It took a long time for me to like the Twelfth Doctor. And this episode is part of why. In fact, it’s one of the big reasons why. Clara Oswald might’ve adjusted pretty quickly in the gap between Deep Breath and Into the Dalek, but not Lena Mactíre. It took me a hell of a lot longer.
Here’s the thing: When series 8 started, I was still deep in mourning for the Eleventh Doctor. I was excited for the new season, and intrigued by all the trailers and teasers that came out for promotion, especially the little clips with 12 standing moodily in the console room while various objects counted down to his official debut.
But I still missed my Raggedy Man, and I wasn’t sure if I was going to keep watching if Matt Smith wasn’t the star anymore. And Twelve… Twelve didn’t exactly do me any favors.
Like, look at what he does in Deep Breath. He and Clara have the robots bearing down on them and the Doctor abandons Clara with the sonic, leaving her no means to defend or protect herself except her own wits and cleverness. Obviously, now, I know why he did what he did (Clara can take care of herself, she doesn’t need him to pull her ass out of danger) but in the moment, watching it for the first time, I felt as betrayed as Jenna Coleman looked.
In the episodes that follow, he’s rude, crude, and generally a jackass to absolutely everyone he comes into contact with – not unlike Hugh Laurie’s turn as Gregory House on… well, House. Or, more appropriately for Capaldi, Malcolm Tucker in The Thick of It. He just wasn’t all that likable to me, and I kept waiting for “the real Doctor” to show up.
This episode, as I said earlier, is a big part of why I didn’t like 12 early on. This script might be a co-write with Steven Moffat, and certainly there are lines in here that sound like him, but so much of how the Doctor is written here just comes off, to me, as Gareth Roberts putting himself into the Doctor.
By now, Roberts’ general awfulness is well known. He’s racist, a bully, a transphobe, and pretty much every other conceivable stereotype about right-wing people who work in media. And after this episode aired, he was basically blackballed from the franchise generally.
And why? For the same reason the Harry Potter franchise went from being a beloved cultural phenomenon to a great big collective albatross around the neck of everyone involved with it – Twitter transphobia.
Quoting from TARDIS Wiki: “In September 2017, Roberts posted a tweet on his Twitter account that gained some media attention for being trans-misogynistic. In early May 2019, BBC Books released details about an upcoming Doctor Who anthology that would include a short story by Roberts; a month later, Roberts announced in an article that his story would not be included in the anthology after other contributing writers threatened to withdraw from the publication due to Roberts’ tweets.”
His name has not been heard with any connection to the show or the franchise since. And I can’t say I miss him. Sure, his novelization of Shada was really annoyingly good, but that’s not really saying much because he was working pretty heavily off of what Douglas Adams had already done in 1979.
Episodes like The Caretaker, and The Shakespeare Code before that, are when you get to see the real Roberts – a right-wing hack who couldn’t help but turn the Doctor into a bully when confronted by a Black man. Sure, there’s precedent for it with Mickey, but Mickey’s race was never 9’s issue with him, whereas it is absolutely a part of 12’s issues with Danny.
He routinely fails to internalize that a Black man can teach math, preferring instead to believe that he’s a PE teacher because, I guess, Black people are just automatically better at physical activities than whites are. He whistles a line from “Another Brick in the Wall” by Pink Floyd, presumably “We don’t need no education.” Not just making fun of Danny’s last name, but also his civilian career choice.
But the Pink Floyd reference hits differently now, in 2024, than it could have in 2014, for much the same reasons his references to Harry Potter in The Shakespeare Code are so stomach-churning in a way they weren’t in 2007. In 2014, Waters was just a guy trying to use the fame and influence granted to him by Pink Floyd for good causes.
But in 2024, he’s turned into a man who is on the Russian side of the ongoing war in Ukraine. He endorsed Nicolás Maduro, an actual freaking dictator, for president in this year’s election there. (Maduro proceeded to “win,” in much the same way Vladimir Putin always “wins” Russia’s elections.)
I don’t know what Roberts’ views on recent world affairs are, but I don’t really care, either. Because the kinds of pop culture references you choose to make in your creative work, in my opinion, speak volumes about who you are as a person. And it would not surprise me to learn that Roberts has followed in lockstep with Waters when it comes to global politics.
In the end, what Gareth Roberts was is a bully. He wrote 12 like a bully. And while it’s natural that we all put a little of ourselves into the characters we write, sometimes, we can go a little too far.
It’s really not until Flatline that I started to warm up to 12. (Which is ironic, considering he spends most of that episode snarking at Clara and being the same general variety of asshole that he usually is.) It was only when he got to “The man that stops the monsters” that I really started to like him, and by the time we get to the start of series 9, where he loosens up considerably, he’s a much better character. Now, he’s one of my favorite Doctors.
But none of that is because of Gareth Roberts. Only in spite of him.
Leave a Reply