Since I became a fan of the show in 2010, I have seen two big anniversaries: the 50th and the 60th. What’s interesting to me is how different the show’s fortunes are in 2023 than they were in 2013 – back then, the show was on top of the world, to the point that The Day of the Doctor was the second-biggest movie in America after The Hunger Games: Catching Fire.
Ten years later though, and the picture looks very different. Doctor Who isn’t on top of the world anymore. During the previous era, it was teetering on the edge of cancellation, helmed by a man who seemed more interested in revisiting classic Doctor Who than pushing the show forward. It was nostalgia for nostalgia’s sake.
Blessedly, with The Star Beast, RTD shows us that those days are finally behind us. Yes, there is nostalgia, but it’s nostalgia with a desire to move the show forward. That is the difference. The order of the day isn’t just, “Let’s bring back Donna Noble and David Tennant as the Doctor! It’s the anniversary!” It’s doing that, and making it clear that this isn’t just 2008 Redux.
As I’ve expressed periodically in this space, bringing Tennant back wasn’t just a good idea, it was a necessary part of getting the show back into the good graces of the public. In effect, RTD is rebooting Doctor Who again – hence his insisting that Gatwa’s first season will be the new “Series 1.” Get people’s attention by playing the hits, and then at Lenatmas, we get Gatwa. It’s a compelling plan, and one that’s already showing signs of working – The Star Beast has scored very positive reviews from the professionals, and at least in the circles of Who fandom I’m in, the story was greeted rapturously.
Part of this just comes down to the fact that Davies was, and is, an exceptional writer. After five years of plot coming at the expense of character, it’s nice to finally have a writer back in charge who understands that characters are more than just pre-defined roles for exposition and comic relief. They are people too, and if given the chance, we can fall in love with them, as so many people did for Donna Noble and the Tenth Doctor. This reunion tour is a victory lap for those folks, and that’s wonderful!
What makes this work is that Davies has clearly evolved as a writer since the last time he was in charge of Doctor Who. More to the point, he’s evolved a lot on social issues since the 2000s, and there’s a concerted effort at making this new version of the show as inclusive as possible, which I applaud.
I’ve heard criticism from some corners that the gender-related aspects of the story, and making Rose’s transness as big a part of it as it was, was too “on the nose,’ I really do not give a shit. At a time when the trans community is dealing with genocidal rhetoric by the right, and our so-called allies on the left going back on their promises to protect us, stating “TRANS RIGHTS!” as loudly as possible is pretty okay with me, doubly so when in regard to how transness ends up contributing to the solution of “How can Donna remember the Doctor without her head exploding?”
I love that after fifteen years, this black mark on the original Davies era has finally been healed – no doubt, Davies watched Hell Bent, saw the re-enactment of that scene with Twelve and Clara, and the wheels started turning in his head. The end solution, (Donna giving birth to a child and thus spreading the metacrisis out to the next generation) while handled slightly inelegantly, is still an inspired idea. Moffatian, even.
Are there problems with word choice? Sure. Not all trans people are enby, and there’s admittedly a slight whiff of gender essentialism in the “a male-presenting Time Lord like you can’t understand” line… but I see what it’s trying to do – it’s RTD responding to, and building on, the overtly feminist Doctor Who that Steven Moffat spent six seasons working on, and I am 100% here for it.
Further, speaking as a trans woman: I am beyond thrilled that someone from my community is not only on the show, but is front and center in events instead of being shoved onto the screen as token “representation” so the white cishet liberals in the audience can feel good about themselves. There is actual engagement with what being trans is and means here, in a way that simply would not have been possible during the Chibnall era. So, I can forgive a little clunkiness here. Because at least it’s not Sacha Dhawan in a Nazi uniform, or the steaming pile of toxic horseshit that “Thasmin” was.
Is The Star Beast as good as Day? It’s hard to answer, because I feel like the two stories are doing drastically different things… and Day was one episode while Star Beast is the first of three. The plot logic may not be air-tight and the pacing might be off, but at the end of the day, who the hell cares? We’ve just spent five years watching the show fail to achieve the bare minimum. Arguing about plot logic and pacing now, after all that, feels like needless nitpicking.
I am a Doctor Who fan again. It feels slightly odd to say given how significantly Star Trek has replaced Doctor Who in terms of “sci-fi thing I think about a lot,” but at the same time, it feels right. There is room in my heart for both the USS Enterprise and the TARDIS, and I am glad to be in both worlds. Whatever else we might say about the new Davies era, there’s no doubt in my mind that the show is in very, very good paws.
Leave a Reply