The Mactíre Anthology: The Haunting of Villa Diodati

Well, damn, Maxine Alderton came out swinging, didn’t she? It really is nice to have an episode that I can just enjoy without qualifiers. The last one from this season that did that was Tesla, and like this one, it was also one of the episodes that didn’t have an “and Chris Chibnall” added to the writing credits.

Actually, it’s Chris Chibnall that I want to talk about, first and foremost. His fingerprints have been all over this season, even more so than last year. Maybe it’s the fact that he’s trying for an actual arc this time around, compared to last season’s arc-lessness, and he wants to make sure everyone’s on the same page. I mean, fair enough? Steven Moffat did something similar three seasons ago, so I can’t exactly fault him for that, but… he’s also just not as good a writer. The co-written stories are pretty much all okay, but not because he was along for the ride, if you catch my drift.

This one had me thinking of a couple different older stories as it went along: first, Hide from 2013, previously the only episode of the show to do a haunted house story. Then there was The Unquiet Dead from 2005, a Mark Gatiss-penned historical romp where they meet Charles Dickens and fight ghosts that aren’t actually ghosts at all, but aliens.

I guess it’s not too much of a surprise that this is as good as it is. The historicals have always been the strongest parts of any Chibnall-era season, and 1800s period drama is something the BBC can do with its eyes closed. The casting is good, the dialogue decent, the atmosphere suitably dark and spooky, and I really loved the trick with making the house fold in on itself.

Then we have the Cybermen. Or rather, a Cyberman, one who is pretty heavily rusted, only half converted, and still has plenty of emotion. Points for creepy as fuck costume design, that’s for sure. This would be a great episode to watch on Halloween.

But then, of course, with the appearance of the Cybermen we get to the Arc Stuff, like the warning from everyone’s favorite 51st century comedy sexual assaulter. To be honest, I’m not even remotely interested in armies of Cybermen going to war, it sounds for all the world like a lamer version of Earthshock, (which would be an accomplishment) or, given the continual Davies-era retreads, a version of the Series 2 finale without the Daleks. As I’ve stated previously, Doctor Who should be trying out new things and going new places, not just inferior retreads of stuff that was happening 14 years ago.

I mean, shit. Star Trek Picard has been doing exactly that for the last month, and you know what? I’ve been enjoying that a lot more than I have this season of Who, just on that basis alone. Picard bucks the recent trend in Star Trek of doing endless visits back to the pre-Original Series era, and by recent, I mean it’s been doing that for around 20 years. Enterprise, the Abrams reboot movies, and Discovery have all been boldly going back to what has already been done before, and now FINALLY we are beginning to move forward.

So, yeah. We now exist in a strange world where the second-oldest sci-fi franchise is actually doing better than the first-oldest. Okay then. See you all in two weeks for Earthshock 2: Electric Boogaloo.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑