The RTD Rewind: The Shakespeare Code

Before we begin, I have a confession to make: I am not exactly a Shakespeare aficionado. The last time I read one of his plays, I was in the tenth grade and it was Julius Caesar. At some point I watched the production of Hamlet that featured David Tennant and Patrick Stewart, or at least parts of it. And then… that was pretty much the end of that. Or at least, it was until I spent the last quarter of 2022 and a chunk of 2023 watching Star Trek: The Next Generation.

Take, for example, “The Defector” from season 3. The episode opens with Data, everyone’s favorite android, performing a scene from Henry V: Data plays Henry, disguised among a couple of commoners the night before a battle. Puzzled about this, Data asks of Picard: “Captain, why should a king wish to pass as a commoner? If he is the leader, should he not be leading?”

Picard’s reply was: “Listen to what Shakespeare is telling you about the man, Data. A king who had a true feeling for his soldiers would wish to share their fears with them on the eve of battle.” The rest of the episode then busies itself with setting up a similar situation for the crew to deal with – a Romulan logistics guy defects from the Empire to warn the Federation of a coming attack, and he is later revealed to be an admiral in disguise.

In an argument with the Romulan commander Tomalak toward the end, Picard even makes a slight reference to the play from the beginning, as he refuses to surrender: “If the cause is just and honorable, they are prepared to give their lives.” It may not be a “Shakespeare episode” in the same way as, say, TNG’s two Moriarty episodes, but it does engage with the text, and in the end, allows Shakespeare and his work to stand on their own terms.

All of this is a very long way of saying that “The Defector,” an episode from an completely different sci-fi show made in 1990, does much more with Shakespeare as both a writer and as a genre of storytelling than the Doctor Who episode from 17 years later. If this were an Adventures in Narrative Substitution article, I’d recommend you go watch that instead. (And you should anyway, because it’s a fucking great episode of Star Trek.)

The problem with The Shakespeare Code is that, despite being an episode containing Shakespeare, barely has nothing to do with him or his writings except for a built-in excuse to make hackneyed in-jokes. Tortured comparisons to J.K. Rowling are made instead, up to and including Martha shouting “Expelliarmus!” to banish the Carrionites from Earth. It might as well be called the J.K. Rowling episode instead, given how obsessed Roberts is with mentioning her. (Given what we now know about both of them, it’s very easy to read this as one racist transphobe recognizing another and giving her a shout-out.)

The great irony is that there almost was an actual Rowling historical. Per Shannon Sullivan: “On Christmas Eve, an alien creature attaches itself to author JK Rowling. Suddenly, the real world is replaced by a magical reality influenced by the writer’s own imagination. The Doctor must battle witches and wizards to reach Rowling and put the world to rights.” David Tennant thought that was a horrible idea, and we were spared that particular indignity.

Roberts’s apparent complete lack of understanding about Shakespeare reminds me of two things: the Twitter meme about a guy who has only watched Boss Babyremarking that his second movie gives him Boss Baby vibes, and the post my good friend Audrey wrote on Roberts’s season 4 episode, The Unicorn and the Wasp, in which he displays a similar lack of understanding regarding Agatha Christie.

Audrey writes:

It’s hard to take seriously the notion that she was some unparalleled genius, or a keen observer of the human condition, as the Doctor himself essentially asserts, when – again, by design – the “joke” is basically that every murder mystery is the same, and that the whole genre’s just a shopping list of tropes. Something which doesn’t fit well alongside the episode’s view of Christie, which asserts her cleverness whilst simultaneously making it out that all her books are alike.

The cherry on the top of it all, for me, is that Roberts obviously took inspiration from the board game Clue, naming his characters in similar fashion to the players within the game’s setting – indeed, The Unicorn and the Wasp is less of an Agatha Christie pastiche and more of a Clue one, understanding nothing about makes either great or how they function.

The energy Roberts gives in these historical settings is the same as the class slacker showing up to tenth grade English to give a presentation on a book he didn’t read, despite having six weeks to work on the essay. So he just bullshits his entire presentation, for a lack of literally anything else to offer. For fuck’s sake Gareth, it’s William Shakespeare. This really shouldn’t be that hard.

Thankfully, Wasp is the last time Roberts is asked to do a historical of any sort: his next 3 stories are all set in the modern day, and focus on various aspects of middle-class British life into which the Doctor intrudes, albeit to increasingly diminishing returns.

In previous essays on him I’ve tackled his transphobia, and considered his conservatism. Now it’s time to reckon with his racism. Because make no mistake about it, this dude is racist. When he’s not crassly having the Doctor suggest to Martha that she walk around like she owns the place, he’s having Shakespeare objectify her. Truth is, it really shouldn’t have been surprising that he drifted closer and closer to the right. By the time we get to The Caretaker, he’s gone so completely off the deep end when it comes to race that the only reason that episode is watchable at all because it’s a co-write with Steven Moffat. Needless to say, I do not particularly mind that he hasn’t been involved with the series in any capacity for nine years now, and I do not see that changing. Nor should it. The world has moved past Gareth Roberts and his particular brand of racist transphobic right-wingery.

Thankfully, normality reasserts itself next week with Gridlock, the episode in which Russell T Davies returns to New Earth to indulge in his obvious fondness for anthropomorphic cats.

It’s okay, Rusty. You can admit you’re a furry.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑