The good news about this episode is that it’s not, thankfully, the reactionary disaster that Kerblam was last season. The bad news is, it replaces that reactionary conservatism with… nothing. Yes, it does a better job of integrating the “how humans are fucking up the planet” stuff than Orphan 55 did, but at least that one also had justifiable anger about how things got so bad.
With this, the Doctor just talks repeatedly about how much plastic is in the world with no particular emotional attachment beyond general earnestness, the same kind of earnestness Jodie usually resorts to with an undercooked script. Plastic everywhere is just something that is true now, apparently, like how the sky is blue or ice is cold.
Yaz, thankfully, gets more of a chance to be helpful and contribute to the story than she’s gotten in the last season and a half. This is true of Graham and Ryan too, but with Yaz it sticks out more since she was essentially a background character last season and for most of this one.
What I will also give the episode points for is its handling of the gay couple, Jake and Adam. I tweeted the other week about how so far, this era’s handing of queer people has been to kill everyone off, and I’m happy to say that Praxeus breaks that streak by saving both their lives: Adam the astronaut is cured after becoming afflicted with the titular virus, and the Doctor come to Jake’s rescue just before the ship he’s in blows up.
If it feels like I’m scraping the bottom of the barrel for things to write about here, it’s because I am. I’ll be honest, this episode left me cold. I’m relieved it wasn’t a political trainwreck like Kerblam was, and Chibnall is showing some signs of improvement (as evidenced by Spyfall Part 1), which makes the news that he’s essentially gotten a writing credit for virtually every episode of this season except for Orphan 55 and Nikola Tesla’s Night of Terror a little easier to stomach.
It’s a good episode, to be sure, and a definite improvement over last season. (I’d sooner rewatch this over most of Series 11, quite frankly.) But again, it’s hard to feel emotionally connected to the show these days. I get more out of Star Trek: Picard than I do out of Doctor Who, and I’m not sure how to feel about that.
Leave a Reply