And here we are again, talking about the best Dalek story of the revival. Last time we were here I was writing about the novelization, in a post that no less than ROBERT FREAKING SHEARMAN complimented me on. But this week we tackle the original TV episode: Christopher Eccleston’s first Dalek story, and just like the book, it’s an absolute delight from start to finish.
Every time I watch this story, I notice something new about it. Let’s start with the obvious: while this isn’t the first story to mention the Time War or its grisly ending, it is the first story to focus on the Doctor’s role in events:
DOCTOR: They’re never going to come! Your race is dead! You all burnt, all of you. Ten million ships on fire. The entire Dalek race wiped out in one second.
DALEK: You lie!
DOCTOR: I watched it happen. I made it happen.
DALEK: You destroyed us?
DOCTOR: I had no choice.
DALEK: And what of the Time Lords?
DOCTOR: Dead. They burnt with you. The end of the last great Time War. Everyone lost.
And for eight years, this was what we had. The Doctor did something horrible to end a war that had gone on for far too long and killed an incalculably large number of innocent people, and in the process, committed genocide twice over. Watching his performance in this scene, you can very easily buy that it would’ve been Eccleston’s Doctor who pushed the button. His trauma and guilt at what he did is palpable indeed: he’s not proud, nor should he be.
So, question: what happens to the Doctor at the end of the Time War? One version of events was that the Eighth Doctor died and became someone else, a warrior, specifically to go to battle on the front lines. He didn’t become Eccleston though: he became John Hurt, and fought for so long that he aged into an old man, with his final regeneration into Eccleston occurring (presumably) shortly after his use of the Moment.
But there’s another story here, a way things almost unfolded. In 2020, Russell T Davies unveiled a short story he’d originally written in 2013 for the fiftieth anniversary, depicting in prose form the regeneration of the Eighth Doctor into the Ninth. Titled Doctor Who and the Time War and designed like a Target book that doesn’t exist, it’s a brilliant little short story, and exactly what I’d expect from the guy who created the Time War in the first place.
But I did say almost. As Davies wrote in his introduction, Steven Moffat surprised everyone with the reveal of the War Doctor, and then did it again with The Night of the Doctor, Eight’s first TV story in 17 years. Time War became non-canon, and was mothballed until the 15th anniversary of Rose, when it landed as a prequel to that story.
So, was RTD’s short story the original ending of the Time War? No War Doctor, no Bad Wolf!Moment? It might’ve been. In a universe where Eccleston returned to join his two successors for The Day of the Doctor, it probably would’ve fit very nicely, it’s even possible to imagine it being filmed and made into a parallel version of Night of the Doctor. And maybe, in the universe next door from ours, that’s exactly what happened!
But in our universe, Eccleston said no to returning, and so the character of the War Doctor was made to fill the gap between Eight and Nine. And yes, as in The Day of the Doctor, it turns out Gallifrey doesn’t burn at all, it just gets transported into another universe/the end of time, safely hidden away. As it turns out, Rose is right when she says at the end, “The Dalek survived. Maybe some of your people did too.” And of course she’s right, she’s the Bad Wolf, she made it happen.
But because there were thirteen Doctors saving Gallifrey together, out-of-sync timelines filling the air like an oncoming storm, Nine doesn’t remember it. As far as he’s concerned, everything he tells the Dalek in the cage scene is still 100% accurate, as is his reply to Rose’s statement: “I’d know. In here Feels like there’s no one.”
Does the reveal that Gallifrey was restored change anything about Dalek, as a story? I’d say no. Every effort was made to respect what had gone before, it’s only the Doctor’s actions that have changed, and even then, he still remembers the old events. Memories are fickle things, people can be convinced they saw Bugs Bunny at Disney World even though, for legal reasons, such a thing is impossible. The Doctor is acting throughout the story using the information available to him at the time, and no amount of Gallifrey being alternately destroyed, saved, and then destroyed again can change that.
At the end of the day, this story is about the relationship between the Doctor and the Dalek. They have defined each other by opposition from the show’s very earliest days, and the conflict between them takes a new course when the Dalek realizes that as far as its concerned, there is exactly no difference between itself and the Predator, at least as far as vehement hatred goes. The Doctor’s reaction is to prove its point, between throwing around “Ex-term-in-ate” and repeatedly ordering it to kill itself.
The unspoken question is, could the Doctor have actually pulled the trigger and shot the Dalek, if Rose hadn’t been there to stop him? The original ending of the War suggests yes, but as we’ll see in The Parting of the Ways, when faced with a near-identical situation, he can’t. Because then he wouldn’t be the Doctor anymore. The Doctor fights the Daleks because he must, because they represent everything he opposes, to sink down to their level means he’s giving up the fight. That’s why “You would make a good Dalek” has the sting it does.
Good grief, Dalek is brilliant. The performances, the plot, the sheer amount of emotional drama Shearman was able to wring out of the Doctor and the Dalek, the fact that Rose gives it the Human Factor and freaks it out to no end… it’s all amazing!
I have wondered what might have been, though: what if the Dalek had chosen to live, and continued to mutate? Would it have become human? Or maybe it would’ve ended up like Rusty from Into The Dalek, turning its egg-whisk on its own kind rather than the rest of the universe. We’ll never know, of course, but it’s interesting to contemplate. One possible answer lies at the end of the novelization, but I won’t give details: it’s really something you have to find out for yourself. I will say this though: it will make you feel for the Dalek.
Next week: It’s Doctor Who in an exciting adventure with Rupert Murdoch, except he looks like Replacement Scotty.
Leave a Reply