Wolf Trek: Too Short A Season

Captain’s log, stardate 79232.0: When the Enterprise is ordered to transport a Starfleet Admiral to a hostage negotiation, Picard realizes the Admiral has overdosed on an illegal de-aging drug which could jeopardize the whole mission.


In which we have our first encounter with what will become an (in)famous Star Trek mainstay, the “badmiral,” to use the term coined by Captain Carol Freeman of the USS Cerritos. For whatever reason, whenever an officer goes beyond the rank of captain, even the best Starfleet officer goes a little haywire.

In-universe, it’s never explained why so many flag officers tend to get corrupt, but if I had to guess, I would say it’s because that when you’re taken off the bridge of a starship and put into a desk job, you can’t handle the boredom. Perhaps that’s why, in Generations, Kirk (who has been an insane admiral in the movies) tells Picard in the Nexus: “Don’t let them promote you. Don’t let them transfer you. Don’t let them do anything that takes you off the bridge of that ship, because while you’re there, you can make a difference.”

And then what happens is that, in the backstory of Star Trek: Picard, Jean-Luc is promoted to admiral, put onto the bridge of another ship entirely, and given the mission to evacuate the Romulans from their soon-to-explode star. Then that goes south, Picard quits, and by the time we hit the main action of seasons 1 and 3, while we know Picard is in the right, the people he’s trying to work with (Clancy, another admiral, and Captain Liam Shaw) certainly think he’s a nutcase. Oh, the irony.

Which brings me back to the OG TNG Badmiral, Mark Jameson. Per Star Trek.com: 

Admiral Mark Jameson was a lauded officer who commanded the U.S.S. Gettysburg. In his old age, he suffered from the incurable Iverson’s Disease, which left him wheelchair-bound. Despite this, he was requested by the Mordan IV governor Karnas to help negotiate a new peace treaty. While the planet had ended their civil war years prior, current terrorists have captured a Federation Ambassador and his staff on their planet. The governor specifically requested Jameson as he was the Starfleet officer who negotiated the release of hostages from Mordan decades prior.

Captain Picard and the Enterprise was tasked with transporting Jameson to Mordan. Ahead of the negotiations, the admiral secretly started an age-reversing drug trial. However, he took a dosage of the unstable agent that was enough for two individuals. They soon all learn the hostage situation was a ploy to lure Jameson back to Mordan by Karnas. 

Turning to Picard, Jameson revealed that his career-lauding hostage negotiation was a farce. It was only “successful” as he was supplying both sides, Karnas and his rivals, with weapons, which led to the planet’s 40-year war, as well as being a clear violation of the Prime Directive. There are no terrorists on the planet; Karnas himself is holding the hostages and intends for Jameson to pay dearly for the death and destruction he wrought on Mordan. Now visibly and physically decades younger, the brash Jameson demanded an armed rescue mission believing he could still balance the scales. His pomp and hubris ultimately led to his eventual death as his body shut down from the drug and reverse aging.

Not great, is it? And the hell of it is, what this guy did is nothing compared to the shit that other admirals we’ll see over the course of TNG get up to. 

What’s brilliant about this episode is that for the first time, the Federation (and by extension, Starfleet itself) is held up to a microscope and revealed to be found wanting. One of the common criticisms I often hear from Trek fans online is that contemporary Trek shows (most infamously, Discovery and Picard) spend a lot of time criticizing the Federation, going against the Roddenberry ideals that had animated the original Star Trek.

What these people seem to forget is that criticizing the Federation isn’t some new thing, it’s been going on since 1988. An episode like “Too Short A Season” paints a bleak picture of what the Federation allowed to happen – Mark Jameson should’ve been thrown in prison for what he did, but instead, he was lionized and became a respected admiral, because he misrepresented his actions at Mordan in the first place. Dying at the end thanks to a drug overdose is the only comeuppance he gets. (Well, that and it was pretty clear his wife was about ready to divorce him after she realized how selfish he was being.)

Bear in mind also that Roddenberry was still calling the shots. Sometimes that leads to episodes like “Angel One” and “The Naked Now,” and sometimes that means letting this episode, critical of the Federation and Starfleet as it is, go out pretty much as intended. Only the crew of the Enterprise itself come out with their hands clean. All of a sudden, this is no longer a show about the ambassadors of a perfect utopia cruising around space, but the crew of one starship striving to do what’s right, because their government is imperfect and flawed.

This is a theme I’ve touched on a lot in my own Trek writing. The Federation of the 2390s and early 2400s is one that has become isolationist, lightyears away from the more exploratory incarnation we see through much of TNG. My characters, having grown up on the stories of the golden age that was the 2360s, want to bring something of that era back, even as the forces of corrupt admirals, the passage of time, and the ghosts of things like the Dominion War and the Romulan supernova make that task more difficult. Not because they want to pretend it’s still 2366, but because they know Starfleet can be better than it is.

And that, I think, is part of why I keep coming back to TNG. Conceived in the dark days of Ronald Reagan and the conservative revolution that began under him, continued under Bush, and led directly to the conservative Democrat administration of Bill Clinton, TNG reminds us that true patriotism is not saying, “The Federation is always right,” but being clear-eyed about its faults and trying to hold yourself up to a better standard, in the hope that others might do the same.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑