The Moonlight Side: Part 3 – Scent and a Sound

This week, our journey through werewolf media takes us to the world of audio, specifically four Doctor Who audio plays from Big Finish Productions. These were released as part of the company’s recently-ended Monthly Adventures line in 2001 (Loups-Garoux) and 2019 (The Monsters of Gokroth et al). The last three see the return of Mags the werewolf from ‘The Greatest Show in the Galaxy,’ a 1988 Sylvester McCoy story.

Loups-Garoux by Marc Platt

Our first story is a Fifth Doctor audio with Turlough, and aside from the fact that it’s got werewolves in it, it also features Eleanor Bron, making her third and final Doctor Who appearance, though I know her best as Ahme, Paul McCartney’s quasi-love interest in the Beatles movie Help!.

Anyway: though it take place primarily in Rio de Janeiro in 2080, Loups-Garoux opens in Germany during the year 1589, when infamous mass murderer Peter Stubbe was executed for his crimes. Stubbe was a real person, and the details surrounding his death appear in Montague Summers’ The Werewolf in Lore and Legend, which we looked at a couple weeks ago. In his book, Summers reprints a pamphlet describing Stubbe’s crimes, which you can also check out here. In the Doctor Who story though, Stubbe is able to escape his execution, and lies low for 500 years before surfacing in Rio, just as the Doctor and Turlough turn up.

Bron plays Ileana de Santos, a werewolf and daughter of a famous local merchant. Her son, Victor, has been stuck in his wolf form for some time, and Ileana is concerned for his welfare. He’s being treated by a Dr. Hayashi, an older Asian man who seems like he’s on the up and up… except that toward the end of episode 2, he’s revealed to be working with Stubbe, and in episode 3, tells the Doctor he intends to create a “cure” for lycanthropy, because genocide is such an ugly word. Naturally, the Doctor tries to stop him, though Hayashi is killed off instead.

A running theme throughout the story is the destruction of the environment as wrought by the humans: according to the Doctor’s dialogue in episode 1, the Amazon rainforest became a desert, bringing the planet even closer to complete ecological collapse. That might’ve sounded far-fetched 20 years ago, but real-world global warming has led to burning wildfires in the Amazon, to say nothing of the droughts that have been going on there since 2005. So much for science fiction.

In some ways, Loups-Garoux reminds me a bit of ‘The Green Death,’ but it’s angrier given how much worse the climate crisis has gotten since 1973. In episode 4, Stubbe talks about taking the planet back from the humans, and while there’s no doubt in my mind that he’s doing it for his own selfish reasons, being a psychopathic mass murderer and all, it’s not hard to blame him.

As I wrote in the Adventures in Narrative Substitution post on Kerblam!, capitalism’s relentless pursuit of profit at all costs leads to destructive ripple effects everywhere else. Sometimes it’s the mental and physical well-being of those of us being ground to dust working the machinery, and sometimes it’s the trees and the wolves and the other animals in the world, hunted and killed to near extinction.

Then there’s Stubbe himself. As I said last post, he’s definitely one of those toxic alphas I mentioned, perhaps the worst of all, given his plans for wolf domination of Earth. The Doctor does his best to goad Stubbe’s followers into attacking him instead with a brilliant speech, announcing how, once Stubbe’s done with them, they’ll be his lapdog poodles. And it works!

Platt’s werewolves are fascinating: they don’t seem to be overly fond of humans (or cut-claws, as they’re called) and don’t change on the full moon like Rowling’s wolves. Instead, they’re more like Carrie Vaughn’s, able to change at will or when extremely stressed, as with Ileana’s own transformation at the cliffhanger of episode 2 (she gets better). They can even induce the change in others simply by showing them their shadows in the mirror, which ought to make my friend Frezno happy. Even the Doctor starts to succumb, though not for long.

The key thing about these werewolves is their connection to the Earth: they are bound to it, to leave it behind would kill them, as the Doctor tells Ileana when she tries to run away with him in the TARDIS. That connection proves crucial, as it is what allows Stubbe to finally die: the Doctor brings the TARDIS into Earth’s orbit, significantly weakening him and allowing Rosa (the indigenous American woman who’s been tracking him all story) to take his spirit into her mind with her magical forest powers. Sure, it’s magic rather than science, but then again, the show has always run on fantasy logic, sci-fi trappings notwithstanding.

Performance-wise, I have to give top marks to Bron, Nicky Henson as Stubbe, Mark Strickson as Turlough, and, of course, Peter Davison as the Doctor. I will admit it does take a bit to get used to his voice in this: it’s much lower and more gravelly than what he had on TV. But then again, that’s what happens when you hit middle age, as pretty much anyone who’s listened to a Paul McCartney record from around 1993 onward can tell you. It helps, I think, to imagine Five in his older, time-displaced appearance from Time Crash than how he looked in the early ‘80s.

I’ll never forgive BF for using the ‘70s title music though. I’m sorry, but it just sounds wrong for a Five story.

The Monsters of Gokroth by Matt Fitton

Jumping ahead 18 years and to another Doctor, The Monsters of Gokroth was the 250th release of the Monthly Adventures range and, as mentioned, saw Mags the werewolf from ‘The Greatest Show in the Galaxy’ rejoin the Seventh Doctor, taking Ace’s place as his companion for three stories. Mags doesn’t appear very often in Doctor Who expanded universe media: aside from her sole TV story, its Target novelization, and these audios, her only other appearance is in Hill of Beans, a comic story where Jessica Martin herself was the artist. We’ll take Lupine Representation Moments where we can get them, I suppose!

Gokroth, at the outset, feels like a typical base-under-siege story: there’s a village where the townspeople live in fear and monsters on the outside threatening to attack. Living in a nearby castle is a mysterious doctor, Maleeva, who conducts experiments during thunderstorms, earning the villagers’ suspicion and eventual ire. But, as The Gothic Archies once sang, things are not what they appear.

In my Back to the Eleventh Hour post on the Series 6 story ‘The Almost People,’ I wrote that one of the problems with bases under siege, as a genre, is that they depend on othering the invaders so the Doctor and his human allies can win the day. What Fitton pulls off with Gokroth is a wonderful example of what El Sandifer calls narrative substitution: appearing to tell one kind of story before sweeping the proverbial rug out from under you to reveal a different and (usually) better story underneath.

The cliffhanger of the third episode is that Maleeva, despite her name (derived from the Romani fortune teller in The Wolf Man, who also wasn’t evil), has actually been trying to help the people of Gokroth; much like the Cheetah planet in ‘Survival,’ Gokroth has a morphic field which transforms anyone who lands on it into monsters, as the human colonists discovered when they arrived. Maleeva has been trying to turn them back into humans, but in so doing, she’s denying them their truth, creating a society that lives in mortal dread.

So, where does Mags fit into all this? She begins the story searching for a cure for her lycanthropy, as her transformations have become unmoored from the lunar cycle, making her more dangerous. Her arc in this story, essentially, is a microcosm of the one the villagers have: she fears the wolf within her, and she must learn to control it if she is to survive. She just about manages it (or so the Doctor thinks) toward the end of episode 4 just as the villagers are beginning to accept their own monstrousness.

I unabashedly love this story, I really do. I know that Big Finish, as a company, has gotten a lot of flak from some corners for essentially being a nostalgia factory for Doctor Who fans of a certain age, endlessly churning out new stories for those fans who want to keep partying like it’s 1973 and Jon Pertwee is still the Doctor. But within the last few years, the company has made a genuine effort at cleaning up its act and becoming, for my money, a place where excellent stories can still be told, especially at a time when the TV series is falling short.

If Gokroth can be said to have a moral, I think it would go something along the lines of “Embrace your own monstrousness.” Mags, when we meet her, is doing what a lot of trans people do before they accept that they’re trans: she tries to deny that part of herself, doing everything she can to purge it from her and become “normal.” I can’t speak to what trans men go through, but I know that for trans women, we’ll go all in on our masculinity, whatever that entails for us. For me, it mainly meant watching lots of Top Gear and Mythbusters and James Bond movies, because those were the kinds of things boys liked, and for some people, it’s joining the military, as in the case of Chelsea Manning.

But just like with Mags and her lycanthropy, we can’t deny our true selves for long; eventually, they must break free, and we must allow the changes to take place. I’m still working on the real-life gender transition, but online, I’ve been out and socially transitioned for most of the last six years, and I don’t regret it for an instant. I’m happier now than I ever was when I pretended to be a boy, and I certainly can’t imagine that I’d be writing the things I do if I weren’t trans. There are a lot of downsides with being trans, but there are plenty of upsides too, and those deserve to be celebrated.

And bringing Mags back allows this story to be absolutely saturated with Big Queer Energy, whether that was intentional on Fitton’s part or not. For all I know, I could just be seeing patterns in things that aren’t there, but who says they aren’t? The McCoy years are well-known for having big queer energy, and Mags is as much a part of that tradition as Ace. For crying out loud, she’s a punk rock werewolf! Give that woman a guitar and she’d be the lupine Joan Jett!

The best scene of the story for me is the closing seconds of episode 4: the Doctor tells Mags that he’s tying up loose ends and seeing to unfinished business before he regenerates, and invites her to join him on his travels. She accepts, and when she asks where they’ll go next, he lets her choose. It’s a lovely little scene, and a strong beginning to the trilogy as well.

The Moons of Vulpana by Emma Reeves

In the middle story of the trilogy, Mags is still searching for a way to control her inner wolf, so the Doctor takes her to Vulpana a few hundred years before she was born. They land in an environment where not only are werewolves in control, they hunt the ones who can’t change for sport, as their blood is deemed impure, and in this society, the purity of blood means everything. It’s one of Doctor Who’s great genre collisions, in this case the world of werewolves with, say, Downton Abbey.

Running throughout the story is an awareness by all the characters that Vulpanan society must change, lest it fall apart completely, but the conflict comes from the way everyone tries to approach it. Ulla, the matriarch of the Second Moon House, believes that the traditional ways are still the best ones, and so she is suspicious of anything new. Her son, Jax, believes in science and technology, so he built a fifth moon to turn the nobles on each other, since he knows they’d do that anyway. His theory goes that if all the nobles die, he can build a new Vulpana from the ashes with himself as its head.

Moons is fascinating, because while there is an evil plan that the Doctor gets to thwart, he and Mags don’t exactly win either. Both sides on the issue of Vulpana’s continued existence are monstrous for different reasons, and as Mags tells the Doctor at the end, by the time she’s born, the society she’s just seen will have fallen apart anyway, having fled to other worlds.

In that respect, this story reminds me of ‘Survival,’ in which the Doctor and Ace get trapped on a planet of humanoid cheetahs who are busy trying to survive even as their world falls apart around them. “If we fight like animals, we’ll die like animals” applies as well to the wolves of Vulpana as it did to the Doctor and the Master during their fight at the end of that story.

Listening to it and digesting it now, I must admit I feel a bit introspective. On the day I write this (Sept. 12, 2021), we’ve just passed the twentieth anniversary of the terrorist attacks in New York on Sept. 11th, 2001. We reached that anniversary at a time when COVID-19 has killed far more people by several orders of magnitude, and even with the vaccine, there’s no end in sight. One half of the US continues to refuse to wear masks or get vaccinated, loudly proclaiming themselves to be oppressed by the vaccinated majority.

And on top of an ongoing pandemic, we have climate change. We have a political system so old and creaky that we can’t even get an infrastructure bill passed because certain people (Joe Manchin) are pretending to care about the federal budget deficit, and that’s before you factor in that one of our two parties is very close to achieving their goal of a permanent majority, if the results of the 2022 midterms and the 2024 general election go their way. (Which they probably will.)

And now here I am, listening to a Doctor Who story about a planet ruled by wealthy elites trying desperately to stick to what they know, even though the world as they know it is falling around their furry, lupine ears. I look at ancient Vulpana and see a sci-fi reflection of the world around me, down to the lying hypocrite declaring that he alone can fix it.

It’s tempting to descend into nihilism, to declare that nothing will get better, that the various apocalypses threatening to bring us down will succeed. Certainly, living in deep cover among the humans for so long has taught me that they can be infinitely cruel and cowardly, much like the Vulpanans.

But goddammit, that’s not how I am. As my Doctor once said, “I am and always will be the optimist, the hoper of far-flung hopes and dreamer of improbable dreams.” I believe that a better world, one where everyone works for the benefit of the pack as a whole, is possible. We don’t have an all-knowing alien in a blue box to help us, but we can learn from the lessons they’ve tried to teach us and build that world together. The Moons of Vulpana only shows us where we are; it doesn’t point the way forward. But a foundation is a foundation, and that by itself is a good start.

An Alien Werewolf In London by Alan Barnes

As I’ve said, the running theme of this trilogy has been Mags trying to get a hold of her wolf self with varying levels of success. She tries to do it with Dr. Maleeva in Gokroth, but it never actually works out, and in Moons, Jax lures her to his side by telling her he can teach her how to control her changes, only to reveal in one of his last lines of dialogue that he never needed to learn that, because he couldn’t change at all.

In this story, Mags finally meets her match, literally: what happens is, the Doctor and Mags land on Earth in the early 1990s per Ace’s summons. Ace has parted ways with the Doctor at this point in her timeline, but it seems to have been on good terms. She reveals she intends to pull a rescue mission: a friend of hers, an Australian named Rufus, tells the group about an alien creature he found chained up in a mausoleum belonging to Rohesia and Raymond, two ridiculously wealthy siblings with secrets of their own.

As the story unspools, we learn that the alien is actually a creature called a Sin Eater, a kind of empathic shapeshifter. At the end of the first episode, Mags transforms into her wolf shape and bites the Sin Eater (hereinafter referred to as Arthur) who bites back. Arthur changes into Mags’ form and absorbs her memories and lycanthropy as well, freeing Mags from her curse for a year or so.

At story’s end, Mags, Arthur, the Doctor, and Ace go their separate ways: Ace and Arthur stay behind on Earth, while Mags and the Doctor head back to the TARDIS for further adventures. Mags later admits that while she’s happy for Arthur getting to live her best life with Ace, she adds that “wherever I go the monster will always be there.” Her wolf self will always be a part of her, even if she doesn’t want it to be. For Mags, to change into a wolf once a month is to be cursed, because she becomes a monster.

But I can’t help but look at it through different eyes. True, changing into a wolf once a month would be a ridiculously painful experience: bones are not exactly meant to warp and shift in the way they do during werewolf transformations. Hiding it from possibly unaccepting parents would be downright impossible, whereas starting HRT would at least produce effects that are difficult to see if you’re not looking closely enough over a very long period of time.

But let’s assume, just for a moment, that it’s a painless experience and you don’t have to worry how your family or friends might respond. One full moon night, you transform into your other self, and suddenly that is all you are. The Kitty Norville books illustrate this beautifully by allowing Kitty’s inner wolf to narrate, with her text always written in italics:

“The night becomes so clear, seen through the Wolf’s eyes.

Then she leaps, the Wolf is formed and running, four legs feel so natural, so splendid, pads barely touching soft earth before they fly again. Wind rushes through her fur like fingers, scent pours into her nose: trees, earth, decay, life, water, day-old tracks, hour-old tracks, spent rifle cartridges from last season, blood, pain, her pack. Pack’s territory. And the One. The Leader. Right behind her, chasing.”

The wolf is happy! This isn’t a curse to be feared or repulsed by but something to be embraced! Wild wolves are far from the monstrous creatures that humans have portrayed them as; they are beautiful, intelligent animals, strongly devoted to their families. Yes, they hunt, but only so they can eat. Even then, they almost never attack humans. It’s ironic to me that humans have long feared wolves, when to me, the two species have more in common than most people will admit.

Big Finish have not, as yet, talked about doing more with Mags and the Seventh Doctor. The end of the Monthly Adventures range this past spring, coupled with a move toward Doctor-specific box sets in its place from next January and the fact that Six and Peri got a boxset of their own earlier this year, all suggest to me that Mags could return, and I hope she does. Not just because Martin and McCoy have wonderful chemistry but also because I feel there are still more stories to tell with Mags, to develop her character from one-off to one of the great companions, to mention her in the same breath as Sarah Jane, Amy Pond, Rose Tyler, or Clara Oswald.

If I were somehow put in charge of plotting a course for her, I’d design something that would allow her to make peace with and learn to love her inner wolf. Maybe spend the whole story in her wolf form, with the Doctor keeping an eye on her in case she lashes out but otherwise stepping back and seeing how she processes the adventure of the week in that mode rather than in ‘human’ mode. As their extensive reworking of the Sixth and Eighth Doctors proved, they can do a lotwith a TV character aside from killing them off.

The Vulpana Mags grew up in was a savage, wolf-eat-wolf world, and then she got snapped up by Captain Cook and forced to live as a show dog in the Psychic Circus. Even going back to an earlier point in Vulpanan history didn’t help, because the savagery was there too, hidden behind the trappings of a Jane Austen novel. She’s never had a positive role model she can look up to for help or guidance, and she needs that desperately. I hope Big Finish does that for her, but if they don’t, I’d be more than happy to take a crack at it. Isn’t that what fanfics are for?

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑