And now for something completely different: namely, a cartoon! This is The Infinite Quest, an animated Doctor Who story that originally aired over 13 weeks as part of Totally Doctor Who, and which then got re-released as a 45 minute episode in 2018 as part of an animated specials collection, along with the original The Power of the Daleks recon, Shada, Dreamland, and 2003’s Scream of the Shalka.
The cartoon is an interesting medium for the show to be experimenting with: much like a comic book, you gain the advantage of being able to depict characters that would be otherwise impossible to do on a live-action TV show, like the frog guy and the insect queen on the dung planet, or the skeleton people in the desert scene. There, the only budget is the ability of the animators to depict what the script calls for.
But with comic books, you lose something: namely, acting. A large part of what makes the Tenth Doctor so magnetic as a character is the way Tennant plays him: he is, by turns, a blabbermouth in one scene, and then the loneliest man in the world in another. He can go from total ham to vengeful time god in the span of twenty minutes. Facial expressions and dialogue tell only half the story, line delivery is the other component.
Cartoons allow you to have both: the flexibility of character design and scenery usually given to comic books, along with the voice performance of the actor. That having been said, why have there not been too many Doctor Who cartoons?
I am not entirely sure. Some of it might just be down to the format of Doctor Who as a show, versus something like Star Trek. With Star Trek and its three animated shows, (The Animated Series, Lower Decks, Prodigy) you have one “standing set” that your story can be set on: namely, the Enterprise, the Cerritos, and the Protostar. Add in the uniform factor and that simplifies your character design as well. You can tell all kinds of stories and rarely leave the ship! That’s fantastic for a weekly show!
Whereas with Doctor Who, the majority of any given episode is set in a new location, the TARDIS is mainly used for transport. And that means you have to work on making the most out of new environments once a week, every week. (Or you would, if there was ever a weekly Doctor Who cartoon, which there has never been.)
We can use Infinite Quest as a test case for this actually, because it did air weekly. If you split the story up according to the locations of the data chip, you’d have the equivalent of a classic series four-parter: the opening scenes with Balthazar and the desert material would make up part one, part two would be the stuff with the frog guy and the insect queen, part three covers Volag-Nok, and then part four is everything involving the ruins of the Infinite.
With each part, the only bits of consistency are the Doctor and Martha with brief scenes set in the TARDIS, everything else is brand new on a weekly basis. And that’s fine for a one-off thing like Quest, but if there was a season of the new series that just happened to be animated, shit would get complicated real fast.
And that’s just one part of why, i think, a weekly Doctor Who series has never panned out. The other one comes from, again, acting: acting for a cartoon versus acting in live action are two entirely different disciplines. Live action acting forces the actor to not just act with their voice, but also their body, from facial expressions to how they move their body.
For an example, consider the Adventure Games: these were computer games the BBC put out alongside series 5, and essentially they functioned as Doctor Who episodes in game form, down to Matt Smith and Karen Gillan voicing the Eleventh Doctor and Amy.
Putting aside the awfulness of the graphics, (and they are pretty bad) much of what makes the Eleventh Doctor work as a character is the physicality Matt Smith brought to the part, something that is inevitably lost in the transition from live action to animation. He’s decent as a voice actor, but it’s clear that’s not really his strong suit. David Tennant actually does pretty well at translating his Doctor to animation, perhaps because he already has success as a voice actor.
Let me explain: prior to getting the role of the Doctor in 2005, Tennant’s previous experience in the franchise came in voiceover roles. He has a brief cameo in Scream of the Shalka, as well as some larger roles in assorted early Big Finish audio dramas. Voice acting for audio, like with animation, is reliant on the voice alone for the actor to do their thing. And some actors, like David Tennant, are good at this!
As an episode, I honestly kind of like Infinite Quest. The nature of the medium gives it a certain flexibility that the live action show necessarily lacks: even with the benefit of modern special effects, I struggle to imagine this story working as well as it does in live action. Is it the best story of its genre? I wouldn’t go that far: the MacGuffin Quest genre of Doctor Who has been done before, most notably in 1978’s Key to Time arc. While some parts of that season suck, other parts of it are very strong, particularly The Pirate Planet.
I think what makes Quest work is that it could serve well as an introduction to Doctor Who. From the off, we’re starting with the villain in the middle of an evil villain monologue, which the Doctor interrupts. It’s quickly clear who the Doctor is: he’s a heroic character who does things like derail villainous monologues and then defeat them via nonviolent means: in this case, a golden spoon that causes Baltazar’s ship to rust away.
The rest of the episode is taken up with showing off what else the show can do: we’re on a pirate ship! We’re on a planet of the giant dragonflies! We’re in a prison! We’re on the ruins of a spaceship! All that’s missing is the historical element.
And even within those locales, any one of those could function as a story on its own: the oil pirates? Here’s an angry Cartmelian screed about fossil fuels and how our reliance on them has contributed to the ongoing climatological apocalypse, along with an undercurrent centered around the capitalistic death drive: we drained Earth dry, so now we’ve moved on to other planets, which are going the same way because capitalism, in essence, relies on death to make it work. As long as we continue to use the fossilized remains of dinosaurs to make our cars work, capitalism will continue to destroy us.
I’m glad the Target book range has been resurrected from the dead, because I feel like this story could work splendidly as a Dicksian adventure book. With a certain amount of narrative expansion, of course. Will it happen? I would say I doubt it… but the OG Target range novelized Doctor Who and the Pescatons, the first ever audio Doctor Who story, so anything is possible.
Next week: Normal service is resumed with Doctor Who and the Penis Man, otherwise known as Daleks in Manhattan/Evolution of the Daleks.
Leave a Reply