In the entry on New Earth, I compared the Doctor’s relationship with Rose to his relationship with Clara. The two arcs are a study in contrasts, both in how Rose and Clara leave the Doctor, and more generally, a study in how two different writers, Moffat and Davies, approached the idea of Doctor-like companions.
Davies’ view is generally taken to be that becoming Doctor-like is a bad thing. The Rose of Tooth and Claw is someone who considers herself to be on the Doctor’s level, so much so that she doesn’t really attempt to dress in 1870s Scotland clothes. At various points throughout the season, she’s given investigative scenes that otherwise might’ve gone to the Doctor, as in The Idiot’s Lantern when she goes to Magpie’s shop.
Likewise, as Rose becomes more Doctor-like, the Doctor becomes more Rose-like. This two-parter is the last we really see of Ten as the Doctor. Across seasons three and four, he will essentially become the Valeyard. This Doctor is specifically calibrated to work best with Rose Tyler. Once she’s gone, he ceases to exist.
Rose Tyler is the lynchpin of the Davies years. Following her departure in this story, she goes on to haunt the last two seasons of the era, both in a metaphorical sense (Season 3 has the Doctor mourning Rose throughout and he compares Martha unfavorably to her repeatedly) and in a literal one when she pops up on various screens and monitors throughout Series 4, prior to her return in Turn Left. Billie Piper may no longer be part of the cast, but Rose Tyler never leaves.
But, if Rose is such an important character, why did she leave in the first place? For that answer, let’s turn to a good friend of mine…
Clara:
It’s hard not to get choked up while watching ‘Doomsday.’ Before I start hitting it with a claw hammer, I want to make clear that the story works. The image of the Doctor and Rose laying their hands on the same wall in different timelines justifies the whole venture. Rose’s tragedy is iconic. But, what was her tragic flaw?
Rose, like Icarus, flew too close to the sun. She was a mortal who fell in love with a god. Worse, she started behaving as if she was a god too. Rose behaves like the Doctor from travelling with him too much. In ‘Army of Ghosts,’ Jackie foresees Rose’s future as a “strange woman walking through the marketplace on some planet a billion miles from Earth, but she’s not Rose Tyler. Not anymore. She’s not even human.” So, she had to be forced to leave the Doctor and be punished for her hubris. Is this fair?
Consider Clara Oswald, the best companion (shut up, yes she is). During her run on the show, especially Series 8 and 9, she took on the role of the Doctor. As Moffat said, Clara is a bit like if the Doctor was a young human woman living in London: brilliant and clever and wanting something more. So, we can see that Clara and Rose have a lot in common.
The difference is that the Clara era and Rose era of the show have opposite attitudes. In the Rose era, it is bad and wrong that Rose becomes like the Doctor; she becomes less human. In the Clara era, it’s empowering and awesome that Clara becomes like the Doctor because there’s no reason she shouldn’t. The Clara era challenges the gendered power dynamic between Doctor and companion, the dynamic that requires the Doctor (always a man) to be the hyper-competent authority and the companion (not exclusively but typically a woman) to be a less competent friend who takes orders to some degree.
The Rose era does a lot to re-frame what a companion can be, but it doesn’t break that gendered dynamic. I don’t want to exaggerate and make Rose sound like an imbecile, but the show does emphasise how normal she is. When she saves the day in her first episode, the show is lightning-fast to puncture her hero moment by saying that she got a bronze in gymnastics. Even in her ostensibly final story where she’s supposed to be most like the Doctor, she’s almost immediately outsmarted and kidnapped by Torchwood. This is because the Rose era is scared to have a companion genuinely be as competent as the Doctor because it wants to preserve that gendered authority/assistant dynamic. Only in Series 4, once she’s out of the companion role, does she take a level in badass. That way, she’s not a threat to the Doctor’s authority.
Threatening the Doctor’s authority is why Rose is sealed into Pete’s World. Rose can’t leave her boring, normal life and stay with the Doctor, no matter how much she wants to. She is condemned to her role just as the Doctor is condemned to his. We know that she goes back to adventuring, but we’re not shown that on screen (yet). The impression we’re given is of a broken Rose condemned to the mundane. While 10’s misery shows how he is locked into Doctorhood, Rose’s fate shows how she is locked out.
But, 10 doesn’t have it so rough. One of the luxuries of that Doctorhood is that he can exert his authority over Rose. Just like in ‘The Parting of the Ways,’ he tricks her and sends her away from the danger against her wishes. This is the second of eight times that he pulls this obviously paternalistic move. While the show does sympathise with Rose’s despair in both instances, I remain unconvinced that it views the Doctor’s deceit as anything other than the noble act of a wise authority. Think of this, then think of Donna’s ending in ‘Journey’s End.’
Also, to be fair, think of 11, who pulls this trick four times. ‘The Doctor’s Wife’ and ‘Time of the Doctor’ both see the same idea recycled (‘Time’ does it twice in a row). ‘The God Complex’ also counts since it sees 11 send Amy and Rory away to a safe, normal life. But, importantly, there’s no deception and they have a conversation about it first. This can be understood as the first seed of the idea of ‘Hell Bent.’ If you’ve been following along up to this point, you should understand how Clara’s last episode smashes ‘Doomsday’ to bits. The mindwipe makes ‘Journey’s End’ the common comparison, but Rose and Donna have essentially the same ending; as Dr. Elizabeth Sandifer writes, Davies is the sort of writer who never wastes a ‘good’ idea on one use. Donna, semi-literally, becomes the Doctor and she too is condemned accordingly.
For what extreme Doctor-like qualities is Rose punished? It’s not like she’s good at saving the world on her own (compare ‘Christmas Invasion’ to ‘Flatline’). She certainly doesn’t share his flaws. We never get anything like “You were an excellent Doctor… goodness had nothing to do with it.” No, what the Rose era means when it says that Rose is becoming like the Doctor is less substantial than that. She just likes travelling and having adventures. Not exactly the height of hubris.
This, even though Rose has no shortage of flaws for which the show forgives her. The final moments of ‘Rose,’ when she leaves London to travel with the Doctor, play out as follows:
ROSE: Thanks.
MICKEY: Thanks for what?
ROSE: Exactly.
Then she kisses him and runs. What a jerk!
Of course, the show puts a lot of time into showing how this hurt Jackie and Mickey, but it never truly holds Rose accountable. There’s no point where she suffers meaningful consequences for abandoning her loved ones in Powell Street. She never gets a well-deserved kick up the backside for repeatedly cheating on her boyfriend.
That the show frequently reminds us of the damage to Mickey and Jackie’s lives only stunts the show more. The point of this is clear: the Rose era is drawing attention to the problems in how classic Who wrote companions. But, it blows up the rules and doesn’t put them back together until Series 7B, when Clara asserts that she’ll only travel part-time.
Until then, the old structures are destroyed, and the show tries to navigate the rubble. Rose is caught in the crossfire of this self-reflexive commentary. As a result, she’s a huge dick and the show never notices. She never gets a comeuppance for any of the many bad things she’s done. Instead, she’s punished for getting too big for her boots.
Lena:
The Davies era, as Clara illustrated, is generally against the idea of its female companions approaching Doctor levels of narrative importance. Rose is banished to a parallel dimension, and Donna got twelve episodes of character development erased from her memory, an event that really could have been avoided had Tennant regenerated into Matt Smith a couple years early.
The loss of Rose is a destabilizing force on the show going forward. The Doctor becomes a darker man, and his hubris and vanity begins to drive his actions, making him something of an anti-hero. Which is fine, if you’re fond of anti-heroes. But that’s not me, I prefer my Doctors to be properly heroic. (And less blatantly vain and egotistical.)
And ultimately, this is why I don’t like the Tenth Doctor very much. He’s like the Sixth Doctor with more dashing charisma and, admittedly, less companion strangling. (Instead, when Martha shows up, we get racism.) He thinks he’s hot shit, but in truth he’s just shit.
Leave a Reply