Having pretty successfully covered the capitalist angle on the story in the AINS post on Kerblam!, I’m going to do what I did with Thin Ice and try to find an alternate angle on this story that isn’t just ranting about the capitalist death drive for the next three pages.
Though to be fair, the death drive is real and the problems have only gotten worse, if possible, since 2017. And they will likely keep getting worse, because we elected Trump again, all but ensuring the eventual end of life on Earth.
On the other paw, who knows? Trump’s second presidency may well be the one that, in 38 years, lead to the Vulcans landing in Bozeman, Montana. Sure, we’ll have to go through World War III first, but Trump and the latest incarnation of his DC Wrecking Crew seem to have baked that into their plans for this term already.
But back to Oxygen. I’ve always kind of liked the Doctor’s little monologue at the beginning, pessimistic though it is, because it begins with four wonderful little words: “Space… The final frontier.”
Yes, good people, that was a Star Trek reference. And since I’m running out of time (and space) to write about the cosmic dance these two franchises have been sharing with each other, I might as well write it now. This has nothing really to do with Oxygen, though I will say that if there’s anyone in the Star Trek universe who would come up with something like oxygen credits, it’d be the Ferengi and we all know it.
Star Trek and Doctor Who have each been around a very long time, nearly as long as each other. The original series, begun in 1966, started airing on NBC the same week as the second-to-last Hartnell story, The Smugglers, and continued on until June 1969, where it wrapped up with “Turnabout Intruder,” which aired the same week as episode 8 of The War Games.
The Animated Series slightly overlaps with late-period Pertwee, while The Motion Picture and the rest of the TOS movies up to Voyage Home coincide with late Tom Baker, Peter Davison, and Colin Baker, while The Next Generation overlaps nicely with the Sylvester McCoy years on TV, while the Virgin New Adventures line of novels begins the same month as the last few episodes of TNG’s fourth season.
The VNAs then overlap with the rest of TNG, and wrap late in DS9’s fifth season and Voyager’s third. The mantle is then taken up by Big Finish, who start publishing their monthly range during VOY’s sixth and seventh seasons, and which then overlap with the entirety of Enterprise, which in turn overlaps with Christopher Eccleston’s first few episodes as the Ninth Doctor.
The Kelvin movies sync up with late Tennant, late Smith, and late Capaldi respectively, while the various Paramount+ Star Trek shows sync up with Whittaker and Gatwa. In fact, the only Doctor not to have a Star Trek project air during his era is the Fourteenth Doctor, because his era was exactly three full episodes, a comedy sketch, and a comic book. Go figure.
That said, the worlds of Doctor Who and Star Trek are at least orbiting more closely together now than they ever have before, what with the line “We should visit them sometime” in Space Babies and the joint “Friendship is Universal” panel at SDCC in 2024, during which we learned (among other things) that RTD and I have the same favorite episode: TNG’s “Yesterday’s Enterprise.”
Interestingly, there almost was a televised crossover between Doctor Who and Star Trek. Sometime in 2005, according to RTD himself, he had the idea to land the Tenth Doctor and Rose on the bridge of Archer’s Enterprise… and then ENT got canceled after four seasons by UPN, putting an end to that particular fan dream.
Aside from the existence of the Assimilation2 miniseries from IDW Comics, Doctor Who and Star Trek have never actually crossed over outside of the graphic novel world. There have been Doctor Who stories that nod in the direction of Star Trek, and even more that do direct shout-outs, but that and an overlapped transmission history are about as good as it ever gets.
However, thanks to the aforementioned shoutouts in the new RTD era, and Star Trek continuing to hum along as a streaming television franchise, I have new hopes for a crossover. While we’ve sadly missed the boat on having the Fifteenth Doctor share the screen with Michael Burnham, I can very easily imagine a Strange New Worlds version of that old ENT pitch coming to life, either as an episode or as a TV movie, like with Star Trek: Section 31.
So while we’re on the subject, let’s consider what a crossover might actually entail. Putting aside the insane corporate madness that would ensue in combining a Paramount IP with a Disney one, let’s look at these two franchises somewhat more holistically.
What unites them both, as the “Friendship is Universal” trailer makes abundantly clear, is that these two franchises share a love of friendship, togetherness, and love. Look at, for example, a time-displaced Captain Picard going back to the Farpoint mission in “All Good Things” and saying of his untested crew, “I know you have your doubts about me, about each other, about the ship. All I can say is that although we have only been together for a short time, I know that you are the finest crew in the fleet and I would trust each of you with my life.”
Or there’s the Eleventh Doctor’s words to Amy in The Power of Three: “Because you were the first. The first face this face saw. And you’re seared onto my hearts, Amelia Pond. You always will be. I’m running to you, and Rory, before you fade from me.”
This is what drives these shows, and their fandoms, together. And it’s why I love them both. Doctor Who helped spark my creativity, and made me realize that yes, I could write for a living! It didn’t have to be a fanciful dream anymore! And Star Trek has picked up where Who left off, giving me a whole new universe of adventures to write blogs about. (I will get back to Wolf Trek. Eventually.)
And while I’m on the subject, the Prime Directive, whether it’s the Starfleet one or the Time Lord one mentioned in The Beast Below, exists to be broken. At least Doctor Who straight up admits it, whereas Star Trek agonizes over it for 40 minutes and then decides to break it anyway, in the name of the greater good. The Prime Directive just sucks, no matter which universe you’re in.
Anyway. Here’s to Doctor Who and Star Trek! Maybe, someday, we will see them on screen together.
Leave a Reply