The Mactíre Anthology: The Battle of Ranskoor av Kolos Review

As much as I tried to go in blind, I couldn’t. I glimpsed a headline suggesting that Doctor Who fans were disappointed by a boring finale, and opinions in the Eruditorum Press Discord seemed negative at best. And I still, for the life of me, cannot remember the episode title beyond the first three words. My impressions have been influenced, and I won’t even try to deny it.

We have had a series where there has been no arc, and therefore nothing to really wrap up. I didn’t buy Chibnall’s hogwash about “the emotional journey” of the characters, because what journey? What emotions? That would imply the leads were allowed to feel things, and given the complete lack of conflict or indeed much else in this particular TARDIS team, there doesn’t seem to be anything there, either. (Aside from Ed Hime’s handling of the Grace thing, that felt like something out of a Moffat script. Ah, better days…)

God, how times change. Could it really be true that a year ago, we were awaiting Peter Capaldi’s final bow and Jodie Whittaker’s debut? The promise of the era to come still unfulfilled, we waited with baited breath between those two beautiful first words, and the teasing glimpses we got in the gap between December 25th, 2017 and October 7th, 2018.

I miss those days. Never, in all the years I’ve watched this show, have I actually wanted the season to be over, and yet that’s exactly what Series 11 has pulled off. I came for Jodie Whittaker, and stayed for… well, a handful of decent to even spectacular episodes written by people who weren’t the show runner, and something of an obligation. I’m a Doctor Who fan, therefore I must watch Doctor Who, even if I think it’s shit.

To be fair, not all the things to come out of this series have been bad. Much like Thomas Newman’s scores for the A Series of Unfortunate Events movie or the fourth Craig-era Bond movie Spectre, Segun Akinola’s music has enlivened even the worst episodes (*cough* Kerblam *cough*). The historicals this year have all been excellent, and have shown how taking trips back into real history, and not the theme park version of history seen so often in the Moffat and Davies years, can work outside of the 1960s.

But anyway: this is how the series ends. Not with a Big Bang, or even a whimper, just a great big “thud.” Suddenly and abruptly, just like they did in the classic series, only with less character development. Might as well talk about it, shall we?

I like how the Doctor’s inconsistent morals regarding weapons came up, and that she was rightly called on it by Ryan. However, shrugging it off with “Because my rules change all the time” is entirely not what this character is supposed to be about. Sure, she doesn’t use the grenades, but that isn’t the point. The Doctor isn’t supposed to be the kind of person who reaches for a gun first. Chibnall, evidently, doesn’t quite get it.

And for the love of god, did we seriously have to turn this into a male revenge for female pain plot?! It’s not as though Steven Moffat spent the entirety of series 6 taking that entire angle apart and deconstructing it! And here’s Chibnall, resurrecting it to resolve the same fridging move he pulled in the freaking first place! God, what a shitshow.

I’ll be honest: the episode left me cold, as pretty much every Chibnall script has this year. Hell, this entire season has left me cold. Chibnall had an opportunity to use Jodie’s Doctor to his advantage, and build on Steven Moffat’s legacy just as Moffat built on Davies’. But that didn’t happen. Instead we got boring episodes with no consequence or development, punctuated with occasional moments of brilliance.

As the weeks have gone by, The Woman Who Fell to Earth feels like a bit of an outlier. Plot points and character elements were set up, things that could have taken the series in a different direction, but none of that happened. Honestly, you could watch both these episodes right after the other and not miss anything. There was no buildup or tension at all, no recurring elements. It was a series full of absences; devoid of humor, light, hope, and most damningly of all, magic.

And if that wasn’t enough? News broke late Sunday that the show will be taking a leave of absence until 2020, making the New Years Special the only episode to be broadcast in 2019. And we all know what happened the last time the Doctor took a year off: Trump and Brexit.

But maybe that’s for the best. Because Doctor Who, under Chris Chibnall, isn’t really a show I’m interested in watching. I’ll happily read any and all 13th Doctor books and comics that are released between now and then, but as for the series itself? It’s too early to decide now, I have a whole year for that. The odds aren’t good though.

Sorry, Doctor. I really wanted to keep traveling with you, but… I just don’t think much of the guy running your program. I do know one thing, though: I’ll be rewatching a lotof Moffat-era stuff. Because at least that era was made by someone who cared.

Ranking: 1/10.

Note: expect an end-of-season overview post probably tomorrow, once I finish polishing it.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑