The RTD Rewind: The Waters of Mars

At the end of The Giggle, the newly-born Fifteenth Doctor consoles the exhausted Fourteenth, and specifically says that he’s “running on fumes.” The only solution? The Doctor needs to stop fixing everything else, and start fixing himself. Physician, heal thyself indeed.

Now broadly speaking, this is the in-universe way of taking stock of the last sixty years of Doctor Who adventures, considering the effects that would have on the Doctor, and addressing that. It’s gesturing in a similar direction to Twice Upon A Time, funnily enough, where Twelve says to Bill and Nardole: “A life this long, do you understand what it is? It’s a battlefield, like this one, and it’s empty. Because everyone else has fallen.”

Davies though actually proposes a solution, in the form of the bi-generation: two Doctors live, but one (the David Tennant Doctor) stays behind on Earth to have a family with the Nobles and Melanie Bush, while the Ncuti Gatwa incarnation goes off to meet Ruby Sunday, having healed at last from sixty years of traumatic experiences.

The Waters of Mars, looking back, is the story that begins the domino chain that leads to Fourteen running on fumes, and it all comes down to the fact that for all the obvious physical resemblance, the Tenth and Fourteenth Doctors are very different characters.

Running throughout Ten’s era is the theme of hubris: In The Lenatmas Invasion, he changes British history and dethrones Harriet Jones entirely because she pissed him off. The British Golden Age that Nine spoke of fails to happen, and the end result is that the Master becomes Prime Minister, and at some point, the events of Torchwood: Children of Earth happen. And now, we have him saving Adelaide Brooke’s life, despite the fact that her death on Mars was a fixed point in time.

The scene where the Doctor changes his mind and decides the laws of time don’t matter anymore is when his hubris reaches unbearable levels, as even he himself realizes after Adelaide kills herself. But it’s too late to fix it, and two of the three Doctors that follow him spend their entire lives dealing with the after-effects.

The Eleventh Doctor, obviously, gets hit with this the most. Series 6 is basically an extended deconstruction of the god-like characterization of the Doctor that the Tennant era ran with, while in The Name of the Doctor, the Great Intelligence says of our favorite Time Lord: “Welcome to the final resting place of the cruel tyrant. Of the slaughterer of the ten billion, and the vessel of the final darkness.”

Even as late as the Capaldi era, there are still flashes of Ten’s hubris now and then. Just look at what Twelve says to Ashildr shortly after Clara dies in Face the Raven: “I’ll do my best, but I strongly advise you to keep out of my way. You’ll find that it’s a very small universe when I’m angry with you.”

Just two stories later, Hell Bent is about Twelve experiencing his own Time Lord Victorious moment, and that’s where he starts the story. It takes Clara wiping his memories of her (in a deliberate response to, and role reversal of, Journey’s End) for him to get his head on straight again.

The only post-Tennant Doctor to be spared this reckoning, ironically, is the Thirteenth. True, the Chibnall era spent an alarming amount of time attempting to recapture the glory days of Ten with little success, but there’s nothing like Ten’s hubris in Thirteen. For all that I’ve bitched and moaned about Chibnall’s considerable faults when it comes to writing the Doctor, this relative lack of character depth works out for him here.

Which just makes it slightly ironic that RTD, in Wild Blue Yonder, spins the events of series 13 as Time War 2.0, with the Doctor’s stated failure to save the universe in the aftermath of the Flux event taking the place of the destruction of Gallifrey prior to the revival. Admittedly, this is transparently just RTD attempting to make the best out of the shit sandwich he inherited from Lena Chibnall, but still. You gotta give him an A for effort, at least.

All of this is to say that Fourteen really is a breath of fresh air compared to Ten. Sure, they look and act alike and even dress similarly, but Fourteen comes across, as I’ve said previously, as a version of Ten who had a lot of character development that finally allowed him to work Ten’s more toxic attributes out of his system.

Nothing illustrates this better than the way that the two Tennant Doctors treat the female captains in their respective stories. Adelaide Brooke, in The Waters of Mars, does get respected by Ten when he exposits about what her death will lead to in the future… except that respect is twisted into the Doctor deciding that what he needs to do is save her instead. Brooke now becomes a pawn in the Doctor’s quest to make the laws of time his own, the first step down the path that could have (and in Paul Cornell’s The Four Doctors comic book, did) led to him becoming emperor of the universe.

Meanwhile, the unnamed equinoid captain of the ship in Wild Blue Yonder gets this delightful speech by Fourteen: “Oh, well done, Captain! Because she knew, even with a lost ship, if you were found one day, if you two ever reached the universe, you’d run riot across the stars! And you were already becoming copies of the captain. You’d have owned this spaceship. If you’d copied her perfectly, you could have flown this ship home and started your war. So… she ended her life to hide whatever it is she left behind, because when she died, you hadn’t completed her.”

No attempt at saving the dead captain there, is there? Nope. Her story is done, and the Doctor lets her be, simply serving as the last piece in the puzzle that ultimately destroys the Not-Things. This is who Fourteen is, in a nutshell. Other characters have agency, and that agency will be respected.

Next time… it’s the end, but the moment has been prepared for.

Or is it?

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑