceptionally mid-tier episode of TNG. As with episodes like “Justice” and “Angel One,” you get the sense that this is TNG on autopilot, taking something that could have been made in the late ‘60s during the original series, and reworking it to fit the Next Gen crew instead.

I will say, though, that this episode is probably one of the best for our acting ensign Wesley Crusher. Having watched TNG all the way through once before, I think I can safely say that the fandom, unfairly, gives Wes (and by extension Wil Wheaton) a very bad rap.

Like, okay, the bullshit the show got up to in “Naked Now” where Wesley is both the cause of a problem (the Enterprise risks being destroyed by a nearby star) and the solution was annoying as hell, and the blatant character shilling by the Traveler in “Where No One Has Gone Before” set my teeth on edge.

However. None of this is actually Wheaton’s fault. He is an actor, and a pretty good one considering how young he is in this, trying to do his best with the material he’s given. It’s the same problem Matthew Waterhouse had on Doctor Who in the early 80s, when he was playing the teen genius character of Adric: we all hate him, but more from how the character was written than from how he was played.

(And for that matter: Wesley Crusher is a better character than Adric by several orders of magnitude.)

The problem is that over the ensuing 37 years, the Received Wisdom of TNG (skip seasons 1 and 2, Wesley sucks and deserves all the abuse he gets, etc) becomes virtual gospel. And yet, when you actually sit down to watch the freaking episodes, you find a character who, though not without his flaws, is still much better than the aforementioned received wisdom would have you believe.

Consider what Wesley does once the kids are kidnapped. Rather than freaking out or trying to panic, our acting ensign is the picture of Starfleet emotional control:

KATIE: (blonde girl half Wesley’s height) Wesley, I’m frightened.
WESLEY: I know you are, Katie. We all are. But we’re going to be all right. Everyone knows where we are, and no one is going to hurt you. I promise.
(Radue, Rashella and Duana enter)
RADUE: Greetings, Wesley Crusher. The Custodian indicated that you would be the leader.
WESLEY: The Custodian? Who is the Custodian?
RADUE: The Custodian is not a person.
RASHELLA: You have been brought to Aldea as our guests. We’ll provide anything you need or want.
WESLEY: We want to go home.
RADUE: Wesley, all of you have been chosen because you are special. Just ask for anything you want, and you shall have it.

And like, he didn’t just learn this from Jean-Luc. This kid has Starfleet in his blood, his dad used to serve with Picard on the Stargazer, while his mom is the chief medical officer of the flagship for all but one season of the show. So of course he would know what to do in a situation like this: remain calm, project an aura of strength and confidence, and keep up crew morale as well as you can, while also doing your best to make sure everyone gets home. That’s what a Starfleet officer does, especially those in the command track like Wesley here.

The TV Tropes page for this episode comments, “Given Wesley’s oft-touted Teen Genius intellect and the fact that’s he’s given access to the Aldean supercomputer, it’s odd that he never attempts to disable the planetary shield/cloak from within (even if he failed, he could have at least tried). It’s an unusual case where “Wesley saves the day” actually would have made some amount of sense yet the most he does is lead a hunger strike.”

I think I can explain this. Partly, his failure to do anything about the shield early on is so the Enterprise crew can do it at the end of act five, while the other half of it is, I think his teen genius tendencies really only apply in the specific environment of a Federation starship, around technology he knows. While he’s familiar enough with the Custodian to do the basics, anything more advanced than that (given how impressive Aldean technology allegedly is) might be beyond his skills. He is, after all, still a kid.

I don’t know that I’ll ever be the hugest fan of Wesley Crusher, but that doesn’t really matter. I like him enough to know that he doesn’t deserve all the hate he’s gotten over the last 3 decades. Certainly, Will Wheaton himself doesn’t. He’s spent most of the time since the invention of social media blocking anyone who says “Shut up Wesley!” even as a joke, and frankly, good for him. That people still treat him like he’s that kid they all hated on TNG as opposed to a grown man is just plain cruel.

You wanna know my favorite Wheaton moment? The entire segment of the Ready Room show devoted to the reconstructed Enterprise-D. While wearing a shirt that reads Acting Ensign, Wheaton guides us through the bridge alongside Michael Okuda, giving us an inside look (from his own perspective) on how various aspects of the ship work, including tactical and of course, the helm console he always sat at during the show.

And toward the end of this… well. He gets to sit in The Chair.

By The Chair, I of course mean the captain’s chair. The only person allowed to sit in that chair was Patrick Stewart, since he was the captain, both onscreen and off. (Unless, of course, guests were visiting or a script called for someone else’s character to sit there, which did often happen.)

In the Ready Room segment, Wheaton reveals he texted the cast asking for permission to sit in the Chair. Frakes replies: “Mr. Crusher… You have the bridge.”

Wheaton then sits in the chair, and honest to god, his utterly delighted, awestruck expression is one of the sweetest things I’ve ever seen in my life.

And once you’ve seen that, you’d have to have a heart of stone to still hate Wheaton or his character.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑