Adventures in Narrative Substitution: Resolution (of the Daleks)

This week, we end as we began: with Daleks. And nothing tests a Doctor’s mettle quite like coming face-to-eyestalk with everyone’s favorite fascist squids. Just this series, we’ve looked at two classics of the genre: 1966’s ‘The Power of the Daleks,’ where they were used to ring in Troughton era, while ‘Remembrance’ opened the show’s 25th anniversary season and even went so far as to make the Daleks scary again. And now, this week, have two more classics: ‘Dalek’ by Rob Shearman and ‘Genesis of the Daleks’ by Terry Nation.

One of the things that has endlessly bothered me about ‘Resolution’ was the complete lack of promotion regarding the return of the Daleks. There have been exactly two occasions when they’ve been a surprise: the end of ‘The Dead Planet’ when Barbara is menaced by a sink plunger (because sixties viewers don’t know what Daleks are yet) and the end of ‘Army of Ghosts,’ when they interrupt the Cyberman story already in progress by bursting out of the Genesis Ark.

Ever since ‘The Dalek Invasion of Earth’ came out in 1965, Daleks have always been a sure-fire way to drum up interest in the show. And why not? Everyone loves them, they’re space Nazis, and it’s fun to watch them get repeatedly outsmarted by the Doctor! Even ‘Victory of the Daleks,’ a story I otherwise have little time for, understands that putting the Doctor in the room with a Dalek means you automatically get to do a plot that’s all but impossible to screw up.

Bafflingly, Daleks never come up in any of the promo materials for ‘Resolution’ save for the teaser trailer, and even then, it’s just stock audio of “EX-TERM-IN-ATE!” Other than that, if you went in the story completely blind, you’d have no idea that Daleks were involved until the squid arrives. Furthermore, they’re fucking Daleks, and everyone who’s watched the last ten episodes knows they have to pop up eventually! That’s what they do!

But as always, this is the Chibnall era: screwing up the basic shit is just what this era does.

When it comes to the Dalek itself, I’ll give Chibnall points for originality: having a Dalek out of its casing, dependent upon Lin to move around, is new. Certainly, it gives Nicholas Briggs some interesting things to do with that ring modulator. However, I have to admit that I felt incredibly uncomfortable when I watched the possession scene. Yes, I realize that was probably the point, but it feels a bit too much like early Torchwood and not enough like Doctor Who. (Also, can we please stop with the emphasis on female pain already?!)

Once the Dalek gets back into its casing though, it becomes a standard Doctor Who adventure. I wrote in the original version of this post that ‘Resolution’ was obviously trying to be the New Tens version of ‘Dalek,’ from the one-word title, a scene where the Dalek kills a bunch of soldiers, and even the fact that the Dalek in question is in disrepair and unable to contact its people. But as is usually the case when Chibnall steals from better writers than him, he kind of misses the point.

Part of what makes ‘Dalek’ work so well isn’t just the famous scene where Christopher Eccleston’s Doctor goes completely apeshit on the Dalek when he sees it but also that the story focuses on Dalek psychology and what happens when a Dalek gets humanized: it thinks of itself as impure because it took in Rose’s DNA and eventually chooses to exterminate itself rather than become Rusty the Dalek nine years early.

But of course, nothing like this ever happens in ‘Resolution,’ because we left subtext behind in 2017. It’s hard not to get the impression Chibnall doesn’t know what to do with the Daleks. In the Davies years, they were trying to restart their empire and/or get revenge on the Doctor for their actions in the Time War, and in the Moffat years, they were used as vehicles for explorations of the Doctor’s character. Even ‘Victory,’ for all its flaws, still ends with Amy saving the day by reminding Bracewell of Dorabella instead of the pain and loss the Doctor focused on.

But Chibnall? He just makes them out to be Generic Doctor Who Monster #38. You could have replaced the Dalek with the Toclafane (an early design of which was intended to be used if Davies and Shearman couldn’t get the Dalek rights) and had virtually the same story. They are there to tick a box and nothing more.

The thing, though, is that Daleks aren’t meant to be generic murderous monsters from outer space; they’re supposed to be fascist murderous monsters from outer space. If you watch ‘Genesis of the Daleks,’ easily the best Dalek story of the 1970s and Terry Nation’s best work ever, you’ll see that the Kaled camps (where Davros and his crew are all hanging out) are designed to evoke Nazi-era Germany, down to the uniforms. Davros, meanwhile, is essentially Space Hitler. Just check out that famous conversation he has with the Doctor in episode 5:

DAVROS: Now, future errors will be eradicated. Defeats will become victories. You have changed the future of the universe, Doctor.
DOCTOR: I have betrayed the future. Davros, for the last time, consider what you’re doing. Stop the development of the Daleks.
DAVROS: Impossible. It is beyond my control. The workshops are already fully automated to produce the Dalek machines.
DOCTOR: It’s not the machines, it’s the minds of the creatures inside them. Minds that you created. They are totally evil.
DAVROS: Evil? No. No, I will not accept that. They are conditioned simply to survive. They can survive only by becoming the dominant species. When all other life forms are suppressed, when the Daleks are the supreme rulers of the universe, then you will have peace. Wars will end. They are the power not of evil, but of good.

So far, so fash. I’d say that ‘Resolution’ might have been better had Chibnall paid a little bit more attention to the whole “alien Nazi analogue” thing, except that’s more or less what he tries to do in ‘Revolution.’ In that, the humans discover the melted Dalek casing from the end of ‘Resolution’ and build their own knockoff versions, which they refer to as “security drones.” And of course, it’s never said directly that building a fascist police state with some killer robots is a bad thing, it’s just implied.

Yeah, well, here’s some free writing advice, Chibnall: IF FASCISTS ARE TAKING OVER YOUR GOVERNMENT, YOUR FIRST JOB IS TO GET THEM THE HELL OUT OF OFFICE BY ANY MEANS NECESSARY!

Now, I’m not trying to suggest that Chibnall is somehow a secret Nazi; he’s just a largely harmless centrist with a crippling inability to think through the implications and consequences of what he writes. Case in point: the Doctor’s line describing the recon scout Dalek as a “refugee.” Here’s some more free writing advice: YOU DO NOT CALL A MURDEROUS SPACE NAZI A MOTHERFUCKING REFUGEE EVER. PERIOD.

And finally, some thoughts on the episode’s emotional arc: Ryan meets his absent father again, now working as a microwave salesman. This is exceptionally problematic writing for a Black character by a white man, since it relies on stereotypes, but then again, so has Ryan’s entire tenure on the show. Doctor Who has never done right by its Black characters; Chibnall is just the latest example.

As my dear friend Miranda observed:

Y’know, maybe Graham being the center of Ryan’s story and having the brunt of the focus of Grace be about him rather than Ryan was fucked up and tonedeaf! It’s not that Graham was important to Ryan that’s the issue, it’s that his entire story revolves around him accepting Graham, giving Graham the things he wants, the other black family members being dead or deadbeat meaning his main and only relationship is to his white grandad.

She is 100% right. It’s another huge example of Chris Chibnall actively refusing to think about the consequences of his writing. Grace should NOT have been killed off in the first place, but if we’re going to do that, THE ABSOLUTE LEAST he could have done was NOT center the white guy in the narrative of Black pain. But he couldn’t even do that, nor could he avoid making Aaron a walking stereotype.

The Aaron/Ryan subplot, for me, is just the latest example of how this era’s surface level progressivism masks the fact that, in so many ways, it’s actually quite regressive. Hiring diverse talent is an absolute necessity, and I’m glad Chibnall chose to establish that precedent. But it’s not enough. It’s never enough. The only way this show can even begin to account for the wrongs it’s inflicted on its Black characters and the way it has hurt its Black viewers is if his replacement isn’t yet another white man. Otherwise, the cycle will just continue.

You can be an ally to Black people all you want. But sometimes the smartest thing for us allies to do is to step aside and let them take center stage and tell their stories.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑