And now, finally, we come to My Doctor: Number eleven, played so magnificently by Matt Smith from 2010 to 2013, he of the cool bow ties and tweed jackets. The Crimson Horror is a bit further ahead in his timeline than I’ve reached in my Back to the Eleventh Hour pieces thus far, but this is a show about time travel, such shenanigans are bound to happen sooner or later.
Speaking of Eleventh Hour, if you’ve read my stuff so far, then you know I’ve never been especially fond of Mark Gatiss. I’ve given him a bit of a hard time over the last two books, but I’m glad to say that starting with this and Cold War, he hits a late-career renaissance, churning out hit after hit like his best pal Moffat does in his sleep. (Well, except Sleep No More, but that’s another series.)
The thing about Gatiss is that he has very particular tastes: in his case, classic Doctor Who and an extreme fondness for Victorian-era Britain. So I’m not really surprised that he decided to write a Target book for this story, and much like Dalekand The Day of the Doctor, it’s more of a reinvention than a straight re-telling.
Gatiss’ central innovation here to present the story as an apparently true recounting from various sources: Jenny narrates the bulk of the book, but there are also contributions from Strax, a man named Thursday, Ada Gillyflower, and the Doctor himself, who narrates the flashback sequence in the TV version. Paw on heart, it’s a pretty clever idea, reminiscent of how the A Series of Unfortunate Events books presents the travails of the Baudelaires as the dutifully-recorded results of Lemony Snicket’s careful investigation, or given who we’re talking about here, Dr. Watson and his notes on Sherlock Holmes. (And oh boy, does Gatiss ever lean into the whole in-universe inspiration for Conan-Doyle thing. Jenny even namedrops him!)
So where do the classic Who references enter into it, you ask? Mostly in dialogue given to the Doctor: the first few chapters present Jenny’s first meeting with the Doctor, in the middle of a case involving a killer song and a homely woman with a breathtakingly beautiful voice. When discussing the case with Vastra and Jenny, the Doctor says, “It’s the precision of it, Jenny – I may call you Jenny, mayn’t I?” That’s Gatiss deliberately slipping in a line of Second Doctor dialogue from The Three Doctors, and not gonna lie, I loved it! There’s another joke later in the book about the Terrible Zodin, this time a Five Doctors reference.
Then there’s this bit, when the Doctor tries sneaking into the circus act and fails:
“Ah yes,’ said the Doctor. ‘That’s why I’m here.’ He flashed his clever paper – the one what’s blank but makes people see what they wants to see – but still the policeman shook his head. ‘Sorry, sir but I haven’t ever heard of the Ambassador to Peladon.”
See that?! A Curse of Peladon reference! And we looked at that book a year ago! As frustrating as I find him sometimes (see: the Giant Rats line in chapter 7) I will admit, every now and then Gatiss reveals himself to be as much of a dork with regard to this show as me, and I do like that about him.
And his Eleventh Doctor is absolutely spot-on, particularly at this point in his life, when he’s started to act his age more and drop the whole “cosmic nine year old” routine. And that’s no easy task! El Sandifer once said that the Second Doctor was very difficult to capture in prose since much of what we like about him is rooted in Patrick Troughton’s performance, and I feel like the same applies with the Eleventh. Matt Smith, when you watch him on screen, is a very physical actor, spinning around a bunch and making theatrical gestures with his arms, to say nothing of his unique line deliveries. But Gatiss is very good at helping the reader to visualize him, particularly in chapter 7, as that’s the one the Doctor narrates.
But where this story really sings, for me, is everything to do with Mrs. Gillyflower, brought so wonderfully to life by the late Dame Diana Rigg in 2013. (She even gets a dedication, as did John Hurt in the Day book.) Mrs. G was already a loathsome person on TV but in prose, where there’s just her words and actions, she’s indescribably awful. Frankly, you’d have to have a heart of stone not to sympathize with Ada when she snaps and attacks her after the reveal that her blindness was caused from science experiments gone wrong.
If there is one point of criticism I have with this book, it’s the inclusion of The Kiss: after Jenny rescues the Doctor from the attic where Ada’s been keeping him prisoner, he restores himself to life and kisses her, despite the fact that she’s a lesbian. I’ve heard it said that the kiss was actually improvised by Matt Smith during shooting, but I’ve seen script extracts where the kiss is mentioned in stage directions, so I think it’s safe to say it wasn’t improv.
That’s still not okay though. Unwanted kissing is still sexual assault, and frankly, Gatiss should’ve known better than to put that in the script in the first place, but if he couldn’t do that, he could’ve at least taken it out of the book. If Terrence Dicks can rewrite a character from The Web of Fear into not being an extremely obvious Jewish stereotype, Mark Gatiss can take out a damn kiss. But he didn’t, and there we are.
Kiss aside though, The Crimson Horror is an excellent book: I enjoyed seeing how the Doctor and Jenny first met, and hints at how he met Vastra, and I think Gatiss’ juggling of at least five different narrators was handled skillfully. (There is a bit in Chapter 8 where Mrs. Gillyflower is referred to as “Mama” despite the fact that it isn’t Ada narrating, but I’ll let that slide. Better than confusing Churchill with Chibnall!) I did roll my eyes a bit at the Talons references, but that’s to be expected from someone of Gatiss’ vintage.
Also, he cuts out the lead-in to Nightmare In Silver, where the Maitland kids find some photos of Clara time traveling and bug her about it. Things like that happened all the time in the classic Targets, and given how annoying the kids are, I can honestly say I’m glad they’re gone.
Next time though, as much as I love Clara, can we please have some Ponds on the next go-around?
Leave a Reply