Equestria Forever: A Canterlot Wedding

My memories of this episode will be forever bound up in what was going on in my life at the time it aired. I was a junior in high school, taking an environmental science class, and the guy who sat next to me was the only person I ever met who also Liked The Show, so we’d talk about it a lot during work time.

As I recall, the week the episodes aired we were in one of the main hallways doing some kind of big class project or other, and since there was a lot of noise from a bunch of chattering high schoolers that meant we could talk about anything we wanted, so of course Ponies were discussed.

When I went home to watch the episodes, I used to watch them on my iPod touch, (because I didn’t have a smartphone then) but the week these ones aired, I’d gotten my very first Mac. (I think on that Tuesday, if memory serves.) I do remember I wasted no time in downloading a ton of pony-themed wallpapers, and believe it or not, the lion’s share of my wallpaper folder is taken up by pony ones. (And now Star Trek ships.)

So! Quite apart from anything happening in the episode, ACW is forever burned into my memory as the first episode of the show I ever watched on a computer that was mine, and mine alone. Prior to then I had to share the big desktop in the living room with my parents and younger brother, but not anymore! I had a computer I could customize to my liking, without worrying about whether I’d get pulled off it because Dad needed to use it for like 8 hours or something.

(Seriously, I feel like I could spend the entire rest of this post talking about how pivotal that first Mac was in terms of allowing me actual independence that didn’t previously exist. My roleplaying time on Fillydelphia skyrocketed now that I didn’t have to worry about getting yoinked off the computer mid-scene.)

But anyway, the episodes. It’s been nearly fourteen years since they originally aired, roughly a year after the actual Royal Wedding – the one between Prince William and Kate Middleton. (In context, they got married on the same day “Party of One” aired here in the US.) The Hub went all out on the promotional stuff, putting a wedding announcement in The New York Times, Tori Spelling did some interstitials, it was An Event!

14 years later, I have to say that it is probably, still, my favorite finale the show ever did. And a lot of that has to do with the antagonist: Chrysalis, the queen of the changelings. While the pony fandom has always been known for going All Out with pretty much any character, background or not, with Chrysalis the love was huge and immediate.

The thing about Chrysalis, and the changelings in general, is that they are probably second only to Nightmare Moon in terms of villains that are just full of endless storytelling ideas. Early FimFic was littered with stories, for example, about what Equestria might’ve been like if Nightmare had won, years before the show itself gave us a glimpse in “The Cutie Re-Mark.”

But the changelings take that to a whole other level entirely, because of the paranoia factor. Poor Twilight spends much of the first half essentially being gaslit by everypony, including her friends and her older brother, because they all forgot the aesop from the end of “Lesson Zero” about listening to your friend’s concerns, even when you think they don’t have anything to worry about.

All Twilight knows is that the pony she’s loved since she was younger, Princess Cadance, has gone from being her biggest fan to acting like she doesn’t know who Twilight even is, to say nothing of becoming the worst bridezilla you’ve ever seen. So, of course she gets carried away and has a big accusation in the penultimate scene of the episode! No one’s been listening to her and she feels completely at a loss!

Seriously, the last two minutes of that episode are amazing. Everyone, even Celestia, is pissed off with Twilight because they think she’s gone completely crazy, she thinks she’s gone completely crazy and apologizes to who she thinks is Cadance… and then the scary music starts up, the scenery darkens, there’s green fire everywhere and the next thing you know HOLY SHIT DID TWILIGHT JUST GET DROPPED INTO A PORTAL TO HELL?!

I think it’s a good thing they aired both halves on the same day rather than doing a one-week break as with “Return of Harmony,” entirely because I feel like the fandom would’ve completely exploded with possible explanations as to what was going on with Cadance and Twilight.

But whatever the fandom might’ve invented, nothing would’ve come close to what actually happened: TWILIGHT WAS FUCKING RIGHT AND THE ONLY REASON CHRYSALIS LOST WAS BECAUSE SHE WAS STUPID ENOUGH TO DROP SPARKS IN THE CRYSTAL CAVE.

You drop changelings into the story and suddenly it’s like playing Mafia or something, because You Don’t Know. Is this person really who they say they are, or are they a horrifying pony-shaped bug monster who’ll FEAST ON YOUR LOOOOOOOOOVE?!

A favorite target among the fanfic writers: Bonbon, because she has a different voice every single time she’s given a line. Everyone needs to go read Mendacity by Dromicosuchus, because it is fantastic and the be-all end-all when it comes to Changeling!Bonbon plots.

I would also be remiss if I didn’t talk about the music, and in particular the single best villain song the show ever had, and not just because it was also the first villain song the show ever had. I speak, of course, of “This Day Aria,” sung by Cadance and Chrysalis-as-Cadance as part of a montage.

In alternate verses, Chrysalis helpfully explains to the audience her motivations behind the wedding plan, while Cadance reunites with Twilight and together they work on escaping the gem caves, interrupting the ceremony right when Celestia is about to pronounce them married.

It was a massive hit in fandom circles, and IMO the best version is Odyssey Eurobeat’s version from June 2012, specifically the cut sung by Jessa herself. It is exquisitely well-crafted, and like so much else of her work, it has aged like a fine wine. (I’m listening to it as I type this, and lemme tell ya, it’s throwing me right back to 2012.) Her version even includes the one-verse reprise from the end, just before Chrysalis gets tossed halfway across Equestria by Cadance and Shining Armor, and it is magnificent.

Not much analysis at all this week, but who cares?! It’s the end of the season and I feel like I’ve earned the right to gush about my favorite finale ever. To this very day, the changelings remain my favorite piece of world-building from FIM – just last August I ran a Werewolf game centering around changelings, and now two of them make up the cast of regulars. Which, I think, is evidence enough of how much I still love this show a decade and a half later.

Chrysalis was right! The day really was perfect after all!

Anyway, thus endeth our coverage of season two, and it only took me five years to finish it! (I promise the season 3 posts will not take nearly as long.) I hope you’ve enjoyed this trot down memory lane, and I hope to see you next time, whenever that is, for the start of season 3, and the launch of a spinoff project!

Blessed be,
Lena

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑