Target Practice: Doctor Who and the Daleks

This month’s selection is a very special Doctor Who book. Not only is it the first ever novelization of a television story, (in this case, Terry Nation’s The Daleks) but the first book about the series in any way whatsoever. It was originally published in 1964 under the title Doctor Who in an Exciting Adventure with the Daleks, then re-published in 1973 by Target Books as Doctor Who and the Daleks. The version I’m reading is yet another reprint, this one from 2011.

The first thing we must note, for those of you who may not be familiar with the book, is that it doesn’t start in exactly the same way as the TV version did. Aside from the central quartet of the Doctor, Ian, Barbara, and Susan, Whitaker dispenses with An Unearthly Child altogether, making Ian a scientist, Barbara a private tutor, and giving Susan the last name of English rather than Foreman. There’s not even a junkyard on Totters’ Lane, instead the TARDIS is parked on Barnes Common, and Ian arrives to investigate a car crash.

This isn’t the biggest change the novel makes, but it is the most well-remembered, so much so that Mark Gatiss (and for all my problems with him as a writer, the man knows his Who like no one else) referred to it in his drama about the making of the show, An Adventure in Space and Time.

The biggest change the novel makes though is by telling the story from Ian’s perspective. It’s not often a Doctor Who book makes use of the first-person narration format, which makes this one somewhat unique. This version of Ian isn’t quite the same as his TV incarnation (mostly in relation to his background) but it’s still interesting to get inside his head in a way that wouldn’t have been possible in 1963.

And speaking of the Sixties, this book is very much a relic of that time. The TARDIS is referred to as just a word Susan made up (which was true on TV as well) and written as Tardis, usually without the definite article. More often, it’s called “the Ship.” Ian not only offers Barbara a cigarette when they first meet, he smokes one himself and wishes he had one while wandering through Skaro in chapter six. You’d never see anyone smoking on Doctor Who in this day and age, so seeing it done so casually (even with the knowledge that smoking was more commonplace in 1964 than now) is still quite jarring.

Then there’s the sexism. If you read my review of Doctor Who and the Cybermenfrom last October, then you know how annoying I find it when male characters, and writers, treat women as if we are made of glass, or alien creatures of the kind the Doctor might meet on her travels, instead of living beings with lives and wishes and dreams and wants and fears of our own. But while Gerry Davis simply played up Polly’s femininity and initially kept her from joining Ben and Jamie in defeating the Mondasians, Whitaker is even worse: he infantilizes Barbara and Susan both, having Ian refer to them as “girl” constantly, and in chapter 9, this happens:

“Kristas,’ I said. ‘I’m giving you a job to do. Guard Barbara. Don’t leave her side.’

He nodded reassuringly.

‘I will watch over her. I know what she means to you.’

Was he right? Surely I was merely protecting the weakest of our party.

WEAKEST?! Dammit Chesterfield, Barbara Wright is a hell of a strong woman and you damn well know it! Here she is basically taking the fact that she’s been marooned on a hostile alien planet in stride while you pick fights and pretend to be the most macho man since Arnold Schwarzenegger in his Terminator days. Small wonder she spends half the book trying to kill you with her eyes, I would too if I ended up stuck in space with a chauvinist pig!

I know that sexism of this kind is inevitable, given the time and place it was written. And as bad as it is here, it’s nothing compared to the bullshit Ian Fleming was always pulling with James Bond. (The most recent film of which was Goldfinger, which gave us the wondrously feminist name of Pussy Galore. Gotta love it when men think with their dicks.) But damn if it isn’t exhausting to read through, speaking as a transgender woman from the early 21st century.

Speaking of exhausting, while Whitaker’s prose makes for an engaging read, I have to admit the story itself seemed to drag after the first chapter, when the new introduction was wrapped up and began to move in the direction of the original TV story. This isn’t Whitaker’s fault of course, it’s mostly down to Terry Nation, a man who (as my friend Brendan memorably described him) “wrote the scripts for this story in the space of a week before yeeting off to Sweden for a holiday.”

Whitaker, for his part, does his best to expand the world of the story beyond what we saw on screen, going into greater detail on the TARDIS food machine, having the Thals learn to fight so they can help Ian and Barbara fight the Daleks in chapter 9, and even capping things off with a scene in which the two of them agree to keep traveling with the Doctor after all, as if anticipating the New Series’ default mode of TARDIS travel as the coolest vacation ever.

But at its core, this is still a Nation script, and all the nice prose in the world can’t rescue the story from becoming an endless series of captures and escapes, and in this story, a wall-climbing scene involving a creeper that makes me think of the movie Lost Continent.

And it is, of course, extremely odd to see the Doctor act so unheroically in the opening chapters, in spite of the lengths Whitaker goes to have Ian grow to eventually trust him. That said, at this point the show had very little idea of what it wanted to be, so it follows that the title character has to finish cooking first. That said, the closing speech at the end of chapter 10, toward the Thals, has the air of similar future speeches the Doctor will give:

“Our way is through the stars, my friends. One day perhaps I may come back and visit your grandchildren and see how they have succeeded. There will be birds on this planet then and beautiful flowers. Culture and grace will thrive and this adventure will be a legend.’ He gazed around him impressively and held up one finger.

‘See that that legend,’ he said gravely, ‘is the lowest rung on a ladder to happiness, peace and success.”

Also strange is pretty much every scene with a Dalek in it, since they are prone to having long conversations that are simply not what Dalek chit chat scenes have been historically. They don’t even behave like Daleks, keeping our cast prisoner or just immobilizing Ian’s legs rather than exterminating him outright. The static electricity thing allows them to get defeated quite quickly at the end of the book, and thank goodness it’s undone because otherwise, any subsequent Dalek stories would be far less interesting. They are, at least in this story, kind of terrible monsters.

Then there’s the Thals: a race of perfectly proportioned men and perfectly proportioned women and children, white as can be, considered to be trustworthy because they look like humans. Not only that, they’re the kind of perfect human once described as Aryan. It’s funny that the Daleks considered them to be disfigured, but perhaps that comes out of their existing hatred of anyone who isn’t a Dalek. (That aspect, at least, is present and correct.) Of course the Doctor stays and helps the Thals take over Skaro, they look human, and that detail of his character will become very important in years to come.

Doctor Who and the Daleks, in summary, is a deeply strange book. On the one hand it was the launching point for a series of novelizations that is going strong even to this day, (I write this on the very day that the first New Series Dalek story received its Target adaptation, for example) and it deserves to be read not just as an artifact of what Sixties Doctor Who was really like, but as a promise of other things to come. On the other hand, between the sexism and the godawful plotting (THANKS A LOT TERRY) I would hesitate to recommend this to anyone beyond the mentioned historical significance.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑