I’m writing this on April 9th, 2024, exactly 54 years since the Beatles’ breakup was officially announced. The announcement, a self interview conducted by Paul McCartney, was sent to various UK journalists alongside advance copies of his eponymous debut solo album, in which he wrote:
Q: Did you miss the other Beatles and George Martin? Was there a moment when you thought, ‘I wish Ringo were here for this break?’
A: No.Q: Are you planning a new album or single with the Beatles?
A: No.Q: Is this album a rest away from the Beatles or the start of a solo career?
A: Time will tell. Being a solo album means it’s “the start of a solo career…” and not being done with the Beatles means it’s just a rest. So it’s both.Q: Is your break with the Beatles temporary or permanent, due to personal differences or musical ones?
A: Personal differences, business differences, musical differences, but most of all because I have a better time with my family. Temporary or permanent? I don’t really know.Q: Do you foresee a time when Lennon-McCartney becomes an active songwriting partnership again?
A: No.
This was news to pretty much everyone, especially the other three Beatles. Though John had privately left the group shortly after Abbey Road came out, this was the first public announcement that the band was dead.
The aftermath led to Paul being forced to sue his ex-bandmates in order to get the band legally dissolved, and that took so long to happen that the band wasn’t legally broken up until 1975, leading to the band members venting their various frustrations in their solo work. (Except Ringo, who just wanted everyone to calm down.)
Cut to 2011. The actor Ethan Hawke presented his daughter Maya (who you’ve seen in Stranger Things) with a personalized compilation album centered around the band’s solo work, with personalized liner notes regarding his divorce from Maya’s mother, Uma Thurman. It was called the Black Album, a twist on the informal name for the band’s 1968 release, the White Album.
The Black Album later popped up in the movie Boyhood, where Hawke’s character presents it to his son Mason as a birthday gift. The tracklist, and liner notes, were later released on Buzzfeed. In the notes, Hawke writes:
The dynamic of their breakup, like any divorce, is mysterious. Some say that Paul, the pupil, had surpassed John, the mentor, and they couldn’t reach a new balance. Some say Paul was a little snot who bought the publishing rights out from underneath the other three. Others say without Brian Epstein there was no mediator between their egos. Who knows.
With the BLACK ALBUM, we get to hear the boys write on adult life: marriage, fatherhood, sobriety, spiritual yearning, the emptiness of material success — “Starting Over,” “Maybe I’m Amazed,” “Beautiful Boy,” “The No No Song,” “God” — and still they are keenly aware of this fact: Love does not last.
Once when John was asked whether he would ever play with Paul again, he answered: “It would always be about, ‘Play what?’ It’s about the music. We play well together — if he had an idea and needed me, I’d be interested.”
I love that.
Maybe the lesson is: Love doesn’t last, but the music love creates just might.
Which is, I think, a very accurate summation of everything the band was about, and why they are still so beloved, all these years later. For crying out loud, Beyonce released a cover of “Blackbird” on her most recent record – you can’t tell me these men, and the music they created together, aren’t relevant to today’s world. If anything, we need them more than ever.
As a compilation, the Black Album functions as an excellent introduction to the band’s solo work – a catalog that is, if you take in the efforts of all four of them, very big, several times bigger than the Beatles catalogue. (And in the cases of Paul and Ringo, it’s getting bigger all the time.)
Hawke has done his best to try and replicate the band as well as he can, and present the Black Album as something the Beatles might have made themselves. This is reflected in the number of tracks: John and Paul have the majority (19 and 20 songs respectively) while George has 7 and Ringo 4, mirroring the White Album, while most of the music dates from the 1970s, so it even sounds like a Beatles release. While there have been plenty of imaginary 1970s Beatles albums out there, this is the one that I think best presents the concept, and it’s not even trying to be a hypothetical 70s album.
So, if we’re going to tackle the mountain that is the Beatles’ solo work, this seems like a pretty good place to start, since we get a flavor of what all of their careers were like.
Let’s dive in, shall we?
Disc 1
Band on the Run: Just as he had on Please Please Me, Paul has the honor of starting us off, this time with the title song from his 1973 smash hit with Wings, his second band. Recorded with just himself, Linda, and Denny Laine, the song is a triptych, with three sections that sound completely different from each other… not unlike the medley that goes through half of Abbey Road, actually.
My Sweet Lord: The second track from George’s landmark triple album from 1970, All Things Must Pass. Freed from the constraints of sharing album space with John and Paul, he’s finally able to soar, and that shows in how his guitar sounds here – like he’s flying away from the pain and strife of the Beatle years. Lyrically, this is his first big engagement with his faith since 1968, and the first time he’s invoked God by name ever. (As opposed to implication, like in “Long, Long, Long.”) And I gotta say, that hits real differently now that I am a practicing Wiccan. (More on this when we get to the album.)
Jealous Guy: As mentioned in the Esher Demos post, this song began life as “Child of Nature,” when John was high on learning transcendental meditation in India. He set new lyrics to the tune from 1968, resulting in this piano-based confessional from 1971’s Imagine. I must’ve been about 12 or so when I first heard it, and the sheer vulnerability of it hit me like a freight train. (And it still does!) The last decade of John’s life was one where he tried to make amends from all the pain and awfulness of his youth, and this song is part of that process.
Photograph: A collaborating between Ringo and George, this song was and is one Ringo’s big hits, but for me, I’ll always associate it with when he sang it in 2002, during the Concert for George performance. It’s beautiful, if tear-jerking.
How?: Staying with the theme of John being confessional on a piano, this song finds him trying to figure out whether, or if, he’s capable of love given all the difficulties he’s experienced over the course of his life. The chorus (“You know life can be long”) inject a bit of optimism into the lyrics, suggesting he might have come up with a solution.
Every Night: Paul returns with a comparatively cheerful song about the absolutely debilitating depression he experienced after the Beatles broke up, complete with a sly musical reference to “You Never Give Me Your Money” from Abbey Road. It’s not all bad though – he repeatedly expresses to Linda how much he just wants to stay in and be with her, a sentiment that I absolutely get, now that I’m living with my fiancee.
Blow Away: Coming from the other side of the 1970s, this song was released George’s 1979 eponymous release, recorded during a period of time where everything was going right for him. He sounds as optimistic as he ever has, perhaps presaging similar feelings that his bandmate John Lennon was going through at around the same time.
Maybe I’m Amazed: Released on the first McCartney album, “Maybe I’m Amazed” is one of Paul’s most powerful love songs, which is no small feat considering how many of them he’s written over the years. In one of the darkest periods of his life, he had a shining light in the form of Linda, and his love for her shines through every note. He even brings back his “Oh! Darling” vocal stylings back!
Woman: Described by the writer as a grown-up version of “Girl” from Rubber Soul, down to the title, “Woman” is nothing less than a joyful exclamation of love and appreciation for, as he calls us, “the other half of the sky.” It’s a song that exemplifies how refreshed and happy he was feeling in 1980, entering his 40s, ready to take on the world.
Jet: After meditations on heartbreak and new love, here comes Paul with a good-old fashioned early 1970s rock song, named for his and Linda’s Labrador Retriever. Exactly what the song is about has never been made entirely clear. But who cares?! It’s Paul rocking out again in the way that only he can do! This is one you want to play as loudly as possible!
Stand By Me: Released on Rock ’n’ Roll, John’s album of covers of the songs he loved as a kid, this was his last hit song before he retired from music in 1975 to raise Sean Lennon. The original album version has slapback echo on his vocal – the Ultimate Mix from 2020 presents it unadorned. Whichever you way you slice it, the sheer emotion in his singing is always exhilarating.
No No Song: A simple song by Ringo in which he is offered, and refuses, to try various drugs – not because he’s a victim of the DARE program, but because he lived through the drug-saturated Sixties and he wants to get clean. Good for him!
Junk: As mentioned in the Esher Demo and Anthology 3 posts, this song of Paul’s has been hanging around since the late 1960s, and it still isn’t particularly great. It appears twice on McCartney – first with vocals, then instrumental.
Love: One of the rare upbeat songs on Plastic Ono Band, this is one of John’s loveliest ballads, the close-miked vocals, acoustic guitar, and Phil Spector’s gentle piano give it an almost lullaby-like quality – which might explain why Kenny Loggins did a version of it on his album Return to Pooh Corner, which I listened to obsessively as a kid.
The Back Seat of My Car: Paul has always been the Beatle most likely to write a car song, or even songs just inspired by traveling to other places. (Given how much he loves touring, I am not remotely surprised.) This track is another of his late-60s/early-70s car songs, in the vein of “Two of Us” and “Helen Wheels,” but with sexual entendre that harkens back to, surprise surprise, “Drive My Car” from Rubber Soul, filtered through a more grown-up sensibility.
Watching the Wheels: Staying with the vehicular-adjacent theme, here’s one of my favorite late-period John songs, describing his contentment with just letting life go by rather than chasing the next big fad or capitalizing on his existing fame. For me, this is the grown-up version of “I’m Only Sleeping” from Revolver, only from a healthier perspective than the drug-induced stupor he was in during 1966.
Mind Games: The title song from his under-appreciated release, Mind Games came out at the beginning of John’s 18 month separation from Yoko. The title track, though, is just the latest in an entire sequence of “Power of love” songs of his that go all the way back to “The Word” from Rubber Soul, filtered through the mysticism that runs through the early 1970s. John specifically mentions druidry and magic here, nodding toward neo-paganism and other non-Abrahamic religious traditions. If you read Drawing Down the Moon, you will never look at Lennon’s lyrics in quite the same way again. The whole song gives me big pagan vibes, as I’ll talk about when we get to the album.
Bluebird: Paul’s second-ever bird related song, this is absolutely a spiritual successor to “Blackbird” from 1968, since it deals with similar themes – true freedom, and flight as a way to accomplish it. The main difference is context: “Blackbird” was about the civil rights movement and the plight of Black America, whereas in “Bluebird,” freedom comes from love and sharing in it with others.
Beautiful Boy (Darling Boy): John’s touching ballad to his son Sean, dating from 1980. It’s an absolutely gorgeous song, and the imagery and instrumentation carries echoes of John’s restorative visit to Bermuda in 1980, a trip which re-awakened his musical muse. (It’s also Paul’s favorite solo Lennon song, per a 1982 appearance on Desert Island Discs.)
What Is Life: As on Beatles For Sale, here comes George with the closing song on disc 1, from All Things Must Pass. It wears its Motown influence on his sleeve, directly inspired by the descending guitar riff that begins the track. While it is a love song, there is a matter of debate as to whether the object of his affections is a girl or a deity. (Personally, I think it’s a girl, but given the religious overtones of the source album, I can see an argument for the other reading.)
Disc 2
God: A song from John’s Plastic Ono Band, in which he comprehensively rejects everything from magic to tarot, the Bible, Jesus, Buddha, Bob Dylan, and of course, the Beatles. (The way he spits out his former band’s name as if it were an insult remains attention-grabbing.) When I heard this song for the first time as a teenager, I felt its views on God more or less matched my own. In other words, this song was my theme song during my atheist era, though it no longer is. We’ll never know what John would’ve made of neopaganism, but I’d like to think he’d be interested in it, at least as an intellectual curiosity.
Listen to What the Man Said: On the complete opposite side of the emotional scale comes Paul with this song, from 1975’s Venus and Mars. Exactly who “The Man” is has never been clarified, though given the content of the lyrics, one could read it as “The Man” being God. Which, if nothing else, would make for an interesting contrast with the previous song.
Crippled Inside: In which John indulges in some good old fashioned country rock, featuring George Harrison playing dobro… and according to the lyrics, I think it’s about mental illness? Which is certainly pretty huge for the early 1970s. (Not to mention relatable.)
You’re Sixteen You’re Beautiful (And You’re Mine): Ringo covers a song from the American Graffiti soundtrack, a movie that was directed by George Lucas in his pre-Star Wars era. The lyrics were written by the Sherman Brothers, whom you know from movies like Mary Poppins, Bedknobs and Broomsticks, and The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh. So, with such talent behind it, to say nothing of Ringo’s vocal work, I still have to wonder… WHO THE FUCK THOUGHT WRITING A SONG ABOUT SEXUALIZING A TEENAGER WAS A GOOD IDEA?! GODDESS OF THE SILVER MOON, WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU PEOPLE?!
Let Me Roll It: There are love songs, and then there are love songs by Sir James Paul freaking McCartney. No one, and I mean no one, can write them like he can. This is one of his best by far, and it’s been a staple of mine and Sophie’s joint playlist since we got together. And best of all? If you squint you can take it as Paul expressing his love for John, years after their musical argument in 1971.
Power to the People: A non-album single of John’s from 1971, when he was at his most intensely political – in this case, he shows off his development as a feminist during verse three, and a commitment to the working class heroes of the world in verse two. But what I like is the opening two lines, where he repeats the first line of his song “Revolution,” and then follows it up with a desire to get things moving, rather than the more cautious approach he took in 1968.
Another Day: In which Paul writes an observational song about a lonely woman and her miserable existence… and not for the first time! What we have here is basically “Eleanor Rigby” for the 1970s, focused this time on the doldrum daily routine of an unnamed woman. Going by the lyrics, it sure sounds like she suffers from depression, with a dash of suicidality as well. (Her boyfriend is no help either.) Heavy shit indeed, but that’s just part of how Paul operates. For every “Silly love song,” there’s something like this that really makes you think.
If Not for You: In which George Harrison covers Bob Dylan. Dylan and Harrison had a friendship that went all the way back to 1964, when he introduced the Beatles to marijuana during their first American tour. In 1968 and ’69, Bob and George started hanging out together, resulting in the two of them collaborating on the song “I’d Have You Any Time,” the opening track on All Things Must Pass.
(Just Like) Starting Over: The lead-off song from Double Fantasy opens with chiming bells – a deliberate reference to the funeral bells at the start of “Mother,” the opening song from Plastic Ono Band. This is a song that exemplifies John’s development as a musician and a human being throughout the 1970s, and as we all know, he was really looking forward to the 1980s. My most enduring memory of the song, though, will be when I first heard it: my dad’s very scratched up copy of the Lennon Legend compilation from 1997, where it skipped a lot during his vocalizations heading into the fade-out. I had no idea that wasn’t part of the song! Even today, I still expect the skips!
Let ‘em In: While the lyrics are nothing to get too excited about, the melody they are sung to is absolutely fantastic, and the snare drum gives the track an almost military vibe.
Mother: The inverse of (Just Like) Starting Over, as noted above. If you’re coming to this song after his Beatles work, it’s nothing less than an angry, much-deserved howl of frustration, as he finally lets loose with all the accumulated 30 years of rage at how both of his parents abandoned him. Thank goodness Ringo is there to provide support, both at the drum kit and emotionally. The remixed version of Plastic Ono Band includes a version of the song that is just John’s raw vocal, and it is simply the most haunting thing I’ve ever heard.
Helen Wheels: Breaking the tension is Paul, back again with another of his car songs, named for the Land Rover that he and Linda used to drive around Scotland and down to London – the route they took is described in the lyrics. Also listen for some throwbacks to “Band on the Run.”
I Found Out: Nobody did pure scathing fury quite like John Lennon, and this song is a perfect example of that mode. Per Wikipedia, “The song expresses Lennon’s disillusionment with a world dominated by what he saw as false religion and idols, and warns against being taken in by such beliefs.” (And a not-very-subtle jab at Paul, well ahead from the 1970s diss track that is “How Do You Sleep.”
Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey: A series of song fragments strung together like a miniature version of the Abbey Road medley, and like that medley, it’s absolutely fucking brilliant – Paul’s gift for melody fused with John’s technical ambition and silliness, and combined with Paul’s whole-hearted love for Linda. (The “hands across the water” section, according to Paul, is about the two of them and their respective nationalities.)
Instant Karma!: This one has always been one of my favorite solo-Lennon songs, it was even my ringtone for years when I was in high school. Per Wikipedia, “focus on a concept in which the consequences of one’s actions are immediate rather than borne out over a lifetime,” and I have to say, I understand this concept way better now as a practicing Wiccan – look up the Threefold Law for more information. This track has also been covered by Duran Duran, and they did a fabulous job with it.
Not Guilty: As I mentioned back in the post on the Esher Demos, this track by George was first written in 1968, around the time of the White Album sessions. Their version didn’t see release until 1996, when it appeared on Anthology 3, but the full version only came out in 2018 on the super deluxe White Album set. This version of the song, from George’s 1979 eponymous album, exchanges the hard rock of the original late-Sixties version for something more laid back and jazzy, serving as a contrast to the harsh, biting lyrics.
Heart of the Country: By the early 1970s, Paul had swapped the hustle and bustle of London for the Scottish countryside, eager to escape the hell that was the rapidly-disintegrating Beatles. Paul in a mellow mood is always enjoyable, and this song is no exception.
Oh Yoko!: Proving beyond a doubt that John can do joyful exclamations of love for his wife just as well as Paul can, he comes up with this, the closing track from Imagine. It’s absolutely delightful, with little nods toward his Beatles days – “My love will turn you on” evokes “A Day in the Life,” while the harmonica toward the end echoes his songs from 1962 and ’63, when they were first starting out.
Mull of Kintyre: A gorgeous tribute to the area of Scotland where Paul has owned High Park Farm since 1966, and by some distance, Wings’ biggest hit as a band. It was one of the best selling singles of all time in the UK, where it became the 1977 Christmas number one. When it was released, it sold more copies than “She Loves You” had in 1963. And while I’m Irish, not Scottish, even I know a beautiful song when I hear it.
It Don’t Come Easy: Speaking of big hits, this one is most definitely Ringo’s, written in 1968 or so with an assist from George, who also produced the final recording. It’s his most autobiographical song – the title alone can refer to a number of things, be it his well-known difficulties with songwriting, or his desire to establish himself as something other than the Beatles’ drummer. (As an aside, one line of the lyrics was used by my old pal Longhaul to title one of our MLP fics. I’ll always think of him when I hear it. 🙂 )
Disc 3
Grow Old With Me: One of John’s final recordings, the song is a beautiful, touching love song to Yoko, recorded in November 1980 at The Dakota. The mix I’m listening to is based on the version from 1998’s John Lennon Anthology, with a string arrangement by George Martin, and bass guitar by Giles Martin. John and Yoko hoped this song would be played at weddings – I think it’s a pretty safe bet I’m playing it at mine.
Silly Love Songs: Paul returns with a rebuttal to music critics who didn’t like that he mainly wrote happy, poppy love songs. Given this was the 1970s and Paul was widely viewed as the villain in the story of the Beatles’ breakup, I kind of feel like that might’ve had something to do with how he was critically received. After all, no one complained about a profusion of love songs when John, George, and Ringo were there.
Real Love: Taken from Anthology 2, “Real Love” (as noted before) was one of John’s Dakota piano demos, and got finished up by the other three in the 1990s. But in the context of the Black Album, on a disc filled with love songs, it fits perfectly – it’s a message of hope, something the Beatles were always good at. And further, “Real Love” demonstrates why the solo years were necessary, and are a key part of understanding these men and the music they made: their reunion would not have been possible without time apart.
My Love: A love song from Paul to Linda, in the style of “The Long and Winding Road,” down to Paul trying to do a Ray Charles voice. (But with electric piano, because this is the 1970s.) For me it sounds like an attempt to write “Something,” and not entirely succeeding. But it’s a Linda tribute song now, so I can’t really complain.
Oh My Love: One of the amazing things about John Lennon was how he was able to use that voice of his. He could do hard rock, and then turn on a dime to a touching love ballad. His performance on “Oh My Love” has the same vibe as “Julia,” and it’s gorgeous.
Give Me Love (Give Me Peace on Earth): All Things Must Pass and its followup, Living in the Material World, are both George’s gospel albums. He wrote in his autobiography, “This song is a prayer and personal statement between me, the Lord, and whoever likes it.” And it’s something I can relate to far more strongly now as I’ve developed as a Wiccan. My deities may be very different from George’s, but in the end, we’re both yearning for the same thing – connection.
Pipes of Peace: In which Paul enters the 1980s with a heartfelt desire for peace in the world, with a focus on ecology and not destroying the only planet we’ve got. I only wish we’d listened.
Imagine: The Big One. Ask anyone to picture John’s solo years, and this, understandably, is the first one they’ll name. Some have called it an atheist anthem, and others see it as what it is – a plea for world peace at a time where it seemed like the entire world was burning down. While its message has been derided over the years as being hypocritical, I feel like people who say things like that are missing the point. He can make these statements because he had been a Beatle. There’s no bigger platform than that, and no better legacy than this.
Here Today: Paul’s touching tribute to John Lennon, produced by George Martin. It’s very much the 1980s version of “Yesterday,” except directed toward his best friend in the entire world, so cruelly taken from him (and us) by an assassin’s bullet. I’ve heard him play it live, and yes, he cried. But then, wouldn’t you?
All Things Must Pass: As everyone knows by now, George started writing this song in 1969 during the making of Get Back/Let It Be, hoping to find space for it on a Beatles album… and John and Paul said no. So, George used it as the title song for his first post-breakup album, and completely blew the other two away with it. In 2002, Paul performed this song as part of the Concert for George live show, and he did a beautiful job of it.
And I Love Her: The only other Beatle song on the entire album, taken here from Paul’s performance on MTV’s Unplugged. This version is much slower than the original from 1964, and all the more beautiful for it. Paul’s voice really did age like a fine wine, and this song is a wonderful example of it.
Despite being labeled as a break-up album, and conceptualized as a mixtape for a divorce, what Ethan Hawke has managed to do with The Black Album isn’t just create a cohesive tripe album that sounds like something the Beatles might have made together, or a perfect introduction to their solo work. He’s done both of those things, and managed to summarize exactly what it is about this band that no one, and I mean no one, can match.
For all that his original message in the liner notes was, “Love does not last,” I think there’s a corollary to that. And that is, “Love can come again.” Yes, there will be trouble and strife, but the entire album (particularly disc 3) communicates the message that no matter what happens, while specific forms of love might dwindle, it can always blossom and take a new shape.
“It sounds like them,” said Ringo in the 1990s, when he, Paul, and George listened to the final mixes of “Free As a Bird” and “Real Love.” George replied, “It sounds like them because it is them.” And that’s what we have here – John Paul George and Ringo, physically working apart, but very much together in spirit.
Just as it should be.
Leave a Reply