Let’s just get one thing out of the way: this is not going to be a typical Big Finish review. I will not, for example, be talking about how this set fits in with the Eighth Doctor’s character arc because quite frankly, I don’t have the faintest idea. I haven’t heard any of his post-Charley audios until now, so if you’re looking for that, I’d suggest going somewhere else.
What I will be talking about is Rebecca Root’s character in this set, AKA the first transgender companion in Doctor Who ever. (Unless you count Missy. Which you should.) This is a moment I never dreamed would come, especially given the rampant transphobia in the UK. But now that it’s here, I have exactly one question: Can Big Finish, a company that has only recently begun attempting to shed its public image (at least among the circles of leftist Who fandom where I live) of being a club for cisgender white men of a certain age, manage to pull something this important off without screwing it up? I certainly hope so.
First though, some context. One of the big issues with trans rep in mainstream media is that, by and large, these tend to be stories written by and for cisgender audiences, and nine times out of ten, they hire cisgender actors to play trans characters. For example, the last big TV show I remember focusing on people like me was Amazon’s Transparent, a show where the central character, a trans woman, was played by Jeffrey Tambor, a cis man.
Oh sure, he won two Emmys and a Golden Globe for his performance and dedicated his first win to our community, but it’s a little hard to credit that as good rep when, A) cis men playing trans women is depressingly common even now in this allegedly more enlightened age, and B) He was later accused sexual assault by another actor on the show, an actual trans woman no less, leading to Amazon firing him.
Another problem with trans rep in mainstream media, aside from the above, is that the stories we’re depicted in are almost always about our transitions. I mean, I almost get it. Yes, it is awe inspiring to watch us change. Goddess knows I used to watch hundreds of transition timeline videos when I was first questioning my identity. But there is so much more to us than transitioning. We’re human beings too! (Well, except me, but not everyone can be a sexy anthro wolf.) We have all the same goals and dreams and stuff that cis people do! But all I ever see is shit endlessly obsessed with our transitions. Maybe that would change if we were allowed to write our own stories and get them filmed, but that’s another post.
Which brings me Boy Meets Girl. That was a BBC Two sitcom that aired in 2015 and 2016, and was the UK’s first ever trans-focused situation comedy about a trans woman named Judy. In a refreshing change of pace, she’s played by the aforementioned Rebecca Root, who is trans herself, and the show isn’t even really about her transition, but the budding romance she forms with her cisgender boyfriend, Leo. Having come out earlier in the same year myself, a show like this was an absolute revelation for me, and it still ranks as one of my favorite TV shows.
Naturally, I was ecstatic when I heard Root would not only be featured in the cast of Stranded, but that her character would be trans as well. As soon as I heard that, I knew I’d have to review it, so here we are. Enough set-up, let’s get to work.
Episode 1: Lost Property by Matt Fitton
The premise of the set is this: after some shenanigans, the Doctor and his current companions Liv and Helen land on Earth in 2020. The TARDIS is dead, forcing them to seek refuge in a house the Doctor owns on Baker Street. (Not 221b, but he lives a few doors down, and it’s implied he and Mr. Holmes once knew each other.)
The house has since been turned into a block of apartments by the guy the Doctor later left the house to, someone called Thomas Brewster. Among the house’s residents is Rebecca Root’s character, Tania Bell. Her first big scene comes 19 minutes into the first episode, in which she makes Liv some hot chocolate, and they chat about their lives. We learn, for example, that Tania used to fight with her parents right up until they kicked her out, suggesting that her coming out to them as trans didn’t go very well. (Can I ever relate.)
By all appearances, Tania seems like most of the show’s companions: an entirely ordinary woman from contemporary Earth, like Barbara Wright, Sarah Jane Smith, or Evelyn Smythe before her. The story’s conflict begins when mysterious thefts take place: a new resident of the house has his video game console stolen, and Tania, along with Liv and Helen, talk to the rest of the residents to find out more about what’s going on, given the increasing paranoia filling the place.
The increase in tensions, we learn, comes from an alien security system called the Pandora Bolt, a two-part system which works by keeping people away from a given place by increasing paranoia and suspicion using psionic projections. The Doctor was hoping to use it as an interface to restart the TARDIS, but the resulting chaos and discord leads him to decide it’s too much trouble, so he shorts it out instead.
In the aftermath, Tania places a mysterious phone call, and cryptically assures the other person on the line that the “level 2 activity” has been resolved, and that she’ll deal with things for now. It definitely seems like there’s more to her than meets the eye, though thankfully, her trans status isn’t one of them.
Episode 2: Wild Animals by John Dorney
In this episode, there are no alien monsters or technology to deal with, just the entirely ordinary realities of life. Liv, who has by this point taken a job as a cashier in a convenience store, gets shot during an attempted robbery. The Doctor spends most of the episode trying to avenge Liv (who survives, incidentally) much to the frustration of the cops and Helen.
Meanwhile, Tania spends most of the episode checking in on Liv as she recovers, culminating in a scene 9 minutes from the end of the story in which she asks Liv out to dinner, as a date and everything. (Tania does say it doesn’t have to be a date, but Liv replies that a date is fine.)
And then… the big moment comes. Tania tells Liv that she’s trans, sending this reviewer into a fit of joy and euphoria and HOLY FUCKING SHIT THIS IS ACTUALLY HAPPENING OH MY GOD I LOVE IT.
Seriously. Trying to describe things is kind of my entire job, but there are no words in the English language for me to properly put into words the kinds of emotions I was feeling the first time I heard the words “I’m trans” being spoken in a Doctor Who story, voiced by an honest-to-god trans woman no less. It was indescribably amazing, and it makes me profoundly happy.
What makes this entire moment relatable is how Rebecca delivers the lines. Speaking as a trans woman myself, you really do get the sense she was drawing on her own experiences in life, coming out to various people, and not just acting. There’s a lot of caution and uncertainty in her delivery here, which makes sense because coming out to anyone is a terrifying experience. Even when you’re sure the other person will take the news well, you still feel afraid. (I came out to another trans person once, and felt this way.)
Is it irrational? Sometimes, maybe, but not always. Not everyone does take the news well. Tania’s parents didn’t, and neither did mine. So when someone does take a coming-out in stride, as Liv does, it means the entire world to us.
At times like these, when the British and American governments are doing everything in their respective powers to make being transgender as difficult as they possibly can, a simple story about a trans woman asking another woman out on a date, and being accepted for who she is, is one of the best things anyone can ever write.
For that reason alone, Wild Animals is one of my absolute favorite Doctor Who stories.
Episode 3: Must-See TV by Lisa McMullin
The third story begins with a police officer coming to the door and asking if Tania is in (she is, but Liv says the opposite) and a mysterious phone call from Tania to someone else. She agrees to meet them at a cafe, and after hanging up, mutters “Bloomin’ Torchwood…” At which point we dive into the theme music.
Later, Liv and Tania talk about all this. When Liv asks if Tania’s in trouble, Tania replies “You have no idea, but not the sort you mean.” Liv asks for more detail, but Tania can’t say anything more. As it turns out, Tania is a Torchwood agent, and Andy (the police officer from earlier) is there to check on her because, according to him, she’s been too quiet for too long, and breaking the rules of non-interference by going on a date with Liv, so they bugged the house as well. (Tania finds out and has Andy remove the bugs… but not all of them.)
She knows the Eighth Doctor shouldn’t know about Torchwood at this point in his time stream… and then the Doctor finds the alien tech buried in the back of one of the flat’s TV sets broadcasting their own actions. And Torchwood, as we know from their introduction in Army of Ghosts, kind of has a thing for repurposing alien technology for their own use. Looks like the Doctor’s about to find out about Torchwood whether Tania likes it or not.
Unfortunately, all this subterfuge seems to be putting her relationship with Liv on the rocks. Liv, understandably, doesn’t like that Tania’s hiding things from her, and isn’t reassured by Tania insisting that she can be trusted. At the end of the story though, with the plot resolved, they seem to make up and move on together, having a quiet date together, during which they decide a “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy regarding each others’ secrets. Maybe not the best idea, but given the circumstances, it’s all they’ve got.
Episode 4: Divine Intervention by David K Barnes
The final story in the set begins in an unexpected place: with Tania, Liv, Helen, and Robin watching the Doctor on a quiz show which sounds to me like a lawyer-friendly version of Who Wants To Be A Millionaire. He wins the prize money, (£80,000!) which he plans on using to get the TARDIS working again.
However, Liv and Helen think that he should use the money to fix up the house. An argument ensues and the Doctor runs off to Tania’s flat. She lets him ramble, and then points him in the direction of a shop in Kilburn… and once he’s gone, she tells Andy where she sent him.
Meanwhile, when the Doctor comes to apologize to Liv, she reveals that she has a date with Tania set up in Camden, which he then invites himself to, as though he’s Peppermint Patty inviting herself to Charlie Brown’s Thanksgiving dinner. (He’s treating the entire house to a meal, but still. Not cool, Doc.)
I wish I could write about the date, but I can’t because it doesn’t actually happen. Instead, it gets interrupted by the Doctor being chased by a pair of reptilian alien assassins, who claim he committed crimes against their species in his personal future. They’ve come back to kill him before he can commit those crimes, so they can save their race.
It doesn’t work, of course. The resulting time paradox causes the TARDIS to restart, at least a little bit, and the Doctor’s would-be killers are thrown into separate time zones. Tania doesn’t get much to do once the sci-fi plot kicks in, but at the end of the story, she does go down to a pub with Liv, who promises to tell her the truth at last.
Final Thoughts
Overall, Stranded is a fascinating new take on how to tell a Doctor Who story. I enjoyed the set very much, and I look forward to future installments. But what really makes me happy is that not only do we finally have a trans companion for the first time ever, but her being trans isn’t even a plot point! It’s completely unremarkable, and coming as it does in a landscape of trans-inclusive media that remains focused on transition at the exclusion of all else, it’s a breath of fresh air.
BF’s next challenge: get an actual trans person to write for Tania.
Leave a Reply