So, The Giggle then. It’s not really a goodbye to the Tennant Doctor like The End of Time was - 14 was too short-lived of an incumbent to really have something like that. So rather than a goodbye and the usual bit of the old Doctor regenerating into the new, we get the bi-regeneration instead.... Continue Reading →
The RTD Rewind: Wild Blue Yonder
It would be easy, looking at the bare facts of casting and plot, to accuse RTD of pandering only to the people who last watched the show in 2008 when he was last in charge. Certainly, I’ve seen some rumblings on Twitter to this effect – RTD is perfectly happy to call back to his... Continue Reading →
The RTD Rewind: The Star Beast
Since I became a fan of the show in 2010, I have seen two big anniversaries: the 50th and the 60th. What’s interesting to me is how different the show’s fortunes are in 2023 than they were in 2013 – back then, the show was on top of the world, to the point that The... Continue Reading →
The RTD Rewind: The End of Time
Hard to believe that it’s been two years since I started this watch-through of the original Davies era. A lot’s changed since then: I used to live in Missouri, and I used to watch these on my days off from my retail job. Now, I live with my girlfriend in New York, and writing has,... Continue Reading →
The RTD Rewind: The Waters of Mars
At the end of The Giggle, the newly-born Fifteenth Doctor consoles the exhausted Fourteenth, and specifically says that he’s “running on fumes.” The only solution? The Doctor needs to stop fixing everything else, and start fixing himself. Physician, heal thyself indeed. Now broadly speaking, this is the in-universe way of taking stock of the last... Continue Reading →
The RTD Rewind: Planet of the Dead
As with The Next Doctor, one gets the impression that Planet of the Dead is best seen when looked at as part of the extended coda to series four that sets up the Tenth Doctor’s regeneration, and from there, comparing these three final specials to the trio that rounded out the 60th anniversary. Having discussed... Continue Reading →
The RTD Rewind: The Next Doctor
I imagine the central joke of this episode might’ve worked better in 2008, when David Tennant leaving the series was public knowledge, but the identity of the new Doctor wasn’t for another week or so. (I am, in fact, writing this on New Years Day 2024, fifteen years to the month since the Matt Smith... Continue Reading →
The RTD Rewind: Turn Left/The Stolen Earth/Journey’s End
“A cosmos without the Doctor scarcely bears thinking about,” said the Master in the show’s 20th anniversary story, The Five Doctors. 25 years later, we finally find out exactly what a universe without the Doctor would look like, and as one would expect, the results are extremely very not good. Without Donna taking the job... Continue Reading →
The RTD Rewind: Midnight
The scariest thing about Midnight isn’t the scenes where Sky steals the Doctor’s voice and almost gets him kicked out of the train car. It’s everything that happens before this moment - ignore Sky and the Doctor, focus on the rest of the cast and their reactions. They freak out about Sky repeating everyone and... Continue Reading →
The RTD Rewind: Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead
At long last! After 4 solid weeks of stories that ranged from mediocre to awful, Steven Moffat comes in with one of his all-time best stories, and given his high batting average, that’s really saying something. There are times, watching these older episodes, that I really wish I got to watch it on broadcast. Rose... Continue Reading →