Equestria Forever: May the Best Pet Win/Mysterious Mare Do Well

Rainbow Dash, if I’m being honest, has never been my favorite of the main six. She’s a bit too egotistical for my liking, though I understand now why she’s like that – you would be too if you had parents who cheered you on as if even the mundanities of life were the Super Bowl and you were Tom Brady, back when he was still QB of the Patriots instead of a national embarrassment.

But I digress. Rainbow is a very easy character to write badly, and a very hard character to write well. She’s egotistical, selfish, and inconsiderate of others, which can get her into trouble more often than not. Both of this week’s episodes spend a lot of time trying to humble her, but they go about it in very different directions. (And if you ask me, one of those attempts is far more successful than the other.)

“May the Best Pet Win” is primarily a story where Dash realizes she’s the only one out of her friend group not to have a pet of her own, so she approaches Fluttershy for help on finding one, focusing specifically on animals who can fly, appeal to Dash’s particular aesthetic, and most importantly are just as fast as she is.

Rainbow’s initial conception of what kind of pet would work best for her makes complete sense, given that she spends much of her time flying and wants to join the Wonderbolts someday. She needs a training partner of sorts, to help her get into shape when it comes time for her to join the elite squad. And Fluttershy, to her credit, is quick to grasp what she needs, after a few false starts.

There’s some measure of irony in Rainbow spending much of the race scenes dismissing the performance of the tortoise, only for him to become the pet for her, but again, I get why she does it: at first glance, the tortoise is the least appropriate possibility out there. But when the avalanche happens and she’s pinned by rocks, of course it’s the tortoise who rescues her.

Looked at another way, this episode illustrates the differences between what Rainbow wants (a pet that looks cool, can keep up with her, and enhance her own image) and what she needs – companionship and, of course, loyalty, which only Tank shows in abundance. As she says at the end, “Today I learned what the most important quality really is: a certain kind of spirit, a sticktoitiveness. A never-give-up, can-do attitude that’s the mark of a real winner!”

But let’s be real – it was always going to be the tortoise. He got all the closeups during that musical number, for crying out loud!

All that said, “May the Best Pet Win!” is a wonderful Rainbow Dash episode. While her recurring tendency to value surface level traits over deeper things does bother me, Tank’s example does do a good job of getting her to see that there are some things that are more important than speed and power. It’s an episode that humbles her without making her out to be a bad pony, which is more than I can say for the next episode under discussion.

“The Mysterious Mare-Do-Well” has gotten under my fur for fifteen freaking years, ever since it first aired in November 2011. I understand that the idea was to do a character critique for Rainbow, which isn’t a bad idea in and of itself, the problem is that the episode, as aired, more or less amounted to less of a critique and more of a character assassination.

“Mare Do Well,” in multiple directions, is basically an inversion of last season’s “Boast Busters.” “Mare Do Well” wants us to believe that Rainbow is the equivalent of Trixie in the latter: an egotistical showmare who is focused more on puffing herself up, regardless of the dangers that her showmareship puts other ponies into. 

But the thing is, she’s not! While it is true that Dash can get carried away (like giving herself a catchphrase) she still performs some acts of genuine heroism in this episode, even if some of them (like helping Granny Smith across the street) are less warranted than others. Trixie, meanwhile, remains a jerk until the last third of the series, when she’s paired up with Starlight Glimmer and acquires unexpected depth.

The actions of the mane cast (minus Rarity) may have been well-intentioned, but in my view they were completely unnecessary. Creating a fictional hero meant to show up Dash, while hyping her (read: themselves) at every opportunity only make the problem worse, because they are now collectively guilty of exactly what they’re accusing Dash of doing.

On top of all that, they completely wreck poor Rainbow’s self esteem. This is a pony whose self-image is largely built around the approval of others, and now here are HER BEST FRIENDS shredding that self-image in order to, allegedly, make a point about humility. There is such a thing as overkill here, girls. 

“Boast Busters” handled this all so much better. Obviously, the intended aesops are different (one is ‘it’s okay to be proud of your accomplishments,’ which was what Twilight was struggling with, and the other is ‘don’t be a braggart,’) but even so – if Twilight was able to show up Trixie without making a spectacle of herself, then surely she and the rest of the mains could’ve done the same here.

Season 3’s “Wonderbolts Academy” is kind of Rainbow’s version of “Boast Busters,” with the character of Lightning Dust serving as a foil and reflection of Rainbow, with Rainbow’s negative traits exaggerated to a significant degree. The difference between the two of them is exemplified by the climax where Lighting intentionally places multiple ponies in danger, something that Rainbow, even at her worst, would never do. 

Because that’s the thing about Rainbow. For all that she drives me completely crazy, her heart is always in the right place. She’s dependable to the last, no matter what, but “Mare Do Well” completely disregards that for the sake of plot. 

At least we have “May the Best Pet Win.”

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑