So, here we are: the final entry in Adventures in Narrative Substitution, the final post on the Chibnall era I'll ever write, and the next-to-last one you'll read, as the 42 post in The RTD Rewind will come out after this. It's taken a long time to get here, but the end is in sight.... Continue Reading →
Adventures in Narrative Substitution: Legend of the Sea Devils
First of all, I’d like to begin by shamelessly plugging my new book, the second volume of the Back to the Eleventh Hourtrilogy of critical essays on the era of the Eleventh Doctor. It covers series six, a truly mad and ambitious season of the show if there ever was one. Yes, the same description... Continue Reading →
Adventures in Narrative Substitution: Eve of the Daleks
I’ve talked a lot over the course of this series about queerness, and in particular, the Chibnall era’s continual failures to deliver. I don’t think I’m being at all hyperbolic when I say that his era of the show is easily the most cis-het of the New Series so far. And when queer characters have... Continue Reading →
Adventures in Narrative Substitution: The Vanquishers
My usual thing for this series is to contrast the Chibnall era with something else, but as with the Survivors/Kroll post, I can’t really do that this time: in this case, the writers are too much alike. Chibnall, Bob Baker, and Dave Martin all attempt to make Doctor Who into Epic Television. The vast majority... Continue Reading →
Adventures in Narrative Substitution: Survivors of the Flux
The thing that happens when you decide to swap one season story arc for another is that eventually, you end up comparing two stories that are both kind of shit. Graham Williams hated it, Robert Holmes himself hated it, Mary Tamm hated it, everyone hated it except the viewing public of 1978, who gave it... Continue Reading →
Adventures in Narrative Substitution: Village of the Angels
Village of the Angels broke me. You’ll recall in my post on Ranskoor that I compared watching the Chibnall era to the experience of watching Z-grade movies on Mystery Science Theater 3000: most of the time I can handle the badness so long as I have some good quips or observations to make, as the... Continue Reading →
Adventures in Narrative Substitution: Once, Upon Time
Once Upon Time, I will admit, is a very difficult episode to write about, especially in the template I’ve established for this series. In an episode involving lots and lots of jumping around between various disparate bits of Plot and flashback sequences, how on earth do you find a similar story to talk about, when... Continue Reading →
Adventures in Narrative Substitution: War of the Sontarans
One aspect of the Chibnall years that I haven’t remarked on yet is its lack of humor. Now admittedly, literally any other writer being appointed to replace Moffat would’ve been something of a come-down, given Moffat’s situation comedy background (EVERYONE GO AND WATCH PRESS GANG) leading him to infuse virtually every script he ever wrote... Continue Reading →
Adventures in Narrative Substitution: The Halloween Apocalypse
One of the things Chibnall decided was his job as showrunner of Doctor Who was to get the show to measure up alongside “prestige” Netflix dramas like Stranger Things or the various Kurtzman-era Star Treks. This led to changes in the show’s look, from a new aspect ratio (2:1, the same as the first season... Continue Reading →
Adventures in Narrative Substitution: The Division
In 1970, Doctor Who had changed. Black and white was out and color was in. Jon Pertwee replaced Patrick Troughton as the Doctor, and for once, he didn’t travel in time and space, but stuck around on Earth as a nominal employee of the United Nations Intelligence Taskforce, aka UNIT. All of a sudden, Doctor... Continue Reading →