The Mactíre Anthology: Orphan 55 Review

Doctor Who has, usually, presented an optimistic view of the future of humanity, always playing our ability to survive the worst catastrophes. In light of solar flares roasting the planet, we build nation-ships and go off into the stars, as seen in The Beast Below. In 1975’s The Ark in Space, the Doctor gives this speech when he realizes what the titular arc is:

“Homo sapiens. What an inventive, invincible species. It’s only a few million years since they’ve crawled up out of the mud and learned to walk. Puny, defenseless bipeds. They’ve survived flood, famine and plague. They’ve survived cosmic wars and holocausts, and now here they are amongst the stars, waiting to begin a new life, ready to outsit eternity. They’re indomitable. Indomitable!”The Doctor

none

And yet, the reveal that the monsters of this week’s episode, the Dregs, are actually mutated humans cuts against that, to say nothing of the other big reveal: the titular Orphan 55 is Earth, but made uninhabitable due to the climate crisis that’s going on right now, right in front of our very eyes.

This story couldn’t be more timely if it tried. Climate change is real, and it’s ravaging our planet this very instant. Intense wildfires in California and Australia, melting ice caps, starving polar bears, nastier hurricanes. Of course this story is set after the apocalypse, the Doctor can’t do anything about present-day Earth because she isn’t real. The only people who can stop this timeline from coming true are the same people responsible for bringing us to this point in the first place.

So no, of course this isn’t going to be a hopeful episode. It’s very aware that the likelihood of humanity getting its collective shit together and trying to stop our own extinction is about zero. I can’t blame Ed Hime for being pessimistic, because to be honest, I’m feeling pretty pessimistic myself.

After all, here’s a good chance Donald Trump could be elected to a second term, and even if he’s not, there’s a lot of his judges on our courts, and his party has a built-in advantage in the Senate. Any climate change legislation, even AOC’s Green New Deal, would be dead on arrival. But even if it passed and became law, there’s nothing stopping the next Republican president from derailing everything, as Trump’s EPA did to Obama’s Clean Power Plan and other initiatives. (Yes, I am aware electoral politics will not solve our problems, but it ain’t like revolutions are fool-proof either.)

Orphan 55 is not my favorite episode of this era. The 46-minute runtime suggests a lot was cut, probably from the middle sections during the search for Benni. I will say it’s better than Spyfall. The Doctor gets to be the Doctor, Tosin Cole is given some of his best material ever, and hey, there’s a cute cat lady. I am the last person to argue against including furries in Doctor Who.

But while it’s not my favorite, it’s also an episode that feels absolutely perfect for these grim, depressing, despairing times.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑