Let’s talk about Space and Time. Not the dimensional concepts, but the comedy sketches shown in mid-March 2011 as part of the BBC’s Comic Relief telethon. Shown in two parts, the story plays for comedy what Series 6’s The Girl Who Waited will later play for drama: putting two versions of Amy together in the same place and seeing what happens afterwards.
Like his previous Comic Relief story, The Curse of Fatal Death, Space/Time is Moffat writing Doctor Who as a sex comedy, the kind of thing he used to do before scaring the hell out of seven year olds by making garden statuary terrifying. (And cracks in walls, and ticking clocks, and gas masks, and actual seven year olds wondering where their moms are, and…)
And to be fair, he is very good at doing this, even when River isn’t around. (But especially when she is.) The problem is that he also tends to make the same mistakes that other men do when it comes to writing women, and that’s demean them for the sake of a joke. Which is, obviously, A Bad Thing. Moffat fan though I am, even I will admit he’s kind of sexist. Just not always in the way his detractors usually portray him.
Recall that the entire chain of events began when Rory looked through the TARDIS’ glass floor and up at his wife’s skirt. Some detractors simplify this to “male companion looking up woman’s skirt and thus they are a pervert,” but there is some Necessary Context here, which is that THEY GOT MARRIED LIKE TWO FUCKING EPISODES AGO. RORY ISN’T SOME RANDO, HE’S AMY’S HUSBAND. That doesn’t excuse it, of course, but context is important.
Now, okay, Rory only looks up Amy’s skirt because he and the Doctor were discussing Amy’s bad driving skills and the circumstances under which she got her license, and the conversation suggests that she only passed because of what she was wearing. You can either take this as Steven Moffat blaming Amy for dressing immodestly, (and that Amy takes the blame for causing the TARDIS to crash a few lines later seems to imply that this is exactly what’s going on) or you can take it as commentary on the habits of men when gazing upon attractive women like Karen Gillan.
I mean, for crying out loud, the Doctor never even places blame on Amy initially, instead he says “Oh, Rory!” In the exact same tone of voice you’d use when you just discovered your dog pooped on the kitchen floor. Again. (We’ll get to the trousers line later.) Amy isn’t actually at fault here, Rory is the one to blame.
From there, we move on into a plot that is not unlike the first episode of Logopolis, with the TARDIS materializing inside itself, or another Moffat-penned mini-episode, 2007’s Time Crash, which also had a TARDIS inside itself, multiple versions of the same person on screen at once, and enough predestination paradoxes to give Beethoven a headache.
But none of that is really the point here. Sure, the sci-fi stuff is entertaining enough, and I’m always in the mood for women flirting with each other even if the timeline could fall apart in the act of doing so, but. At the end of the day, this is still a comedy sketch largely about women as sexual objects. I mean, this is the same writer who, the first time the Doctor regenerated into a woman, had her make a joke about acquiring etheric beam locators. It’s one thing when a trans woman says it, and quite another when a cis guy has a previously-male character say it. Sure, it’s a punchline, but it’s not a funny one.
At the end of the story, with the crisis resolved and the TARDIS back in normal flight, the Doctor says: “But just in case, Pond, put some trousers on.” Which… yeah. It’s a bad line. It’s an unfunny punchline to a story that, entertaining as it is, still leans into objectifying women. Criticizing women for what they’re wearing is exactly what high school principals do when they have their school dress codes punish teenage girls for wearing spaghetti-strap tank tops, or insist upon having skirts be knee-length and no shorter. It’s our society’s penchant for victim blaming rather than actually attempting to solve the problem at hand. It’s shameful and appalling and has absolutely no business being included in a script for a charity comedy sketch, or anywhere else.
Doctor, Amy shouldn’t have to put trousers on if she doesn’t want to. (And thank goodness for Karen Gillan following that up with an eye-roll.) If anything, Rory needs to work on his “not looking up Amy’s skirt” skills. (And the Doctor needs to get rid of the glass floor, but that’s not for another season and a half.) And men need to stop sexualizing women for the sake of a cheap laugh.
To his credit, Moffat leans on the sex comedy tropes less and less as his tenure goes on, and when he does return to them, he isn’t quite as bad about them as he is here. (The exception is Twice Upon A Time, but that’s another article.) Because unlike, say, Joss Whedon or Aaron Sorkin, Moffat learns from his mistakes and makes genuine attempts to improve and grow. Capaldi-era Moffat is a much better writer than Smith-era Moffat, and I say this as someone who loves the Smith years with all her fuzzy heart. Frankly, you’d have to be willfully ignorant not to see that.
And if you are that willfully ignorant… well, that just says a hell of a lot more about you than it does about Steven Moffat.
Leave a Reply