Adventures in Narrative Substitution: The Battle of Ranskoor Av Kolos

The season finale, at least in Doctor Who terms, has really only been around on a consistent basis since 2005. The classic series was structured more like a very long-running serial, like Coronation Street, the Commando Cody theatrical shorts, or General Hospital: a season began, it aired for a while, then it wrapped up and the show went on break for a bit before returning later in the year. Character and story arcs weren’t a core part of the story being told.

But that’s not to say they never happened! It’s especially obvious with regeneration stories: ‘The War Games,’ ‘Planet of the Spiders,’ ‘Logopolis,’ and ‘The Caves of Androzani’ all occurred at or near the end of their respective seasons, tying a neat bow around the incumbent’s era and making room for their successor after that. Then there are stories like ‘The Armageddon Factor’ and ‘The Ultimate Foe,’ which wrapped up story arcs, specifically the quest for the Key to Time in ‘Factor’ and the Doctor’s trial by the Time Lords in ‘Foe.’ ‘The Time Meddler,’ the last story of the second season, has no arc to end, but it does move the series forward by revealing that the Monk has a TARDIS, giving him a connection to the Doctor.

And given Chibnall’s decision to bring the show back to its Sixties roots with Series 11, you’d think that he might take a few cues from ‘Meddler’ and come up with a decent story for an arc-less season. After all, ‘It Takes You Away’ largely tidied up the Grace plot-line, so at that point he should have free rein to let his imagination run wild and do something that moves the show forward, right? There’s nothing he can possibly do to screw this up!

But you would be wrong. Because this is Chris Chibnall, a man who can be relied upon to fuck up even basic principles of Aristotelian dramatic structure. His best scripts are so okay, they’re average, and his worst ones… well, we’re about to find out.

Let’s be blunt: ‘The Battle of Ranskoor Av Kolos,’ by every conceivable measure, is a failure from the title on down. The dialogue is so bad you don’t even have to watch the episode to get a sense of the story because the characters tell you what they’re doing as they’re doing it. It’s horrendously shot, the actors are wasted, and the plot consists of recycled bits of Davies and Adams with none of the heart or humor, like the world’s worst Beatles tribute band. The religion stuff… well, that’s not really my place to say; this wolf is a jaded ex-Irish Catholic who hasn’t set paw in a church since loup was about 14. Instead, I’ll direct you to my good friend Max Curtis’ piece on Thirteen and religion from March 2020. Or, a thousand wolf-years ago.

So: having established that ‘Battle’ is truly the ‘Red Zone Cuba’ of Doctor Who stories and a spectacularly amateurish showing from someone who’s supposed to be a professional, what do we do with this? To answer that question, let’s ask another: how do you substitute a narrative?

In my series, I’ve usually taken the Chibnall-era story in question, compared it to aspects of previous stories that match up, and pointed out where and how Chibnall’s effort falls short. Sometimes I end with an out-and-out rejection (‘Arachnids’ and ‘Kerblam’ are good examples) and sometimes I let the stories stand as they are, but still establish the ways in which the wider era hurts them (‘Demons’ and ITYA).

The sheer incompetence of ‘Battle’ requires an immediate rejection, so to do that, let’s look at the two stories I’ve selected: ‘The Name of the Doctor’ from Series 7 (as a response to the story’s main setting) and ‘Logopolis’ (to pit Tim Shaw against the Ainley Master).

Let’s start with ‘Name.’ The bulk of the story is spent on the planet Trenzalore, where the Doctor is buried, with he, Clara, the Paternosters, the Great Intelligence, and Ghost River all wandering around a giant TARDIS, now transformed into a tomb for its lost pilot. That does not sound like interesting television, but trust me, it is: the setting is largely there for ambiance. The real meat of the story is in its character work.

Moffat’s season finales, in general, tend to be very character-driven affairs. The Davies ones were more about bombast and spectacle, blowing people away with Dalek armies, Cybermen and Daleks killing each other with lasers and weaponized sarcasm, Davros being a giant ham, and so on. Moffat ones have spectacle too, but primarily, their hearts always lie in people having conversations with each other, and this is where that approach really works.

Here’s the pivotal scene:

SIMEON: The Doctor’s life is a open wound. And an open wound can be entered.
DOCTOR: No, it would destroy you.
S: Not at all. It will kill me. It will destroy you. I can rewrite your every living moment. I can turn every one of you victories into defeats. Poison every friendship. Deliver pain to your every breath.
D: It will burn you up. Once you go through, you can’t come back. You will be scattered along my timeline like confetti.
S: It matters not, Doctor. You thwarted me at every turn. Now you will give me peace, as I take my revenge on every second of your life. Goodbye. Goodbye, Doctor.

In the show, the Doctor is the center of the universe. It’s his name in the title for crying out loud! So ‘Name’ asks, “What would happen if the Doctor was taken out of the universe?” And the answer, as it was in ‘The Pandorica Opens’ and ‘The Wedding of River Song,’ is complete and total destabilization of everything, not just the universe of but, in this case, of the show’s entire narrative engine. There can be no Doctor Who stories without the Doctor, and if there’s no Doctor, there’s no point in having a fiftieth anniversary celebration.

And so, in a few lines of dialogue and some good acting from Matt Smith and kind of generic acting from Richard E. Grant, Moffat pulls off the most audacious narrative collapse ever, to steal another term from El Sandifer.

Meanwhile, this is what passes for character drama in Battle:

GRAHAM: Doc, can I have a word?
DOCTOR: Of course.
[…]
G: I need to be honest with you, cos I am really grateful for everything you’ve done for me. Well, for us, you know? Everywhere we’ve been, all the adventures, been amazing. But if that is the creature from Sheffield, I will kill it if I can. For what it did to Grace.
[…]
D: You’re better than this. You are. You have to be. If you kill him, I can’t have you travel with me. That’s if you even live.
G: I understand.
D: No, you don’t. We’re going to rescue hostages. Anything that compromises them is dangerous. And if you kill him, you become the same as him.

Yeah. Not only has Chibnall apparently decided Graham’s arc isn’t wrapped up well enough, he’s decided to give Graham a revenge plot for absolutely no reason whatsoever, completely out of the blue, with zero set-up. There is no possible justification for this in any of the preceding 9 episodes; it just happens. And of course, it plays out in the most hackneyed way imaginable: at the end, Graham and Ryan ultimately choose not to kill Tzim-Sha, instead sealing him in one of his own cryogenic chambers. It’s like these two have never seen Austin Powers. PEOPLE ESCAPE FROM THEM ALL THE TIME! THAT’S WHAT THEY’RE FOR!

Then there’s the Doctor, with her whole “If you kill him, you will be just like him” schtick. Which is complete bullshit on an ethical standpoint. If anything, Graham would be doing the universe a favor because guess what, THE BIG BLUE TOOTH FAIRY OF DOOM IS DEAD! HE CAN’T HURT ANYONE ANYMORE!

Now, the Doctor not wanting Graham to kill Tzim-Sha because she doesn’t want that stain on his heart? That, at least, makes sense. For crying out loud, that’s what happens at the end of ‘Death in Heaven’ when Clara prepares to kill Missy:

DOCTOR: No. No, don’t you dare. I won’t let you.
CLARA: Old friend, is she? If you have ever let this creature live, everything that happened today, is on you. All of it, on you. And you’re not going to let her live again.
D: Clara, all I’m doing is not letting you kill her. I never said I was letting her live.
C: Really?
D: If that’s the only thing that will stop you, yes.

But then again, that was written by someone who knows how morality works. Chibnall clearly doesn’t, not if he’s reaching for “BOTH SIDES ARE EQUALLY BAD.” Or as I call it, the Jill Stein Voter Defense: “Sure! One party’s a bunch of racist old Christo-fascists bent on turning the US into an authoritarian ethno-state and the other one has a lot of centrist wet blankets who keep getting in their own way then wonder why they lose elections, but rather than vote for the wet blankets so they can keep the world from falling to wreck and ruin, I’m going to vote Green and let the fascists win instead!”

There is no dealing with such people. If the Doctor is an ideal to which the Time Lord we address by that name aspires, then in Chris Chibnall’s hands, she’s evidently stopped trying to be the Doctor and appears to have settled for being the female Keir Starmer instead. At least we have Clara.

Let’s move on, then, to Tzim-Sha. The character, as the personification of toxic masculinity, remains ridiculous. If Chibnall was even remotely capable of humor, and he’s not except when he blunders into it by accident or makes a Beatles joke, he’d recognize this and emphasize it. But because he has to play everything so goddessdamned seriously, we get him being treated by the narrative with the same weight as Davros in ‘The Stolen Earth,’ except that Sha’s never done anything to earn that.

His plan is thus: hoodwink the Ux into believing in him instead of the intentionally vague Creator and use their reality-warping abilities to shrink some planets down and use them to create a great big super weapon, which he then aims at Earth. Which is, as I pointed out on Twitter, literally what happens in the last two episodes of ‘The Pirate Planet.’ Stealing from other writers you like is not, inherently, a bad thing, but it helps if you put your own twist on it so that your version is still distinct. Chibnall doesn’t (unless you count not giving Tzim-Sha a Mr. Fibuli-alike to bark orders at as a twist).

So, okay, great, the Earth is in danger from a great big laser. But so what? We never see any sequences of people running around in a panic, no scenes of newscasters looking grim-faced as alien death arrives to strike them down like sinners, just a bunch of clips of the planet from orbit with a laser being fired at the ocean! There are stakes, but nothing is done to make those stakes matter.

Which brings me to ‘Logopolis.’ It’s the final story for the Fourth Doctor and, much like ‘Battle,’ contains a group of reality warpers, in this case, the people of the titular planet, total math geniuses who can chant in base sixteen. The Doctor pays them a visit to see if they can help him fix the chameleon circuit on the TARDIS, but before they’re able to try, the Master shows up and starts throwing a wrench into things… except that in the act of doing so, he accidentally slaughters one quarter of the entire universe, including the planet Traken (seen in the story just before this), where new companion Nyssa comes from. Nice job breaking it, Master.

Here’s how you do stakes: 10 minutes into part 4, Nyssa gets to watch her planet die on the TARDIS’ scanner screen. She says, “The Master killed my stepmother, and then my father, and now the world that I grew up in, blotted out forever.” It doesn’t come across in text, but if you watch the story, you can hear Sarah Sutton as Nyssa try valiantly not to cry, as if she learned emotional suppression from a Vulcan. True, Who from 1981 to 1986 was about as bad with emotional content as the current era is, but for every Eric Saward or Chris Chibnall, there’s a Christopher H. Bidmead or an Ed Hime doing their best to make up for it.

I like to think I’ve built up something of a tolerance for bad media over the years. Watch enough bad movies with Joel, Mike, Jonah, Tom Servo, and Crow, and you start to appreciate them for what they are, extremely obvious warts and all. But some experiments are more painful than others: The Castle of Fu-Manchu, from MST’s third season, was so bad that it came very close to breaking the spirits of my favorite trio of wisecrackers. (Yes, that’s one of the movies Talons was inspired by, and yes, it’s just as racist. Crow even launches into an editorial a quarter of the way into the movie decrying the prevalent yellowface, only to break down in tears before he can finish.)

Watching the Chibnall era, ITYA and Demons aside, is like watching Manos unriffed; by the end of the movie, you want to tear out your hair, or fur, wondering how in the world anyone decided this was a good thing to do and why they weren’t all fired. By the time this episode aired in 2018, I felt so completely despondent that I almost considered giving up on the show entirely. Then I watched ‘The Doctor’s Wife’ a few days later and remembered why it was I love this wonderful and infuriating TV show so much.

When it’s made well, Doctor Who is pure TV magic. When made badly, it feels like something sent up to me by some unknown British member of the Forrester clan, and all I can do is talk back at the screen with witty remarks and occasional insightful analysis.

The good news is that there are only nine more episodes left to air before the Chibnall era ends. The bad news is, I still have another two seasons to do before I reach that same point. It’s been a long journey so far, and there’s still quite a bit to get through. I hope, as I always do, that you’ll go on it with me.

So ends the alleged battle of ‘Ranskoor Av Kolos’: the final score was ‘Battle’ 0, Mactíre 10. Join us next week for a discussion on the emotional reunion of Ryan with his absent father, Skarosian refugees, and Chris Chibnall’s secret hentai obsession.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑