Wolf Trek: Home Soil

Captain’s log, stardate 79270.1: The Enterprise arrives at the Velara terraforming base to check on progress but soon discovers that an alien intelligence is responsible for murdering one of the terraformers and soon commandeers the Enterprise.


I think one of the major differences of TNG compared to the original series, and one that makes it increasingly relevant in today’s world, is expanding the concept of computers beyond the boxy megalomaniac types you saw in the ‘60s and toward asking serious questions about artificial lifeforms and transhumanism, looking toward these things with genuine curiosity rather than fear.

This was an age where the giant computers that took up an entire room in a lab somewhere not only shrunk down to desk size, but got friendlier to use. With the advent of the Apple’s original Macintosh in 1984, you no longer needed a degree in computer science to use a computer – simply by moving a little arrow around with an attached mouse, you could click a button and open a program. That was huge.

All of a sudden, computers were friendly, and you can draw a direct line from the Macintosh of 1984 to Data, everyone’s favorite android. He’s a nice guy who just happens to be a machine. But because humans are so used to the idea of machines being used for labor, even something as nominally progressive as Starfleet struggles with dealing with artificial life.

This episode, along with season 2’s “The Measure of a Man” and “The Quality of Life” in season six, form a trilogy of stories based around the idea of artificial life as something to be treasured and respected rather than feared. The Moriarty duology of “Elementary, Dear Data” and “Ship in A Bottle” explore this too, by giving us the concept of a sentient hologram. And of course, Voyager will go even further and give us the character of the Doctor, (no, not the Time Lord) a holographic crew member.

During his famous defense of Data in “The Measure of a Man,” Picard asks: “A single Data, and forgive me, Commander, is a curiosity. A wonder, even. But thousands of Datas. Isn’t that becoming a race? And won’t we be judged by how we treat that race?”

Which brings us to “Home Soil.” The episode begins with the Enterprise checking in on what first appears to be a routine terraforming mission, until it transpires that, contrary to what Starfleet knows, there is life on this seemingly barren world – just inorganic life. And in terraforming the planet to make it suitable for organic life, Starfleet has inadvertently been committing genocide:

VOICE: We die. Bags of water kill us. You are like others.
PICARD: We have no wish to kill you. We never have.
VOICE: You do not say truth.
PICARD: We will end this war, if you will end the war.
VOICE: Darkness. Death. Terrible. Must go home to wet sand. War over.

This is the kind of optimism toward artificial life, and computers in general, we just don’t really see anymore. Modern-day Trek is distinctly more cynical on the idea of artificial life – the second season of Discovery was all about Control, an AI system instituted by Section 31, going insane and trying to kill everyone.

Lower Decks returned us to the exocomps to discovered by Data and made one a villain, in the same season as Rutherford’s insane holodeck program doing what Moriarty couldn’t and actually leaving the holodeck. And that’s before you get to the end of season 3 and the Texas class of starships – unmanned vessels controlled solely by AI, which predictably go nuts and destroy a Sovereign class vessel – the same class as the Enterprise-E.

The turn toward negativity as regards artificial life is not terribly surprising. We’re living in an age where AI generated “artwork” infests deviantArt and ArtStation like a plague. The disastrous Willy Wonka candy experience from Scotland had promotional art generated by AI, and an AI-written script that leads to meme-worthy concepts like the Unknown, an evil chocolate maker who lives in the walls. (Can they see DNA on bloodstains as well?)

Hell, the recent writer and actor strikes were about making sure that studios couldn’t just generate AI-written and AI-acted slop to feed the masses who are too busy looking at their phones to watch TV anyway. If this is where we got after spending a large chunk of the late ‘80s and early ‘90s dreaming about synthetic life that acts a lot like Data and less like Lore, has something gone horribly wrong? Is there no hope?

Star Trek: Picard suggests there might be.

In the first season, much of the action revolves around two story threads: the abandoned Romulan rescue plan in advance of the 2387 supernova seen in the first Kelvin movie, and the synth uprising that led to the rescue plan being abandoned in the first place. Said uprising led to an immediate ban on all forms of synthetic life, and androids themselves being looked at as figures of fear and suspicion. Even Data, the nicest guy in the world, was treated as a figure of distrust by a news reporter in “Remembrance.”

But Picard isn’t about to sit down and let the androids perish. Oh no, not our Jean-Luc. In defiance of Starfleet, our favorite campaigner for the rights of cybernetic minorities spends much of the season looking for a young synth woman – a person who behaves, looks, and acts like a human. You wouldn’t know she was artificial just by looking at her.

After tracking her down and taking her to her home planet, Picard fights off the Tal Shiar and gives his life to stop the synths from unleashing apocalypse on the organic beings of the universe, because he still believes that androids are another form of life, and worthy of our respect. And yes, our love, too.

For all the grief people gave the Picard show about not being Star Trek, I kind of feel like they’re missing the forest for the trees. Star Trek is a show that looks at something we might treat with scorn or suspicion and says, “Hey, what if instead of hating this thing because it’s different from us, why not appreciate it instead?”

AI can be used for good things too, it isn’t all just pictures of humans with seven fingers and eleven toes. AI is what allowed the Beatles to sing one last song, with John sounding as clear in death as he did in life. It’s what allowed Peter Jackson to take archival footage from World War 1, colorize it, and make a movie out of the results.

For better or worse, we’ll always have a love affair for technology – just look at the outpouring of love and grief we felt when Opportunity died.

What matters is what we do with it.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑