Captain’s log, stardate 81253.4: Riker and Picard run up against an age-old wall of mafia-like blood feuding, almost certain to ruin the first negotiations between a clan of vicious pirates and a race of civilized if arrogant beings in centuries.
Hello all! Apologies for the sudden three-month break, I ended up having to completely reconfigure my writing schedule for much of January, February, and March, so it’s only now that I’m finally settling in to return to this series. However, as I’m working on a second Trek project at the same time as this one, Wolf Trek will be going on a longer hiatus following the end of TNG S3. (The new thing is a six-volume book project for all of Trek called About Space.)
However, when I do come back, I’ll have much less work to do – the nature of the project means I only have to write about half of any given show’s entire complement of episodes, which works out to, say, 39 of the 79 episodes in TOS, and 88 of TNG’s 176. So, when Wolf Trek resumes, I’ll only have to write new posts for the episodes I didn’t cover in About Space, the rest will be recycled. So, updates for this series should hopefully be more consistent if I’m only watching 13 episodes per season and not 26. (Gods willing, anyway.)
But for now, let’s turn our attention to “The Vengeance Factor,” episode 9 of season 3. This week, Commander Riker discovers that his latest alien girlfriend is instead an ageless alien death machine hell bent on tracking down and murdering the last surviving members of a particular clan, in revenge for her own clan being mostly wiped out a very long time ago.
But the thing is, he doesn’t know that’s what’s going on with her until the last third or so of the episode. The assassin, Yuta, kills an old guy early in the episode then spends much of the middle being flirted with, cooking food, and generally acting like a Good Little Servant Girl – loads of dramatic irony for us as Riker falls for her, believing she’s on the up-and-up until fairly late on, when he, Data, and Beverly figure shit out at one of the aft bridge consoles.
Not gonna lie, I’m a sucker for a good investigation scene like this. One of the recurring joys of TNG for me is just watching everyone crowd around a console, poke around on the screen, and come to a solution that completely changes the game. It’s competence porn and I can’t get enough of it!
Let’s focus on that scene around the middle of the episode. Yuta comes off shift and tells Riker that she wants to “spend some time with him,” which makes our resident ethical ladies’ man respond thusly when she tries, badly, to put the moves on him:
RIKER: Well, I’ve already dined. Maybe you know a good Acamarian dessert recipe.
(A kiss, of course)
YUTA: Does that not please you? Tell me what you want, William. I will do anything you wish.
RIKER: Wait a minute.
YUTA: I don’t understand. Don’t you want me to give you pleasure?
RIKER: Not as a servant. I told you, I prefer equals.
YUTA: Even in the matters of love?
RIKER: Especially in matters of love.
YUTA: I’ve offended you.
RIKER: No. I only want to make you as happy as you want to make me. You’re entitled to that.
While it is true that Riker does tend to end up with the alien girlfriend of the week a lot more often than Picard does, he doesn’t go cruising around the galaxy looking to pick up chicks. He’s a classical gentleman in a way that you really don’t see much of these days, a positive example of masculinity in a world that, in 2026, has gone completely in the other direction.
A lot of men today would look at the respect with which Riker treats Yuta and call him a “beta male,” because he doesn’t immediately bed her and turn this into a triple-X porn film, insult her, or otherwise demean her in any way shape or form. Hell, show this clip to Pete Hegseth and his head would probably explode.
But on top of that, there’s something else that Riker does here which Underhill touched on in their post on the episode:
Will’s position here is tremendously admirable: What he’s espousing tends to get bandied about rather crassly as “free will” and “individuality”, but what he’s really advocating is something a bit more nuanced than that. What Will values is self respect so far is it allows a person to pursue their true callings in life and egalitarianism such that everyone has the opportunity to do the same.
And by now, you can probably guess where I’m going with this. I would classify what Riker is talking about here as sovereignty in the modern sense of the term, relating to one’s own personal autonomy as a person, rather than that which was given to us by a ruler. And where there is sovereignty, there’s the Great Queen.
(Yes I’m talking about her again, why not? This is TNG’s third season, it’s the third Trek after TOS and TAS, and triplicity is one of her things. It really shouldn’t be a surprise that season 3 has had the greatest number of Morrigan mentions of TNG so far, and I ain’t gonna stop now!)
Here’s a word from Morgan Daimler about what I’m referring to: “Sovereignty is not only about rulership and authority over others, but also about personal autonomy and freedom, in essence about our ability to rule over ourselves. To have personal sovereignty is to stand in our personal power, take responsibility for all of our actions and their consequences, and to embrace the idea that we are ultimately our own authority. Our bodies belong only to ourselves. Our lives are lived as we choose to live them, whether that is for ourselves or for others, for our own happiness, or for other peoples’.”
And yet, in the exact same scene Yuta denies herself her own sovereignty. She clearly doesn’t want to – both in that scene and at the end, she tearfully tells Riker multiple times that she wants what he’s offering, but can’t accept it because her clan’s goal of murdering the other clan must take precedence.
She insists she doesn’t have a choice: she has to kill Chorgan, and the is nothing Riker can do or say that will stop her. So he responds the only way he can, by disintegrating her with his phaser. It’s a heartbreaking moment, and one that was literally inserted into the episode while Gene Roddenberry (who disapproved of the idea) was away on vacation and so couldn’t stop them.
Underhill views it as tragedy for tragedy’s sake, but I don’t agree – it’s a necessary reality check against Trek’s sunny optimism. Sometimes these stories don’t end happily – just watch Riker in the last minute or so of the episode, grim-faced, saying only a few words to his captain and staring contemplatively into his drink at Ten Forward.
Sure, there is peace, but it came with a price – the end of a very long war, and the bloodshed to pay it with. All Riker can do is sit with that pain for a while, mourn his loss, then pick himself up and move on.
As Stephanie Woodfield writes in Priestess of the Morrigan, “People become emotionally invested in the prosecution of war, but not in the ending of it. The irony is that after the battle is over, all people will remember is how it ended. How you ended it, and how you invoked the peace, like the Morrigan standing on the heights after the battle of Moytura, counting the bodies, counting the sacrifices we’ve had to make for our victories. We have to decide if the price we paid was worth it. Peace really isn’t peaceful. It’s earned only when you are willing to fight for it.”
Does Riker think killing Yuta was worth ensuring peace between the Gatherers and the Acamarians? Judging by his emotional state in the last minute and a half, he’s probably thinking the same words uttered by the Fifth Doctor in Warriors of the Deep:
“There should have been another way.”
Leave a Reply