The odd thing about Doctor Who is that, for a British TV show, it has a weird association with American historical catastrophes: the premiere of the classic series was overshadowed by the murder of President Kennedy in Texas the day before, while Rose premiered exactly two years and six days into the Iraq war.
Looking back from 2022, with September 11th itself just over 20 years in the past, it’s a bit jarring to watch Aliens of London today. More than any other season of the show, series 1 of the revival (or season 27 as some people call it) is aggressively and purposefully a product of British television in the spring of 2005.
While all television gets dated sooner or later, series 1 is an extreme case, since so much of how it works structurally and the types of stories it tells weren’t written to be evergreen, they were made to work only in the context in which it originally aired. Bad Wolf (as in the episode, not the production company or me) is an even more blatant case of this, but it crops up here as well.
Just as The Deadly Assassin fictionalized Kennedy’s assassination by applying it to the Time Lords, Aliens of London does it to 9/11 with an effects shot in which Big Ben is destroyed by a crashing spaceship, which then turns out to be an inside job, as some people thought the WTC attacks were. And if that wasn’t enough, Davies rams the satire home still further by having Joseph Green give almost the exact same justification for launching some nukes that Bush gave to invade Iraq: WMDs that turned out to not exist.
If this story had been broadcast a little closer to 9/11 than it actually was, say in 2002 or ’03, parallels like this might have come off as crass at best and in extreme poor taste at worst. But in 2005, Bush’s approval ratings immediately after the attacks had fallen, and while he did get elected to a second term in the 2004 election, John Kerry (his Democratic opponent) criticized him repeatedly over the war in Iraq, and the war was also one of the main reasons for Democrats winning control of Congress in the following year’s midterm elections. So, the time was right for Doctor Who to make fun of Dubya B and kill off Tony Blair, Bush’s pet lapdog at the time.
But political satire is only half of what’s going on in this story. This is also the one where Rose comes home after adventuring in the TARDIS for the last couple of episodes, and this time, Davies dives into the ramifications: she’s been gone for a whole year from Jackie and Mickey’s perspective, missing presumed dead, and when she does return, Jackie is not pleased:
JACKIE: The hours I’ve sat here, days and weeks and months, all on my own. I thought you were dead, and where were you? Travelling. What the hell does that mean, travelling? That’s no sort of answer. You ask her. She won’t tell me. That’s all she says. Travelling.
ROSE: That’s what I was doing.
JACKIE: When your passport’s still in the drawer? It’s just one lie after another.
ROSE: I meant to phone. I really did. I just I forgot.
JACKIE: What, for a year? You forgot for a year? And I am left sitting here. I just don’t believe you. Why won’t you tell me where you’ve been?
Looking at the situation from Jackie’s perspective, I can’t say I blame her for getting mad, her daughter just up and disappeared with some dude! Kidnapping and missing child cases like these happen all the time, Jackie is well within her rights to read the Doctor and Rose the riot act. Frankly, a guilt trip is honestly Rose getting off easy. (My mother would’ve done that and grounded me, regardless of how old I was.)
Other aspects of the story haven’t aged particularly well: there’s an ugly streak of fatphobia running through the Slitheen and the stated reason for them being played by large actors. The constant farting thing might’ve amused the 11 year old boys in the audience, but I found it tiresome pretty much from the word go.
I do, however, quite like the reason Margaret Blaine gives for going to all this trouble: nuke the Earth so they can sell it for scrap. Between this and Cassandra trying to murder everyone on Platform One so she can fund more surgeries, there’s a definite anti-capitalist theme running through the season so far, and I have to admit, after suffering through the more recent pro-Amazon era, I appreciate this a lot more.
And then there’s Mickey. After spending most of Rose being an Auton victim, in this story he gets two big hero moments: first he saves Jackie’s life when she’s attacked by the Slitheen masquerading as the chief of police, and then in part 2, the Doctor has him blow up Downing Street with a missile to prevent the Slitheen from getting the nuclear launch codes. While all of this is genuinely good stuff, it’s also very difficult to enjoy these days.
Part of this is because of the race issue: He’s the first Black recurring character in the series, and the show’s history with non-white races has never been good. In this story he reveals he was accused of killing Rose and brought in for questioning, made a pariah on the estate, and throughout both episodes the Doctor treats him with undisguised contempt. (Not because he’s Black, thank goodness, but even so, the optics are appalling.) Even the missile scene only happens because there’s no one else available to help! Mickey gets better material in series 2, but the show’s handling of its Black characters still leaves a lot to be desired.
But it’s not just the race aspect either. In 2021, in an exposé by British newspaper The Guardian, Mickey actor Noel Clarke was accused of sexual harassment by no less than twenty separate women, going back to the early part of his career in 2004. And when was the bulk of Series 1 shot? 2004. A followup report by the same paper revealed that Clarke sexually harassed four members of the crew during production of series 1, in particular a costume assistant and a driver. Clarke denied the accusations, as men like him tend to do. Per The Guardian: “His lawyers said any suggestion that he would be allowed to behave that way because of his perceived power was “entirely implausible” because he was near the start of his career.”
That’s really not an excuse. Or rather, it’s an excuse, but it’s a fucking terrible one. If you are Noel Clarke and you’re an actor on one of the biggest shows in British TV at that time, that affords you a certain amount of power. And people like him, given even the smallest amount of power, think that means they get to do whatever they want, to anyone they want.
I’ve seen this dynamic before: Donald Trump, Noel Clarke, Bill Cosby, Kevin Spacey, Louis CK, Sam Maleski, every single one of those men (or in Maleski’s case, masculine-presenting enby person) had the same mentality best summed up by the first person in that list: “When you’re a star, they let you do it. You can do anything.”
The women whom Clarke abused didn’t speak out, except for the driver, who talked to an assistant director and was then reassigned. The driver said she wasn’t aware if executives in charge (which would include Russell T Davies, Julie Gardner, Mal Young, and Phil Collinson) were aware of what Clarke did or not, but I don’t know if that makes a difference: he still got hired, appearing not just in this season, but in the second and in the fourth, all the way until The End of Time.
No doubt he hurt even more people with every appearance, the four I mentioned are just the ones who felt ready to talk. Needless to say, it turns my stomach to see him on screen, playing Rose Tyler’s boyfriend and standing in the same room as Billie Piper and Camille Coduri. I’m appalled he was ever allowed on set for one episode, much less sixteen.
But how I feel is nothing compared to the unimaginable emotions that his victims feel. They probably haven’t watched these episodes, why would they, when a man who hurt them is immortalized forever on screen, having a big hero moment? Yes, there are plenty of other aspects to enjoy about these episodes, but I’m a fan, I have distance. Clarke’s victims don’t.
Frankly, that bin should’ve swallowed him for good.
Leave a Reply