Equestria Forever: Sweet and Elite/Secret of My Excess

In some ways, “Sweet and Elite” is something of a sequel to “The Best Night Ever.” Both episodes are set primarily in Canterlot and feature members of the main cast interacting with Canterlot elites, but with drastically different outcomes than before. Recall that Rarity’s big dream was to spend the night with Prince Blueblood and be accepted by the ponies of Canterlot, which ended disastrously when Blueblood turned out to be a giant asshole.

This time around, Rarity does get to meet a Canterlot pony who turns out to be a true gentlecolt, but that doesn’t come without some some problems. As the MLP Wiki explains: “Rarity visits Canterlot and ends up making friends with several elite figures in the city. When her Ponyville friends decide to host a birthday celebration at the same time as an exclusive garden party, however, Rarity must decide which one to attend.” 

Not mentioned in the above summary is the item that serves as the focal point for Rarity’s misfortunes – Twilight’s birthday dress. Assigning herself the commission at the episode’s beginning, Rarity ends up spending so much time among the Canterlot elite that she forgets (or rather, procrastinates) on putting the thing together.

Now, I want to stipulate that Rarity doesn’t just blow off her work for the hell of it. On her first morning in Canterlot, she goes out to get materials for the dress, only to bump into Jet Set and Upper Crust: a husband and wife couple who probably win the award for Snootiest Equines This Side of Prince Blueblood. Rarity’s subsequent attempt at networking is then ruined when this happens:

Upper Crust: …Where did you get that simply marvelous chapeau?

Rarity: Oh, this old thing? Oh, it’s just something I—

Hayseed Turnip Truck: Rarity! Hey, Rarity! Whoo! It’s me, Hayseed Turnip Truck! We met at the big hoedown in Ponyville last fall?

Rarity: Oh, yes, of course… how are you?

Hayseed Turnip Truck: Good! Real good!

After this, Upper Crust and Jet Set change their attitudes and deride Rarity’s hat as looking “a little country,” and that is not meant as a compliment. Rarity, naturally, is incensed by this reaction and promptly decides to blow them out of the water with Twilight’s birthday dress – her pride, and likely PTSD from the whole Blueblood experience at the end of last season, won’t allow her to do otherwise.

But in the next scene, she gets invited to the Wonderbolts derby by somewhat ironically named Fancy Pants, (all around good guy and the kind of elite noblepony we really should’ve seen more of on the show) and… well, you know the rest. 

Rarity tries to act like she belongs, telling little white lies about Rainbow Dash and the Wonderbolts, and gets so wrapped up in this tangled web she’s weaved for herself that by the time we get to the garden party scenes, she’s forced to flit between the posh thing and Twilight’s birthday so often that eventually her friends eventually notice… and it all ends unexpectedly happily, when Twilight chalks all the running around to Rarity being such a savvy business pony.

How you read that bit is up to you, but personally I’m going with “Twilight is trying to help Rarity save face because she’s probably figured out what’s really going on,” with their subsequent boorish behavior as either a bit of petty revenge, or them just being agents of harmless chaos. 

Whatever it is, it worked! Rarity decides to stand with her friends rather than against them, with Fancy Pants adding that he finds them to be “charmingly rustic,” with the possible implication that he likely knows exactly who they are (he winks at Twilight when describing her as a ‘lovely young filly from Ponyville’) and is glad they came along, in all their madness – if so, he’d be filling Celestia’s narrative role from “The Best Night Ever.”

In the end, “Sweet and Elite” is, IMO, an excellent Rarity episode. While she doesn’t come across particularly well in it, she’s able to successfully redeem herself when it counts, and the connections she makes will go on to pay dividends later in the series, when she grows her business from Carousel Boutique to other shops throughout Equestria.

By happy coincidence, Rarity also features in the following episode, “Secret of My Excess.” Per the MLP wiki: “Spike lets his dragon greed get the best of him, which eventually causes him to grow to a monstrous size.” In this case, Spike’s crush on her is what eventually leads him to break free of his avarice-inspired mania, and at the very end of the episode, he almost confesses the truth to her… but it is implied she already knows.

I’ve always found the one-sided crush between Spike and Rarity to be quite sweet, so it’s a shame that this is the episode where it gets dealt with to one degree or another. Specifically it has him treat her as the crown jewel (so to speak) of his growing horde, which does make a certain amount of sense but it’s still not great to see. Because after all, this is a Spike episode.

At least in the early half of the series, Spike episodes had something of a reputation in fandom for being disasters, since most of them required Spike to be written drastically out of character in order for the plot to work. In “Owl’s Well That Ends Well” he spends much of the time jealous of Owlowiscious, and in this one HIS APPARENTLY BIOLOGICAL DRAGON GREED is triggered, leading to him stealing various objects and eventually, Rarity.

It’s that last point that really gets under my fur. In one scene, Twilight goes to speak with Zecora about what’s going on, and we learn this: “A dragon’s heart is prone to greed, a steady diet to make growth speed. Then, the resulting bigger size only makes their hunger rise. If this trait should go unchecked, if Spike continues to collect, more growth will certainly occur – he is going to turn into a monster.”

I’ve always hated the idea that certain aspects of a character that aren’t actually determined by genetics can be somehow. Back in the RTD Rewind post on Daleks in Manhattan, you may remember my little rant about Dalek DNA:

But it’s worth asking the question, what is it that makes a Dalek evil in the first place? Is it a matter of nature, or nurture? Evolution falls pretty hard on the “nature” side of the equation by introducing the concept of Dalek DNA. Daleks are evil because it’s all about the biology, and no matter what you do you can’t change someone’s biology. A Dalek is still a Dalek, even if they look human.

While “Secret of My Excess” isn’t nearly as bad as “Daleks in Manhattan,” it’s still far from a good episode of MLP. I’d even say it’s easily in the bottom-10 of Spike episodes, though the bar is in Tartarus here.

To the extent there is a plus side, it’s the top-notch dialogue, whether it’s Applejack’s flat “Twilight… get my rope,” when she realizes Spike has stolen her apples, or Pinkie’s glorious response to Twilight ordering her not to keep giving Spike cake: “I’m not giving him cake. I’m assulting him with cake!!”

The best line has to go to Rarity though, and it goes like this: “Oh, be quiet! You’ve got nothing to be proud of! Steal everypony’s things, terrorize the town, and use me as a weapon against my own friends! Which, as horrible as it is, I can almost understand because you’re a dragon and all, but THIS! [tears off ruined cape] THIS IS A CRIME AGAINST FASHION!”

And this is proof that even the worst episodes can have good qualities. Diamonds in the rough, you might say.

Next week, who’s up for some world building?

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑