Off the Beatle Track: Beatles For Sale

For my money, there is no Beatles album as criminally underrated as 1964’s Beatles For Sale. The main points against it are that, following A Hard Day’s Night proving that they could function perfectly well writing their own music without relying on covers to fill out album sides, doing a record that feels like a throwback to their 1963 work is something of a step back. (And some of the covers are fucking terrible. Which, okay, fair enough.)

But I would argue that even on a record like this, for all that it retains the structure of Please Please Me and With The Beatles (eight originals, six covers) the content is still a drastic shift from what they were doing in 1963.

Just look at the opening trifecta of songs here: “No Reply,” “I’m A Loser,” and “Baby’s In Black.” Taken as a trilogy, these three tracks represent the grimmest, darkest opening to a Beatles album ever – this is John after listening to a ton of Bob Dylan and country music, and that shows. We are lightyears away from “It Won’t Be Long” and “All My Loving” at this point. I mean shit, it’s not until we get to “Eight Days A Week” that we hit a traditional Beatles love song!

Beatles For Sale, far from being a creative step back for the Beatles, is still a step forward. We saw hints of this on A Hard Day’s Night, with songs like “I’ll Be Back,” and we’ll see more of it when we get to Help! and Rubber Soul. But even here, the Beatles were maturing as songwriters, and fast.

This album has a mixed reputation in Beatles fandom, but personally, I’ve always enjoyed it. I can remember the very first copy of it that I ever owned, the original CD version from 1987. That version of the album was mixed in mono, because that was how those first four CDs were released. It wasn’t until I got the 2009 remaster version from iTunes that I heard this album in stereo, and no surprise, I like it even more now!

Let’s go track by track:


No Reply: Based on the song “Silhouettes” from 1957, this is a song in which the narrator tries to contact his unfaithful girlfriend, failing repeatedly. Despite the bossa-nova rhythm of the backing track, it’s a grim opening to the album, but considering the cover (four faces looking shell-shocked, not smiling, in dark clothes) it makes perfect sense. (I dare you, however, to listen to this song the same way again after hearing one of the early takes from Anthology, where they forget the words and sing “your face” at the end of every verse.)

I’m A Loser: A straight break-up song in which the narrator reflects on his mistakes when dating this particular girl, whom he thought the world of, and still does. And I’ll tell you what, nothing hits you quite so hard as listening to this after… well, a break-up.

Baby’s In Black: This might sound weird considering the dark lyrics, but this is genuinely one of my favorite Beatles songs, entirely because of the vocals: John and Paul singing into the same microphone, harmonizing together in a way that only they were able to do, and it really comes alive in stereo. It’s fucking gorgeous.

Rock And Roll Music: John does a Chuck Berry cover, and he does a really great job with it! Kind of reminds me of “Twist and Shout,” though his vocal performance here is a bit more restrained here than in that earlier song. (For a given definition of “restrained” anyway.) Also note the way in which the piano drops out at 1:45.

I’ll Follow the Sun: Another great Beatles ballad, but even here, it presents a somewhat more negative view of love than we’ve come to expect from the boys so far. In other words, this is the gentlest break-up song you could hope to have, though I’ll always associate it with footage of the band in Miami during their first American tour.

Mr. Moonlight: Yeah, no, I’m sorry, the critics are right. This one just sucks. They almost used “Leave My Kitten Alone” (available on Anthology 1) and if you slipped that into place, “Kitten” is obviously a better song. This is just cheesy and awful.

Kansas City/Hey, Hey, Hey, Hey!: One of the first examples we’ve heard of Paul doing his Little Richard impression, it is genuinely incredible, and as a native Missourian, I am happy that both sides of my old home state are represented. (KC here, STL with “Rock And Roll Music.”)

Eight Days A Week: The boys may not have thought much of this one, but it’s one of my favorite love songs of theirs, and intensely relatable now that I’m in a relationship. I really would love my girlfriend eight days a week!

Words of Love: A touching Buddy Holly cover, this song will now forever be connected to the day my girlfriend sent me this song, completely out of the blue, when we first got together. I love you to the moon and back, Lykos. ❤

Honey Don’t: Ringo’s song on the album, and it’s a cover of Carl Perkins. I don’t rate it especially highly, but that might just be because I’ve never been the biggest fan of country music. They do a pretty credible job, and it’s certainly better than “Mr. Moonlight.”

Every Little Thing: Another Beatles song that hits very differently in the throes of a relationship, when I think of the things my girlfriend does for me, my heart gets full. She writes me love poetry, she comforts me when I need comforting, she makes me laugh, she makes *amazing* quesadillas, she’s always happy to see me… we’ve hit a few rough patches in the past few days, but I know our relationship is strong enough to withstand them.

I Don’t Want to Spoil The Party: I’ve never been quite sure what to make of this song. Maybe it’s the admission that the narrator has had a couple drinks and isn’t entirely in his right mind, but I kind of get the impression that the girl in this song ditched her boyfriend for a reason, whether he loves her or not. Dude, just give her some space, and respect the boundary she set.

What You’re Doing: Paul’s turn to write a more straightforward breakup song, this one for me foreshadows “You Won’t See Me” from Rubber Soul. At this point the guy still has hope even as he is steadily losing his patience, whereas two albums later, he’s given up and is cutting her off entirely.

Everybody’s Trying to Be My Baby: Poor George, getting no vocal time until the last track on the album. It’s another Carl Perkins cover, but this one is far more successful. I have to admit I really like the echo on his voice here – a good slap-back echo never hurt anyone.


It’s really funny to me that Beatles fans will bend over backwards to praise Rubber Soul as being the point at which they became true artists, rather than just being a bubblegum pop group with weird hair and amazing harmonies. That shift didn’t just happen out of nowhere. If you listen to their albums in order, you can hear it coming as early as “I’ll Be Back.” For me, Beatles For Sale is a tentative first step in the direction that will get us to Rubber Soul.

Sonically, the two albums really aren’t that far apart from each other. Soul might have a bit more edge to it in terms of raw experimentation (read: the sitar on “Norwegian Wood”) but when it comes to influences, like country and western or Bob Dylan folk rock, you could presumably move a few tracks from Soul over to here and get a pretty consistent sounding album out of it.

Further, I think there’s a definite extent to which the Beatles tend to be graded on a curve. Because so much of their music is ridiculously good, qualitatively speaking, moments where they seem to fall out of step are magnified more than they might be with other groups. There are bands out there who would kill for something like Beatles For Sale.

Last of all, you have to consider the historical context here. By 1964, the cracks in Beatlemania were already starting to show, and the boys were worn out – just look at those faces on the cover. Ringo in particular is giving us a thousand-yard stare for the ages. As their music gets more complicated and interesting, the stress of constant touring and live performances gets worse too – hell, the next album’s title song is entirely about how trapped John felt in the hurricane that was their early Sixties fame.

So, the fact that the Beatles were able to write and record an album, and do a decent job of it despite all the pressures they were dealing with in late 1964, is nothing short of miraculous. Their work ethic really was incredible.

Next time: Stop worrying! Help! is on the way!

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑