It isn’t often that I get to talk about the works of a given showrunner outside their own era. But I’m going to this time, because good grief, one look at this story and you can immediately tell that it was written by the man responsible for the sci-fi fairytale that was the Matt Smith era. Indeed, this story feels for me like a pre-Revolutionary French take on The Eleventh Hour, down to a scene in which the Doctor investigates something peculiar in a seven year old’s bedroom.
Just check out the dialogue in that scene:
“If you were a thing that ticked and you were hiding in someone’s bedroom, first thing you do, break the clock. No one notices the sound of one clock ticking, but two? You might start to wonder if you’re really alone.”
It may be David Tennant delivering these lines, but to my ears they might as well have been said by Matt Smith. Watch the equivalent scene in The Eleventh Hour straight after this and you’ll see that Smith was intentionally mirroring Tennant’s performance, according to the audio commentary. And did he ever do a good job!
There are more mirrors here too: The Doctor meets Reinette as a seven year old girl, just like Amelia, and becomes her imaginary friend. His visits with her are separated (for her) through large passages of time, from months to years. In time he gets snogged by her (though in Ten’s case it’s apparently very willing) and eventually offers her the chance to travel in time with him. She enthusiastically agrees and waits “two minutes,” only for those two minutes to drag on and on. At the end of the story, she’s dead, and the Doctor is alone… at least until he joins back up with Rose and Mickey.
One realization I had when writing this post is that, throughout his time on the show, Moffat never does a straight “Doctor invites companion to go traveling” scene, something always ends up subverting it somewhat. Let’s go down the list: Amy gets delayed a bunch and when the Doctor is finally able to ask her, she turns him down at first and treats the whole business with no small amount of skepticism, Victorian Clara dies, Cass (from The Night of the Doctor) would sooner die rather than travel with him and so kills them both, and Bill has to essentially convince the Doctor to take her on.
And as mentioned above, Reinette dies. And given the parallels she has with Amy, it’s very easy to imagine something akin to The Girl Who Waited happening with Amy in Leadworth: instead of cynical and angry because the Doctor left her behind with a bunch of robots for company, she could’ve been cynical and angry because her stories about the Raggedy Doctor, eventually, made her a social pariah or something. Talk about harsh.
Indeed, if you wanted to pick an episode that basically contains almost everything about the Moffat era but is not, strictly speaking, part of it, this would be your best bet. (Admittedly we’re missing River, but the script apparently contained out-of-order meetings between Reinette and the Doctor, only for that to get changed for the final episode.)
So, given that this episode has long since been regarded as a classic of both its own era and the man who wrote it, it seems strange to me that the name “Steven Moffat” is now associated, at least in some corners of the internet, with such hatred and disgust that he can’t even do an adaptation of a book he’d stolen liberally from without being attacked for it. His interests haven’t changed much since 2006. If you want proof, re-read his 2020 lockdown short for the Thirteenth Doctor, Terror of the Umpty-Ums, and come up with a list of where specific bits and pieces have come up before. It’s a long list!
As a case in point: The Girl in the Fireplace, at a very basic level, is a fairytale romance that ends in tragedy, with the Doctor alone. It’s the only way a story like this can possibly end. Even The Husbands of River Song does it: that is the story of the last time the Doctor and River see each other before the Library, and the only time when both of them are on a level playing field, more or less.
The story of Series 2, in many ways, is going along the same lines: the Doctor can never truly have a relationship of the romantic variety, because the other person will eventually leave, as he tells Rose in School Reunion. Fireplace doesn’t exactly short-change her relationship with the Doctor, but it does make clear that the road she’s going down is one headed toward inevitable heartbreak.
And as for the Doctor? I’m sorry, but he was a cruel bastard, leading Rose, Reinette, and arguably Sarah Jane on like that the way he did. Sarah Jane at least was able to call him out on it, and she was right to do so, but Reinette and Rose are denied even that much. I’ve dated women who treated me like that, and it’s not fun. Reinette at least dies knowing that the Doctor will likely not return in time to take her anywhere, but Rose? She gets banished to a parallel world, then comes back two seasons later explicitly to see him again, and ends up with his human counterpart instead.
A lot has been written over the years about the Tenth Doctor and his hubris: the cleverest man in the room, the one who knows better and isn’t afraid to show it, the Time Lord who walks in eternity. We saw it with Harriet Jones and the way he shouts down the Sisters of Plentitude in New Earth, and in his and Rose’s cavalier attitudes in Tooth and Claw. The tangles of this story and Doomsday are as much an indicator of this Doctor’s hubris as anything else, and as such, they are entirely his fault. And it’s telling that the next time the Doctor goes near this mode again, he’s the one who gets his memory wiped.
Leave a Reply