Generations: Reflections on TNG and Jean-Luc Picard

Captain’s log, stardate 78457.1:

In Doctor Who fandom, there is a concept called Your Doctor. Very roughly speaking, a person’s Doctor is the incarnation they love best, not necessarily the very first Doctor they encountered. (Though it sometimes is that.) For example: my first Doctors are Two and Ten, since I first encountered them in book form and on TV respectively, while My Doctor is, of course, the Eleventh.

Who a given person’s Doctor is varies. There are many different kinds of people in the world, and many different kinds of Doctors. I fell in love with Doctor Who during Eleven’s era, and even now, I still rate him in first place on my list of favorites. I always will. He’s seared onto my heart.

I don’t know if a similar concept exists for Star Trek captains, but I imagine it does. Star Trek, like Doctor Who, contains multitudes. If your preference is for morality plays and watching William Shatner get his shirt ripped off, you probably like Captain Kirk in the original series. People with a fondness for serialized storytelling and morally grey choices may like Deep Space Nine. If you’re queer as all get out, here’s Discovery. And if you prefer your heroes to solve problems with brains rather than brawn… then you may like The Next Generation.

TNG, and by extension Jean-Luc Picard, has been around for literally my entire life. I was born in October 1994, roughly six or seven months after TNG wrapped on TV, and a month before they appeared in their first voyage to the big screen in Generations. By the time Nemesis came out in late 2002, I was eight years old, and somewhat aware of Star Trek in general: my parents, for example, had a VHS box set of the first 5 TOS movies, and of course, whenever they’d watch TNG in reruns, I always got excited when LeVar Burton came on because he was The Reading Rainbow Guy.

And then… that was essentially that for about ten years or so. Star Trek became a thing that I knew my cousin was into, and he liked the original series. (To the point that his mom redecorated his room with an Enterprise theme.) I actually seemed to avoid the series for whatever reason, right up until it collided with Doctor Who in a way I couldn’t miss.

For all intents and purposes, the eight-issue comic book miniseries Assimilation2 (hereinafter referred to as Assimilation Squared) was my first TNG episode.

For those who haven’t read it, let me explain. In 2012, IDW (who held the Doctor Who comic license at the time, as well as the Star Trek one) announced a crossover between the two oldest franchises in science fiction, the only such crossover ever to exist. (Aside from RTD’s half-baked idea from 2005, which never happened because Enterprise got canceled.)

The premise of the series is this: Somehow, the Cybermen break through the void between realities (again) and encounter the Borg, forming a temporary alliance. The Enterprise is called in when a joint assimilation fleet ravages a planet, and shortly after, the Doctor shows up. And because it’s 2012, this means we get the Eleventh Doctor and the Ponds. (It’s also a better Trek comic than a Who one, but that’s a different subject.)

Obviously, I came to the comic because it was Additional Eleven Content, desperately needed at a time when we only had five episodes on TV. I wasn’t sure what to make of the Trek part of it, but I warmed pretty quickly to Captain Picard, even if I didn’t get the trauma over Wolf 359 at the time. So, after I read the complete miniseries, I fired up “The Best of Both Worlds.”

And I was never the same again.

It’s an exceptionally bleak story, BOBW. It is very much not Standard Operating Procedure for the crew of the USS Enterprise. And yet… I loved it anyway, and still do even ten years after I first saw it. My favorite episode is “Yesterday’s Enterprise,” because again, I have a thing for time travel, doubly so if it involves alternate timelines, and the darker Enterprise bridge is fantastic.

Anyway… Over the next few years, I watched a bit of TNG. Sometimes for fun, otherwise for research purposes, as I’d started writing New Endeavours (my MLP/Trek crossover series) by then and needed to learn as much as I could about the world in which my characters inhabited.

But it was not until 2018, and Patrick Stewart’s announcement at a convention in Vegas that he would be returning to Star Trek, that my Jean-Luc love affair really kicked into high gear.

Prior to then, I’d understood Picard primarily through the eyes of Gemini Shadow, my space pony. They are very similar characters, Jean-Luc and Gem: Polished and professional, big tea drinkers, a preference for diplomacy over physical combat, idealistic, wise, a parent to their respective crews, and calm in a crisis. Some of the resemblance was accidental: Gem already acted like that in the high school AU she’d originated in. Put her in a Starfleet uniform though, and suddenly I knew which captain she was most like.

So in a way, through her, Picard became My Captain, in much the same way that Eleven is My Doctor.

That said, the resonance is different. The Eleventh Doctor was very much a hero for Young Lena, who didn’t yet know that she was trans or a wolf or what have you. As I began figuring these things out, he went away and I needed someone else to look up to. I love the Twelfth Doctor as a character, but I can’t relate to him in the same way as I could Eleven, nor do I really take him as a paragon, a virtue to model myself as.

That’s where Picard stepped into my life. At least, after Gem introduced us.

Look at who Picard is, across TNG and four movies and 3 seasons of his eponymous show: he is a deeply principled man who will do whatever it takes in order to do the right thing.

My favorite moment comes at the end of the episode “The Defector.” Picard is facing off against a Romulan commander, and quotes some Shakespeare while he does it:

TOMALAK [on viewscreen]: I urge you, Captain Picard, surrender. Consider the men and women you would lead into a lost cause.
PICARD: If the cause is just and honorable, they are prepared to give their lives. Are you prepared to die today, Tomalak?
TOMALAK [on viewscreen]: I expected more from you than an idle threat, Picard.
PICARD: Then you shall have it. Mister Worf.
WORF: Aye, sir.
(Three mean Klingon vessels uncloak around the Enterprise and Romulans)
WORF: Klingon warships armed and ready, sir.
PICARD: What shall it be, Tomalak?
TOMALAK [on viewscreen]: You will still not survive our assault.
PICARD: You will not survive ours. Shall we die together?
TOMALAK [on viewscreen]: I look forward to our next meeting, Captain.

One of his best moments in a season full of them. It’s not just that he defeats the Romulan without firing a shot, but how he does it: by baiting him, and then using the invitation Tomalak gives him to display exactly what else he has up his sleeves. Tomalak gets completely out-maneuvered, and it’s incredible to watch.

Another moment: pretty much the entirety of Picard season 1. I know, some of you out there are rolling your eyes, but let me explain. Yes, he’s obviously a lot more jaded than he was in the TNG era, but does that stop him from putting a crew together and saving the androids of Coppelius? Absolutely not. Helping a minority even when the rest of the world is doing otherwise? That has big echoes for me as a trans woman, watching Republican-controlled states try and legislate my people out of existence. And there is exactly zero doubt in my mind that Jean-Luc Picard would march in a pride parade.

So as I sit here on this Captain Picard Day, thinking about this particular character, I think I am glad that he exists. And I am glad that they chose Patrick Stewart to play him, and he embodied the role so well that, apparently, toward the end of Next Gen there was a very hazy line between Stewart and Picard.

I am glad that he came back through three seasons of TV, guiding us through a pandemic and encroaching fascism and whatever other existential threat you care to name. I am glad that I got to see him on the bridge of the Enterprise-D one more time, ready to kick Borg ass and take names. This man is the kind of person I want to be when I grow up, as I go out and begin my new life in New York with the woman I intend to marry.

Or, in three very simple words…

Make it so.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑