The RTD Rewind: The Fires of Pompeii

And here we are, The Big One. And I’m not just saying that because this is the only Doctor Who story to feature both Karen Gillan and Peter Capaldi at the same time. This is the story that will ripple out across the future of the show, most prominently in series 9. You wouldn’t expect for an otherwise ordinary historical episode to be so huge, but its hugeness is apparent only in hindsight. Put a pin in that thought for now, we will return to it later.

On the surface, this episode looks exactly like one of a million episodes of Star Trekwhere they talk about the Prime Directive: Starfleet’s non-interference policy. The Time Lords have their own version, which the Doctor refers to during the cave scene:

DOCTOR: Some things are fixed, some things are in flux. Pompeii is fixed.
DONNA: How do you know which is which?
DOCTOR: Because that’s how I see the universe. Every waking second, I can see what is, what was, what could be, what must not. That’s the burden of a Time Lord, Donna. And I’m the only one left.

Prime Directive episodes are tiresome because they inevitably end with the crew of the Enterprise/Voyager/Discovery/Cerritos ultimately electing to interfere, and face the consequences later on, or because there is some moral justification for doing so – see, for instance, the entire plot of 1998’s Star Trek: Insurrection, where the justification is to undercut a conspiracy between Starfleet and the Son’a, the alien antagonists.

But Pompeii quickly refocuses the terms of the debate away from the cliche moral argument about changing history to something a bit more interesting: the act of saving someone in the face of a “fixed” historical atrocity. The Doctor cannot stop Vesuvius from erupting for the same reason she can’t save Rosa Parks: he is a fictional character and has no effect on our material, lived reality. But he can save equally fictional people, and the pivotal scene with Donna in the TARDIS is what gets him to realize this:

DONNA: You can’t just leave them!
DOCTOR: Don’t you think I’ve done enough? History’s back in place and everyone dies.
DONNA: You’ve got to go back. Doctor, I am telling you, take this thing back. It’s not fair.
DOCTOR: No, it’s not.
DONNA: But your own planet. It burned.
DOCTOR: That’s just it. Don’t you see, Donna? Can’t you understand? If I could go back and save them, then I would. But I can’t. I can never go back. I can’t. I just can’t, I can’t.
DONNA: Just someone. Please. Not the whole town. Just save someone.

And so he does. The Doctor rescues Caecilius and his family, and so many years later, he will regenerate into a form that resembles this long-forgotten Roman. To remind himself that the Doctor is supposed to save people. In The Girl Who Died, the Doctor chooses to gift Ashildr with immortality, sparing her from an otherwise fatal injury… but in so doing, he sows the seeds of loss.

No good deed goes unpunished, as the saying goes. In The Waters of Mars, the Doctor’s attempt to change history, as a result of this story, is stopped when one of the people he was saving, Adelaide Brooke, decides to kill herself offscreen, setting history back on its proper course… more or less.

And in series 9, his decision to save Ashildr will eventually lead her to become the mayor of a London trap street, where his companion Clara Oswald will eventually meet her end. He becomes so consumed with guilt, grief, and fury that he tries to bring Clara back to life in Hell Bent, and when that doesn’t work, he tries to wipe her memory instead… only to have the tables turned:

DOCTOR: When you wake up, you will have forgotten me. You’ll have forgotten we ever even met.
CLARA: And why would I want that?
DOCTOR: Because it’s the only way. That stuff in your head, the image of me, they could use it to find you.
(Clara holds out the sunglasses.)
CLARA: I er… I used these.
DOCTOR: On what?
CLARA: That.
DOCTOR: What did you do?
CLARA: What do you think? Ashildr’s right, you see? We’re too alike.
DOCTOR: Tell me what you did.
CLARA: What else? What else do you think I did? I reversed the polarity. Push that button, Doctor, it will go off in your own face.
DOCTOR: You were trying to trick me?
CLARA: What were you doing to me?
DOCTOR: I’m trying to keep you safe.
CLARA: Why? Nobody’s ever safe. I’ve never asked you for that, ever. These have been the best years of my life, and they are mine. Tomorrow is promised to no one, Doctor, but I insist upon my past. I am entitled to that. It’s mine.

Watching the episode, it’s obvious what event Moffat was obliquely referencing and re-staging at this point: Journey’s End. The Doctor tries to do what he did then, only for it to not work, because Clara is smarter than that. She has, no doubt, seen how this story ends.

I fervently believe that Fourteen, remembering this moment, will make a different choice. He will find a way to save Donna, just as he failed to do in the original episode. We saw it happen in The Day of the Doctor, where the entire climax of that story is about three Doctors, one of whom looks like David Tennant, trying to rewrite the end of the Time War.

In hindsight, it’s darkly amusing that the Doctor tells Donna, “If I could go back and save them, then I would. But I can’t.” Because he already has gone back, he just doesn’t remember.

At the end of the day, The Fires of Pompeii is about far more interesting things than the Prime Directive. We will never be faced with the choice of whether or not to change history, but we can choose to save people from appalling atrocities. We can choose to rescue the innocent. As sentient beings, is it not incumbent upon us to help others? To feed the poor, clothe the needy, and shelter those fleeing persecution?

I don’t have to tell you about the humanitarian crisis in Gaza right now, or the ongoing persecution of Palestinians by virtually every western nation. Or for the ongoing genocide against transgender people being waged by Republicans in America. These things are real, and the people being harmed deserve so much better than we’re giving them.

We are making history, all of us, every second. If history is a story we tell ourselves, then let’s make it a good one. The Doctor showed us how. All we have to do is follow his example.

Just save someone.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑