The Moonlight Side: Part 4 – Silver Bullets and Silver Screens

Tooth and Claw (2006, dir. Euros Lyn)

Our fifth and final look at Doctor Who takes on werewolves comes not from Big Finish audio, but the show’s home format of television. The second story of the second revival season, Tooth and Claw stars David Tennant as the Doctor with Billie Piper as Rose Tyler, with a script by show runner Russell T Davies, his sixth in a row. He was not originally supposed to write this one, but according to Shannon Sullivan, the unnamed original writer largely ignored the brief, forcing Davies to throw this together like a college student writing a six-page essay the weekend before the deadline.

The last time I watched this story was back in 2019 for an abandoned blog project idea I called Trial of the Tenth Time Lord. The premise was, I would put the Tenth Doctor on trial, using his episodes as evidence, with the intent of revealing that he was not exactly the upstanding hero he pretended to be but a villain with good publicity, the answer to the question of “What would the Doctor be like if the Valeyard had won?”, the child-friendly version of Kilgrave.

However, I ran into a problem: David Tennant was simply too good as the Doctor to sustain an era-wide rewatch like that, and the complete collapse of the character I was hoping to expose doesn’t even happen in Series 2. I had nothing to go on! So I took out the trial bits and reworked the best of the essays into the Scrapyard Scribblings series. This time around, I don’t have to do any of that. Instead, I get to just talk about what I’ve always wanted to talk about: the werewolf.

Much like Mags, the werewolf is completely alien. Where exactly they come from is never said in dialogue, but interestingly, they appear to be a sentient virus not unlike the one found in (of all stories) The Invisible Enemy, that infamous Fourth Doctor story from 1977 that introduced K-9 and gave the world a plot that can be best described as “Honey, I Shrunk the Doctor.” There’s no mention of an allergy to silver, but instead, we get the equally interesting allergy to mistletoe.

The werewolf’s plan is to bite Queen Victoria, allowing them to possess her and create an Empire of the Wolf. It sounds cool and all (there’s even a Choose Your Own Adventure book called that, featuring Eleven and Amy) but in all honesty, the plan probably wouldn’t have worked. Vicky had had all of her kids at that point in her life and was unlikely to have more, to say nothing of the fact that by the 1800s, the British monarch didn’t have a lot of power. So, despite the Doctor joking around with Rose at the end, chances are Victoria was safe, and the cut she received really was nothing to worry about.

There’s a couple of other things I like about this story: first, the way the werewolf is killed. The Doctor uses the diamond and the telescope to shower them in moonlight, just like (as he tells Rose) giving a plant too much water will cause it to drown. It’s a unique way of solving the problem that I haven’t seen before, not to mention a lot more appropriate for the show’s historical age group than silver bullets would’ve been.

The best thing, though, is the Doctor’s attitude toward the werewolf. Yes, he has to stop them to keep them from hurting anyone else, but as he runs into the cellar where the wolf is breaking free of the cage, he kind of smiles at them and says, “That’s beautiful.” That’s the pure essence of the Doctor, right there, and I understand now why so many people still hold the Tenth as one of the archetypal Doctors, second only to the Fourth: when he’s not consumed by his own ego, he’s as much a Doctor as the Eleventh or Twelfth. He may not be my favorite, but I’ll never deny his Doctorness. (Also, of course he loves a werewolf; he traveled with Mags! You just know he thought of her in that moment!)

I have, I admit, something of a personal connection to this story: it was one of the first Doctor Who stories I ever watched, along with a small assortment of other Tennant era stories. I would never claim Tennant’s Doctor as mine (my book series isn’t called Back to the Tenth Hour, for goodness sake), but he was my first, at least on television. I liked this story so much that I tried to watch it every full moon, though I don’t think I ever pulled it off.

Other observations: the shot with the Doctor and the wolf listening on either side of a wall is hilarious when you consider what happens at the end of Doomsday, Rose’s constant attempts at getting the Queen to say her famous line got tiresome on the first go, and RTD does a really good job at getting us to sympathize with Victoria. If you ask me, she was completely right when she calls out the Doctor and Rose at the end, though of course her banishment (such as it is) means effectively nothing. All that said, it’s a good story, and it’s a credit to Davies’ talent as a writer that he was able to pull it off in such fashion.

Arizona Werewolf (1995, dir. Tony Zarindast)

Way back at the beginning of this series, we looked at The Wolf Man, Universal’s most well-known werewolf movie and the one that set up most of the tropes of werewolf stories that followed it. It remains an exceptionally popular film even 80 years later and deservedly so! It’s a very, very good movie, and so it’s no surprise it’s been the measuring stick for other werewolf films.

Our movie this week, however, is the complete opposite of The Wolf Man: it’s Arizona Werewolf, (actually called Werewolf, but I’m using the alternate title provided by Wikipedia to eliminate any confusion) released in the mid-1990s and directed by Tony Zarindast, an Iranian director known for… well, this movie and virtually nothing else. The star power begins and ends with Joe Estevez, younger brother of Martin Sheen (though as they look and sound exactly alike, it’s easy to mix them up).

But its badness is part of the point. I picked this film because I wanted to present something that exists on the complete opposite end of the werewolf movie spectrum from The Wolf Man, and this fits that bill perfectly.

Here’s the plot, to the extent one exists: a team of archaeologists uncover a werewolf skeleton in the Arizona desert, and the psychotic foreman, Yuri, hatches a plot to turn people into werewolves by using the skeleton as his medium. Along the way, a simple “writer” named Paul Niles (who is never seen doing any actual writing) gets mixed up in all this, is soon attacked by Yuri, and begins lycanthropizing himself.

Let me make one thing abundantly clear: this movie is, by pretty much any standard imaginable, a complete train wreck. The majority of the cast are Europeans attempting to play Americans and failing spectacularly, particularly the actress playing Natalie, Paul’s girlfriend. The werewolf costumes don’t look so much like actual wolves or even wolf men as people dressed in ape masks bought on the cheap from one of those pop-up Halloween supply stores that show up every October. The direction and cinematography leave much to be desired, Yuri himself goes through at least five or six separate hairstyles during the course of the film, and the twist ending is so abrupt as to be entirely unguessable.

But there’s more awfulness to this film than just poor construction: an early section of the movie attempts to do something different with werewolf legends by having Noel, the guy in charge of the dig, exposit at length about Navajo legends of yee naaldlooshii (skin-walkers in English), complete botching of the language aside. However, that exposition is entirely pointless: despite contrasting the yee naaldlooshii with the ‘white man’s movie monster’ we’re familiar with and thus implying that anyone who gets infected by the skeleton will become a yee naaldlooshii rather than a typical werewolf, the end result is that Paul, Natalie, and Tommy (the first man to be victimized by Yuri’s ‘modern manmade werewolf’ crusade) all become typical cinematic werewolves.

So why is the yee naaldlooshii thing so awful, even if it never leads anywhere? Here’s Adrienne Keene, who runs the Native Appropriations blog, on what happened when J.K. Rowling tried to pull that same stunt in her history of magic in North America:

What you do need to know is that the belief of these things (beings?) has a deep and powerful place in Navajo understandings of the world. It is connected to many other concepts and many other ceremonial understandings and lifeways. It is not just a scary story, or something to tell kids to get them to behave, it’s much deeper than that. My own community also has shape-shifters, but I’m not delving into that either.

What happens when Rowling pulls this in, is we as Native people are now opened up to a barrage of questions about these beliefs and traditions (take a look at my twitter mentions if you don’t believe me)–but these are not things that need or should be discussed by outsiders. At all. I’m sorry if that seems “unfair,” but that’s how our cultures survive.

Congratulations, Tony Zarindast! You’re a cultural appropriator, just like everyone’s favorite queerphobic anti-Semitic children’s novelist! Fuck you!

There are, however, two bright spots: the first is the character of Sam the Keeper, the armed guy in the hat and sunglasses who looks like Santa Claus crossed with Fidel Castro. He contributes exactly nothing to the plot and only appears in a few scenes, and yet, he has such magnetism and charisma that you kind of want to see more of him. You don’t have to believe me, but that’s the facts!

The other bright spot is also, incidentally, the only version of this movie still commercially available: in 1998, just two years after the film came out, it was featured as the fourth episode in the ninth season of Mystery Science Theater 3000, a show specifically designed to showcase, and sometimes celebrate, bad movies by making jokes about them (or, in the case of truly terrible films like this and Manos: The Hands of Fate, obliterate them with humor).

For those who have never seen the show, the premise is neatly spelled out in the series theme song: a totally average guy named Mike is marooned in outer space with his assortment of robot friends, and he’s forced to watch terrible cinema sent to him by Pearl Forrester, a mad scientist trying to rule the world. To get back at her, Mike and his robot companions talk back at the movies they watch, like the world’s snarkiest DVD commentary track.

Which brings me to Arizona Werewolf. It’s the third werewolf movie the show riffed and easily the best: The Mad Monster from Season 1 suffered from an abysmal-quality print and substandard riffs typical of that run of the show, while I Was A Teenage Werewolf from Season 8, while very good, has yet to be commercially released due to rights issues, and I try to support the show as best I can by buying the legal releases (because the era of “Keep Circulating the Tapes” has been over for 30 years now).

As a movie, Arizona Werewolf is appalling, but as an episode of MST, it’s one of my all-time favorites. Mike and the ‘Bots are merciless, mocking everything from overly-long establishing shots to Natalie’s grasp of the English language and the werewolf costumes. The host segments in between theater scenes are even better, particularly the second, where they sing “Where, Oh Werewolf,” a haunting girl-group number about a girl and her date with her lycanthropic boyfriend Steve gone horribly wrong.

And that, I think, is the best way to watch Arizona Werewolf, unless you feel daring enough to track down the original DVD release off of Amazon and brave the incompetence unriffed. But if you’re like me and you prefer jokes to go with your bad movies, you can buy the episode in question here, direct from the makers of the show.

TUSK!

WolfWalkers (2020, dir. Tomm Moore & Ross Stewart)

WolfWalkers is, without a doubt, a breathtaking film. The script is heartbreaking and heartwarming all at the same time, Mebh’s first meeting with Robyn when the latter runs into the forest to find her bird is hilarious, the visuals are gorgeous, it’s a movie that was made to be watched in the autumn as the chill of the air settles in and leaves fall from the trees. The acting is wonderful from all concerned, especially the children who voice Robyn and Mebh. The score is sumptuous, steeped as it is in traditional Irish Celtic instrumentation. It’s a hundred and two minutes of pure cinema magic, and you owe it to yourselves to see it.

But there’s more to this movie, at least for me personally, than beautiful craftswolfship.

As I’ve said, I’ve felt a strong connection to wolves for a very long time; most of my life, in fact. This movie, about a little girl from England who meets another little girl who can turn into a wolf when she sleeps, didn’t so much as tap into that connection as slam into it with all the force of a train. When Robyn first changes into a wolf and runs into the woods to meet up with Mebh, I felt a deep and powerful yearning to be just like both of them. Sadly, such a thing is impossible: the Werewolves of Ossory, one of the main inspirations for the movie, are completely mythological. I can’t physically change into a wolf – no one can – but imagination is a powerful thing, and mine kicked into high gear.

I’d come out as a therian (someone who feels a strong spiritual pull toward a particular animal) earlier in the year, but watching this movie made me see that I didn’t just have a strong connection to wolves: I felt like I was one, in heart and soul and mind, if not in physical body. Realizing that was a powerful thing, as up until then, I’d been thinking of myself as a trans woman with a strong connection to wolves. But a month and a half after seeing this movie, I figured out that wasn’t quite it.

I was still feminine, that much remained true. But this movie helped me to see I didn’t have to identify as human if I didn’t want to. So I chose not to: I came out as a transfemme non-binary wolf on Twitter, with my own set of pronouns (loup/loupself, by the way) and I owe it all to this film. As I wrote in the accompanying thread, my understanding of myself was well beyond how most people conceive of gender: it doesn’t just have to be whether you feel masculine or feminine but your species too. And when I understood that, I went for it with all four paws.

When I originally came out as trans in early 2015, I was already a furry. I’d been a furry for some time, changing species as often as the Doctor changes faces: at various points I’d been a fox, a chakat, (a fictitious hermaphroditic species of centaur-like cats), even an otter, albeit very briefly. But wolf was the longest-lasting of those faces, and I used my coming-out as an opportunity to ditch the Doctor-like character I’d been hiding behind and start again as my new self. So I commissioned some art: a pencil sketch of my new self, drawn by my dear friend @SkyeLegs on Twitter.

Image

It’s a very realistic drawing, a perfect example of wolf anatomy applied to a humanoid form. And if cross-species transitions ever become possible, and the end result looks even a little like that, I’d sign up for it in a heartbeat. I long to feel the crisp autumn breeze through my fur or the crunch of leaves or snow beneath my paws. I want to step outside in the depths of winter and be completely comfortable because my thick fur coat keeps me warm. I wish to have the keen senses of smell and hearing that my wild siblings have and to feel closer to nature than most humans could even dream of being. It might even happen someday: there’s a group working on it.

But until that day arrives, I have the internet, where I can at least exist in pixels. And I have movies like WolfWalkers to awaken the wolf within me and make her howl. I can’t guarantee that you’ll have the same kind of awakening that I did, but if you ever do, by all means, reach out to me. I can be your guide into wolf-dom, as Mebh was for Robyn.


And that, dear readers, is that. I hope my whistle-stop tour on the moonlit world of werewolves has been enlightening. I hope you’ve found new books to read, new films to watch, new things to try. These are just samplings of a wider world of lycanthropic media, I can’t cover them all, but maybe you can.

I can’t really express how much this little series means to me. While I always put a lot of myself into my writing, nothing I’ve done yet has been as autobiographical as this, and I’ve enjoyed putting myself out there. It feels a bit like a weight has been lifted, in a way; I’ve been completely, one hundred percent honest about me and why I am the way I am. And that feels good!

So… until next time, dear reader. When you next look into the sky on a full moon night, listen for howling. We’ll be singing our song for you.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑