Adventures in Narrative Substitution: Nikola Tesla’s Night of Terror

One of the points I’ve raised consistently during the course of this series has been the strength of the historicals. The Chibnall era has always been one devoted to upholding the status quo, so it’s no great shock that the genre in which the Doctor is most constrained shines brighter than a more traditional science fiction one would. 

Just in this series, we’ve seen the Doctor perform non-consensual mind wipes on Ada Lovelace and Noor Inayat Khan to keep history going the way it’s supposed to, and last season we saw her go to extreme lengths to ensure Rosa Parks’ protest on the bus went as recorded. This is an era of the show that believes Status Quo is God, even when it shouldn’t be.

What sticks out to me about this episode is that it feels, just a for a moment, like the Doctor Who I loved as a young viewer of the Smith years. Of course Tesla and the Doctor get along so well, they’re a lot alike! Eccentric inventors with idiosyncratic methods of problem-solving and passionate as can be about helping other people live their best lives? That sounds like the Doctor I know and love.

But this is still the Chibnall era, and that means some of its godawful centrism creeps in even here. Let’s start with a line of dialogue from the Doctor as she and the Fam are walking the streets of early 1900s New York: “Gilded Age New York. This is when the modern world begins. New ideas, new technologies, new skyscrapers. More people getting rich quick, and more poor people than ever before.” The line itself is alright, but the delivery is way off. The way Jodie reads the line, it almost comes across as a positive, it’d work better as a bitter aside, perhaps from Tosin Cole.

Then a little later on, there’s a line about Tesla himself: “He should have been the first billionaire by now, if he hadn’t have torn up his contract.” As I wrote in the Kerblampost, the Thirteenth Doctor is a capitalist to her bones, in this case she’s just less obvious about it.

If you look at it in the right way, this episode and Orphan 55 form an interesting duology: both are set on Earth in different times, and both have something to say about the world we live in. Orphan 55 was a stark warning about what the future could become if we do nothing to address the climate crisis, and this one shows us how we got there. What Thomas Edison represents, with his focus on patents and other trappings of the business world, is nothing less than pure capitalism at the environment’s expense.

Tesla represents a different way forward. Global communications could have changed drastically if he had been able to completely finance his Wardenclyffe project. He wrote at the time, “As soon as completed, it will be possible for a business man in New York to dictate instructions, and have them instantly appear in type at his office in London or elsewhere,” which does rather sound a bit like the internet. Sadly though, it never happened: as seen in the episode, Tesla repeatedly found it hard to keep funding and eventually ran out of money, and by 1917 the tower had been demolished.

This is how capitalism works. Good ideas die if they don’t immediately make heaps of money for the people involved, and if by some miracle they do become profitable, it’s usually the people like Thomas Edison who pocket the cash and take the credit, while the people who do the real work get left in the dust.

In case it wasn’t obvious, I am not exactly a capitalist. Why would I be? We’re living through a second Gilded Age right now: corporations from California to New York City and beyond are raking in huge profits while the people that work there suffer and struggle to make ends meet. In America, there is no state in the country where you can afford rent on a two-bedroom apartment in a minimum wage job. The fight for a $15 minimum wage has been going on for so long that $15 isn’t even a living wage anymore! 

The system is the problem. The center cannot hold. Just last season we looked at Oxygen, a story that attacked the privatization of basic necessities and the attendant focus on profit above all else. That story ended with the workers starting to resist courtesy of the Doctor, this time I want to go one step further. As John Lennon once sang, “You say you want a revolution? We’d better get it on right away.”

The story we’ll be looking at this time is Planet of the Ood from 2008, starring Broadchurch’s David Tennant as the Doctor. In the story, Ten and Donna visit the Ood, in a direct sequel to the Satanic two parter they were introduced in two seasons earlier, and witness a revolution as the Ood collectively overwhelm their asshole boss, Mr. Halpen. 

In this story and the last one, the Ood are shown as slaves, working for the Second Great and Bountiful Human Empire. Humans have taken over their home planet and built a corporation to sell them across the Empire’s three galaxies. And it’s intensely relatable for those of us who are caught in demeaning jobs like cashiering in a retail store for scraps: in 2021 alone, more Americans are ditching their jobs or going out on strike for better working conditions.

True, it is not a perfect system. Donna’s protestations against what the Ood are put through are undercut slightly by the Doctor asking, “Who do you think made your clothes?” The unspoken answer to that question is “People in a Chinese sweatshop,” and while it is true, it underlines another basic point: there is no ethical consumption under capitalism. The corollary? Ethical consumption is possible, we just have to get rid of capitalism first.

What to replace it with, you ask? Doctor Who has an answer to that too, in the personage of Malcolm Hulke. Hulke was the only Doctor Who writer to be a card-carrying communist, and became one after meeting some Russian POWs during Second World War. Though his actual support of the British communist party waxed and waned throughout the sixties and seventies, he remained on the left throughout his life, and it definitely influenced his Doctor Who work.

Doctor Who and the Green Death was his novelization of the TV story The Green Death, broadcast in 1973. The story centers around Panorama Chemicals, which is busily dumping the toxic waste its new oil refinery process makes into a Welsh mine, creating giant mutant maggots that turn people green and then kill them. Orchestrating this is the BOSS, a talking supercomputer who has learned how to brainwash people.

He’s directly contrasted with Clifford Jones and the folks at Wholewheal, a local scientific hippie commune who have been working on using fungi to make meat-substitutes. (Think the Impossible Whopper at Burger King.) In the TV story, Jones and team were just a bunch of silly hippies, but Hulke’s novelization fleshes them out considerably, making them far more sympathetic. They’re working together for the benefit of everyone, and for a more sustainable existence, while Stevens and the BOSS, essentially, are promoting capitalistic fascism. Eventually they are defeated, and the environmental hippie socialists win! (Also, Jo marries Cliff.)

All of this brings me back to Tesla: “The future is mine,” he says at the end of the episode, and he is broadly right about that, technologically speaking. When it comes to economic systems, we have a lot more work to do, but I do know this: the days of the Edisonian fat cats are numbered. One way or another, we, the people, will rise up and build a better world. Let’s get to work.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑