The RTD Rewind: Rise of the Cybermen/The Age of Steel

I’ve said it before, I’ll say it again: the guest episodes remain the strong point of the Chibnall era. Even Kerblam, for all its appalling politics, felt like a well-constructed Doctor Who episode, as did Demons, Witchfinders, and now this. In fact, I’d even say that this week’s episode was the strongest of the lot.

In a lot of ways, this episode reminds me a lot of Hide, from Series 7. We have a big empty house, a strange and unknown threat, a dimensional gateway, and a sudden twist that takes what started out as a traditional base-under-siege into something entirely different. In Hide, it was a love story, but here it’s a meditation on grief and missing the people you love.

This episode also reminds me a little of a Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episode, “Through the Looking Glass” from season 3. There, Commander Sisko ventures to the mirror universe (from the Original Series episode “Mirror Mirror”) and meets his own dead wife, Jennifer, who is alive in this universe.

The parallels are obvious: an alternate universe (in the case of Doctor Who, accessible by a mirror), the dead loved one of a character being alive. But as ever, there’s more to it than that. Graham can’t take Grace back through to our world, because she isn’t Grace at all, but a lure designed by the Solitract. Which, of course, isn’t a bad thing either, it’s just that the two forms of energy can’t co-exist in the same place, like trying to mix matter and anti-matter.

One of the problems I’ve had with this series (among very many) is its refusal to follow up on previously established plot points. The Woman Who Fell to Earth set up half a dozen little plot elements that could have made for a more cohesive series. The Stenza, for example, haven’t been mentioned since Ghost Monument. Yaz’s job hasn’t had any affect on her character or her relationship with Ryan in any way whatsoever. But more to the point, there hasn’t been any episode willing to examine the consequences of Grace’s death. It gets a few brief mentions over the series, but that’s it. Until now, anyway.

It’s clear that Graham misses Grace, but his instinctual belief that she wasn’t who she was claiming to be turned out to be right. Even so, it gave him time to express that grief and longing in a way that we haven’t seen yet. While the character’s fridging was deeply problematic move, it has led to beautiful scenes like the conversation between Graham and Grace here.

As a point of interest, the Solitract is the third such entity to deal with deceased characters, from the Testimony in Twice Upon A Time, to the Thijarians in Demons of the Punjab. There’s definitely a theme here, intentional or not. Whether it’s building to anything is a different question altogether.

In short: it’s a beautiful, contemplative episode, something like a calm before the storm that will (judging by the synopsis) be our finale. Not bad for the penultimate episode.

9/10.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑