The RTD Rewind: Utopia/The Sound of Drums/Last of the Time Lords/Time Crash

So this is how the world ends. Not with a bang, but to the sound of Rogue Traders.

Utopia (and here I am referring to the entire trilogy with that title) is, genuinely, some of the best Doctor Who I’ve seen since Moffat left the show. Yes, I know, this is sixteen year old Who made when the show was still broadcasting in 480p. But my point stands: it is incredibly good Who. It’s better, I would say, than Army of Ghosts/Doomsday. That story only really works if you’re super into Ten/Rose as a pairing, otherwise, it leaves you cold. (Or at least, that was the case when I watched it.)

This has stuff going on. It lures you in with the promise of Derek Jacobi playing a kindly old professor and then WHAM, suddenly he’s THE FREAKING MASTER and everything goes completely to hell! The Doctor and Martha (and, sigh, Jack) are in genuine trouble here. Sure, they win eventually, but it’s a very close thing.

And yet… it is an incredibly bleak story, this. Particularly the ultimate final fate of humanity. As Elizabeth Sandifer wrote:

It’s one thing to make bleak statements about how people screw everything up. That borders on the banal. It’s quite another to position this as the ultimate fate of humanity. Utopia sets up a choice between the joyously eternal nature of humanity and the idea of an inevitable moral rot, and ultimately embraces the latter.

All of humanity’s dreams and hopes come crashing down, and there is only dark and cold and the cackling madness of the serpent. […] And not because of some comfortingly external force. Not the heat death of the universe or age or the inevitability of death, but the fact that there is evil in humanity.

This, ultimately, is what sinks the Davies era for me. It is, on the one paw, staggeringly well-made TV: even some of its worst stories still have enough going on them to bring them up to at least basic watchability. But there is a definite cynicism running through the entire era from start to finish, and in episodes like this, it’s raised so high into the mix that everything else gets drowned out.

And for me, that cynicism makes it hard to really enjoy this story. I can appreciate it as a well-directed, well-acted, and well-plotted piece of television, but it doesn’t make me happy. Even the very end, when time rewinds and (most of) the Master’s atrocities are undone, feel somewhat hollow because of the enormity of Utopia and the transformation of humanity into, literally, substitute Daleks. (The Toclafane were originally designed for series 1 in case they couldn’t get the Dalek rights.) How on Earth do you move on from that?!

By remembering that this is only one possible end to humanity on the show, not the be-all end-all. Consider, if you will, the episode The Big Bang from series 5, just two seasons from now. In that story, we see the Doctor, River, and the Ponds spend 50 minutes or so wandering around an empty museum, trying to figure out how to undo the end of the universe:

DOCTOR: When the Tardis blew up, it caused a total event collapse. A time explosion. And that explosion blasted every atom in every moment of the universe. Except
AMY: Except inside the Pandorica.
DOCTOR: The perfect prison. And inside it, perfectly preserved, a few billion atoms of the universe as it was. In theory, you could extrapolate the whole universe from a single one of them, like, like cloning a body from a single cell. And we’ve got the bumper family pack.
RORY: No, no. Too fast. I’m not getting it.
DOCTOR: The box contains a memory of the universe, and the light transmits the memory, and that’s how we’re going to do it.
AMY: Do what?
DOCTOR: Relight the fire. Reboot the universe.

Where RTD had the Futurekind, the Master, and a rocket ship to nowhere, Moffat gives us the Doctor sacrificing himself to fly the Pandorica into the heart of his exploding TARDIS, after a touching goodbye to Amy Pond:

DOCTOR: Amy Pond. The girl who waited all night in your garden. Was it worth it?
AMY: Shut up. Of course it was.
DOCTOR: You asked me why I was taking you with me and I said, no reason. I was lying.
[…] There was a crack in time in the wall of your bedroom, and it’s been eating away at your life for a long time now. Amy Pond, all alone. The girl who didn’t make sense. How could I resist?
AMY: How could I just forget?
DOCTOR: Nothing is ever forgotten. Not really. But you have to try.

Cynicism and optimism – the two viewpoints that animate these two eras. That’s not to say cynicism is bad: far from it. Cynicism provides a necessary counterweight to optimism, and vice versa. I just mean that while you can have both in Doctor Who, one of those two things must always eventually win out.

In the case of Utopia, optimism appears in Martha’s plot line that runs through most of part three – she is traveling the world, telling people about the Doctor in an effort to turn the Master’s Archangel Network against him. If everyone thinks and/or yells the word DOCTOR at the same instant, that will give our favorite Time Lord enough energy to return to his true age and defeat the Master once and for all.

And, okay, the Super Magic Jesus Doctor effects they use for that climax are, admittedly, a bit much. But the basic point? The power of stories to change reality and fix what’s been broken? That is alchemy. Hell, it’s the exact solution to The Big Bang’s final puzzle: how does Amy bring the Doctor back to life? By telling her wedding guests about her imaginary friend.

This is how good triumphs over evil: rejecting a bad story, and telling a different one in its place. The Moffat era will, of course, return to this idea over and over as it unwinds, but it’s wonderful to see it introduced here, in what is probably the only finale of the Davies years to have a happy ending.

Even the companion departure is happy, relatively speaking: Martha does leave the Doctor, but her own volition, because she’s realized she doesn’t need him anymore. Once she’s gone, the Doctor goes off alone on another adventure…

Only for the TARDIS to collide with itself, and who should appear but the Fifth Doctor, played by Peter Davison?!

Yes, Time Crash is a silly 7 minute comedy sketch that I would struggle to get a thousand words out of, but who cares? When watched straight after Last of the Time Lords, it acts as a much needed burst of frivolity after three episodes of doom, gloom, and John Simm singing karaoke.

And it is hysterical. Moffat leaves no stone unturned, making jokes about Tennant’s enthusiastic portrayal of the title character compared to Davison’s more calm, quiet professionalism, snark about Peter Davison having visibly aged since 1984, repeated digs at the celery stalk, etcetera, with just enough drama to give things a bit of danger… and then lead into a touching moment as Tennant, fanboy of all fanboys, gets to tell his favorite Doctor how much he loved being him. That he and Davison are now in-laws makes this all the sweeter.

Time Crash, for me, is the true finale of series 3. And with that done and dusted, we can now run headlong into the next part of the story…

The return of Donna Noble, and the end of the Tennant era.

Allons-y!

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑