I already know what I’m going to say: this was one of the best episodes of the series. Partly this is because it was a historical, (and the historicals have all been excellent this year) but also because this is more of a traditional historical in the way that Rosaand Demons of the Punjab weren’t. The main rule of historical stories this year has been, “The Doctor doesn’t interfere.” Indeed, that’s the first thing she says at the top of the episode, just after the titles. Thankfully, the trend is immediately subverted when the Doctor dives in to save an old woman.
What we have here is a story not unlike James Moran’s The Fires of Pompeii, with 17th century Lancashire (which is entirely devoid of four thousand holes, incidentally) in place of Pompeii, and the Morax instead of the Pyroviles. We’ve even got a character who we later learn is working for the villain: Lucius in Pompeii, and Becca here. In other aspects it’s like The Eaters of Light from Series 10, mostly from an atmospheric prospective (cold, wintry landscapes), and the Doctor being presented as a magical figure, and the homoromantic sexuality content, specifically Bill’s discussion of her love of women, compared to James I’s very obvious attraction to Ryan.
Another thing I love: Akinola’s score, switching synths for acoustic string instruments like violins and cellos. Musically, you really get a 17th century vibe, I half expected a harpsichord to show up.
And Jodie! Dear god, was she ever on fire this week! FINALLY, after spending the majority of the season having nothing to do (except Tsuranga Conundrum, which for all its flaws does give her a more traditional Doctor role in the plot), she finally gets to sink her teeth into a script and she acts the shit out of it! She shows up, something bad happens, she runs in to help, and works to stop the witch hunts from happening! That’s the kind of Doctor I need right now!
One other story this episode reminded me of was The Good Doctor, set during this series. In both stories, the Doctor now has to deal with the ramifications of being a woman in a society controlled by men, and James I mistakes Graham as the Witchfinder General as the adherents of the Good Doctor mistook him for… well, guess who. And I loved that book, so this episode is, for me, the closest thing to that book we’ve had on TV.
The only things I didn’t like… well, the accents were all ridiculously Northern, and as I’m an American watching a pirated version with no subtitles, I had to really listen carefully to what everyone was saying, and I’m pretty sure I missed things. That’s not a fault of the actors though. I also wasn’t too sure about James’ obsession with Ryan, it carried uncomfortable echoes of how Shakespeare treated Martha in The Shakespeare Code. That said, Cumming’s performance was very enjoyable, injecting some comedy into an otherwise dour season. From a representation standpoint… ew. If that’s what passes for queer rep, I wish they hadn’t bothered.
In the end, after the crushing disaster that was last week, it’s nice to have an episode of Doctor Who that really, honestly, properly feels like Doctor Who, without any of the flaws that have plagued this series so far. The Doctor isn’t a passive figure, she gets to be right in the middle of the action. In a strange sort of way, it gives me a little bit of the magic and sparkle we’ve been missing. Figured it’d be an episode about witches.
Ranking: 10/10. (Yes, again!)
Leave a Reply