This week, the first Doctor Who Christmas story of the modern era. I said story, not special: the original episode aired in April 2005, not December, and the brevity of Eccleston’s tenure means that he doesn’t really get a “Christmas special” onscreen. (His Doctor gets a few in spin-off media though.) So this is what we’ve got, a story that works perfectly well as a Christmas episode, and given the ghosts and quasi-zombies, a Halloween one as well.
Plot-wise, it’s exactly what you’d expect a story with Charles Dickens set at Christmas to be like: Dickens himself is the Scrooge character, and over the course of experiences with the supernatural, ends the story in a happier place. It’s actually reminiscent (in a retroactive sort of way) of Vincent and the Doctor, which also ends with the celebrity guest being reassured that their work lasts forever. And as with this story, Vincent doesn’t produce any new paintings, but he does modify one of his sunflower ones with the dedication “For Amy.” Gatiss doesn’t quite go that far (in fact he explicitly denies the possibility in dialogue) but the echoes of future past are interesting nonetheless.
So, what do I make of Gatiss’ television debut, given how hard I’ve been on him in Back to the Eleventh Hour? Paw on heart, it’s one of my favorites of his scripts, but it has something of a difficult reputation in that the story’s resolution can be summed up as “Don’t let in the immigrants.” Which is obviously bad, and if that was the point the story was trying to make I’d be ready to dig in with my teeth and claws, as I usually do when I get to a morally objectionable Who story, but I can’t do that because this story is really not actually about how immigrants are evil.
I mean, just look at the final scene of the story: Charles Dickens, enlivened by the night he’s just had, tells the Doctor and Rose how much happier and livelier he is now, and how inspired to write he is, after spending most of the running time rubbishing the mere existence of aliens, then in seances. He’s not happy because the evil immigration ghosts got blown up, he’s happy because he’s seen something new and interesting when he’d thought he’d seen everything there was to see, and he allowed himself to see it. The Doctor repeatedly tries to get him to open his mind to new things and it works! The story is saying, “Don’t be afraid of the unknown, embrace it!” It’s exactly the sort of thing Doctor Who should be doing, and I love it for that.
So while the immigration reading is there, (and Lawrence Miles once attacked this story on those grounds) it’s a mistaken one. Gatiss did not intend to write an anti-immigrant story anymore than Peter Harness did with Kill the Moon as an abortion parable. Both of these things are accidents, plain and simple.
Moving on: I said this was one of my favorite Gatiss stories, which begs the question: what facets of his writing do I actually like? I like, for example, his enthusiasm for Victoriana: not because I’m a fan of the time period or anything, I’m actually ambivalent about it, (though I do like the aesthetic, especially Rose’s dress) but because his obvious enthusiasm and fondness of that time bleeds into this story, it’s absolutely palpable. If you’ve got a passion, indulge in it, and Gatiss indulges in this with gusto. (That the BBC can do period drama in its sleep is also very convenient.)
Then there’s just the basic mechanics of writing TV drama, and I have to admit, after suffering through an era of the show where basic competence was in short supply, something like this is a breath of fresh air. He has an excellent grasp of dialogue and character: the entire scene with the Doctor praising and then complaining to Dickens about an element of one of his stories is absolutely hilarious, and I adore the bit where Gwyneth points out to Rose how patronizing she’s being when Rose tells her she doesn’t understand what’s happening with the Gelth. (Meanwhile there’s the Doctor, helpfully translating his explanations into something the people of 1869 can wrap their heads around.)
The man can write and he can do it well, were it not for his lack of interest in the job, I would’ve pegged him as a future showrunner. He probably would’ve done something steeped in the Doctor Who of the mid-1970s, specifically the Hinchcliffe era, maybe with some Sixties flourishes. I don’t know if it would’ve been a runaway success (probably not) but even so, you do wonder what could have been sometimes.
Gatiss is not, however, a perfect writer. His Classic Who fanboyishness, while more often endearing, can be frustrating: Unquiet Dead bears a strong resemblance, setting-wise and tonally, to The Talons of Weng-Chiang, an appallingly racist story that is beloved by a large and vocal contingent of fandom, especially ones of Gatiss’ and Davies’ vintages: Eccleston, reportedly, watched Talons to prepare for his role as the Doctor on Davies’ suggestion, make that of what you will. (On the other paw, Moffat had Matt Smith watch Tomb of the Cybermen, so it’s not like my favorite writer has his hands clean either.)
That said, Unquiet Dead is a strong start to a reasonably solid Who career. One interesting detail I found while researching the story for this post was how they got Simon Callow, a Dickens scholar and someone who’s played him on TV before: he would only play the role if he liked the material, and needless to say, he did. Callow’s performance is exceptional, while watching the story I got so drawn into his part that I almost felt like I was watching the genuine article! Put an image of him in this story next to an image of the actual Dickens, and you’d swear they cloned him.
And speaking of famous Victorian writers who end up in fictional situations similar to the ones in their books, I really ought to go and finish The Sherlockian… join me next week for our first two-parter, the one with the Slitheen.
Leave a Reply