The RTD Rewind: Father’s Day

This week, another adventure in Earth’s past, but unlike pretty much every historical since Marco Polo, we’re not traveling to meet a famous historical figure. Instead, the show goes into Rose’s personal past: the day her father died, November 7th, 1987. (Between the first two episodes of Delta and the Bannermen, incidentally.)

This is kind of a huge moment, since it represents a shift in how the show interacts with its original time period. From 1963 onwards, to do a story set in that part of the 20th century meant doing a contemporary Earth adventure like Planet of Giants, parts of Logopolis, or The Faceless Ones. While in a way all contemporary Earth episodes become historicals sooner or later simply because of time passing since a given story’s airdate, they were still made in what was considered to be the present day, while a historical is obviously not that.

Remembrance of the Daleks is technically the first story to do a historical set within the show’s transmission history, but Remembrance was only made in 1988, still within the same century as An Unearthly Child. Father’s Day, being made in an entirely different century and millennium, means the gap between 2005 and 1987 feels wider even if it’s actually smaller. (18 years vs 25.) And being shot on videotape as the McCoy era was, it even looks like 1980s Who, ignoring the more impressive CGI.

But all of this is window dressing compared to the real story going on: the story of Rose Tyler and her family. Wanting to go back in time and stop the senseless death of someone you love is an entirely understandable emotion, we all have experienced it at least once, though only Rose (being a fictional character in a show where time travel is possible) can actually do it.

Watching this story immediately after The Long Game, and I can kind of see where the Doctor’s coming from: just after an adventure with an opportunistic shithead threatening to change time, here’s the woman he declared to be “the best” going and doing something that, from his perspective, is more of the same: “It’s not about showing you the universe. It never is. It’s about the universe doing something for you.”

In that same conversation, he rhetorically asks: “My entire planet died. My whole family. Do you think it never occurred to me to go back and save them?” Goodness, has the meaning of this line changed a lot since 2005. We now know that he did go back in time and save Gallifrey, he just doesn’t remember it. He did exactly what Rose does here, but with the understanding that the end result (Gallifrey appearing to be destroyed) still had to happen. Pete choosing to sacrifice himself at the end does the same thing: the details may have shifted (note the change in Jackie’s voice at the beginning flashback scene versus the ending one) but the end result is still the same. Pete Tyler dies, and Rose gets to have closure.

This kind of direction in the storytelling breathes new life into the historical genre, just as The Time Meddler did some 40 years earlier. Prior to that, the historical could be basically summed up as “The Doctor and friends visit an interesting period in Earth’s past,” with no science fiction elements save for the regulars and the TARDIS. What The Time Meddlerdid was introduce the concept of alien interference with Earth’s past, and that’s the mode the vast majority of historical stories have been in since: now, the Doctor can fight aliens in time as well as space!

Father’s Day takes the pseudo-historical concept introduced by Meddler and applies it to the companion’s own personal history, making for a far more personal story than the classic series would’ve dared to try and do, with the exception of Ghost Light, where the Seventh Doctor takes Ace back into the past of a house she’d burned down, among other things.

And yet, for some reason or another, this kind of thing doesn’t really recur in the show again. Listen has elements of this idea with the trip back into the ‘90s, except that it’s Danny’s past we visit rather than Clara’s, while Demons of the Punjabbarely highlights Yaz at all, in an episode that was allegedly meant to be her showcase story.

Indeed, the only story that does anything close to this with regard to making the companion as important to the show’s standard operating procedure as this story does isn’t a historical at all, but an alien planet story: 2013’s The Rings of Akhaten. In that story, the Eleventh Doctor takes Clara to the titular planet, where they are forced to fight off a giant sun god that has just woken up from its nap.

The Doctor tries to defeat it with the power of continuity and Time Lord Angst, and he fails. What’s 1000 years of Doctor Who episodes to someone who has probably been around since the beginning of the universe? What does work: Clara’s leaf. That leaf caused her parents to meet each other, and Clara’s mother later gave it to her. In Rings, Clara describes the leaf as “the most important leaf in human history,” figuring that the sun god won’t be able to withstand the sheer amount of infinite potential the leaf contains.

Rings is an absolutely gorgeous story, albeit a heart-breaking one. Quite why it seems to come in toward the bottom of fan polls is bewildering, and admittedly well beyond the scope of this post. What I can say is that it absolutely deserves to stand alongside Father’s Day and The Girl Who Waited as one of the best companion-focused episodes, and anyone who thinks otherwise is free to enjoy their wrong opinion.

As for Father’s Day itself, I am honestly glad Cornell decided to depict Pete Tyler not as the man of Rose’s dreams, but as a lovable loser whose marriage is almost certainly doomed. It’s a more honest illustration of how our views of our parents change as we grow older, and he was right to do it. No parent is perfect, and I’m glad the show leaned into that.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑