Magical Mystery Tour is something of an odd duck in Beatles lore. Like Help! and A Hard Day’s Night before it, its first half is a soundtrack album, consisting of the six songs written for the 1967 TV movie… except that it was never released as an album in the UK. At least, not during the 1960s.
Here’s the situation: in the UK, Magical Mystery Tour was released as a double EP, with three songs on two vinyl records. EPs were not as popular in America, and even though the Beatles’ 1967 recording contract stipulated that Capitol couldn’t fuck around with their albums like they had until 1966, someone there probably figured that since the Beatles hadn’t technically released an album of songs in the UK, they could do whatever they wanted.
So, in November 1967, the 11-track Magical Mystery Tour album came out, with the six film songs and the band’s five 1967 singles all included. It sold like gangbusters here, and copies of the album eventually found their way to the UK, though it wasn’t officially released there until 1976, long after the band had broken up. When the Beatles’ back catalogue was issued on CD in 1987, the American Magical Mystery Tour album became part of the official Beatles canon – on the 2009 remasters, the CD even has a ‘60s Capitol label on the front, rather than a Parlophone or Apple one.
So, with all this in mind, how does it stack up? Let’s find out:
Magical Mystery Tour: As with A Hard Day’s Night and Help! the first track is the title song for the movie, though where the title songs for those two films still worked really well as songs in their own right, “Mystery” really is a movie song, in that much like the lead-off track on Pepper, it spells out the premise of the movie. It’s a pretty cool song, but there’s really nothing to it if you decouple it from the film.
The Fool on the Hill: My second-favorite Paul song from 1967, this is yet another song of his that flirts with classical music rather than rock and roll, though this time the story is about a lonely man on the hill who is, and remains, misunderstood in his community. In other words, it’s an anthem for outcasts everywhere. Goodness knows I’ve vibed with it a lot of late.
Flying: The first ever, and only, instrumental Beatles song to appear on a regular album. I really dig it, honestly? It grooves along really nicely, it’d be a good song to listen to while watching scenery drift by car windows. Ringo carries this song really well, it’s a shame it’s only two minutes. I want an extended cut!
Blue Jay Way: By now, George Harrison doing Indian-inspired music is almost a cliche, or it seems like one. But every time he’s done it, he’s done it slightly differently: “Love You To” had a heavy rock influence, while “Within You Without You” was a fusion of Indian and Western styles of classical music. “Blue Jay Way” is altogether stranger: an Indian-inspired piece played with Western instruments… about George, sitting in a house in Los Angeles, fighting off sleep while waiting for a friend to show up. The atmosphere of the song is exceptionally dark and eerie – you really feel the foggy, sleep-deprivation vibes of the night. As a kid it freaked me out, but as an adult, I really like it. Probably one of the most Gothic songs the Beatles ever did.
Your Mother Should Know: And now for something completely different. It’s a music hall number serving as a plea by Paul for generational understanding, and was almost used as the band’s contribution for the One World telecast, until they went with “All You Need is Love” instead. And honestly, I’m glad they switched songs. I get the point Paul is trying to make, but it’s a little hard for me to go along with it, given my mother’s history of emotional and psychological abuse toward me. Some rifts just can’t be repaired, even if you play a Beatles song.
I Am the Walrus: If you want a song that perfectly encapsulates the psychedelic swirl of madness that was 1967, “Walrus” is easily the song to choose. John wrote it as a response to all those fans who tried to find hidden meanings in Beatles lyrics, so he composed a song where all the words are basically nonsensical, based on everything from Lewis Carroll to Liverpudlian skipping rhymes. (And then people argued over who the walrus was: John, or as he suggests in “Glass Onion,” Paul? John finally settled the issue in 1970 with the lyric, “I was the Walrus, but now I’m John,” from the song “God.”)
Hello, Goodbye: A song about opposites, and another Paul song. Really not too much to say about it, but I like the melody, and the music videos are really great – the band play on a stage in their Sgt. Pepper suits, and periodically you see them dressed up in the grey collarless suits from the “I Want to Hold Your Hand” single cover. In other ones they play their instruments and goof around like total dorks, it’s kind of amazing. Easily one of my favorite Beatles videos, if I’m honest.
Strawberry Fields Forever: My all-time favorite Beatles song ever, this. John wrote this in Spain after the band finished touring in 1966, and the actual recording of the song launched the band’s psychedelic period. It’s probably the most technically complicated song they ever did, not just with all the instrumentation going on, but the way it sounds – the first minute or so is in the key of B flat, while the rest of it (originally recorded in a higher key) had to be slowed down to match the first part. The resulting edit is one of the most famous pieces of Beatles lore ever, and the song just wouldn’t feel the same without it. What starts as a nostalgic look back at a favorite hiding place of John’s as a kid becomes an LSD-infused wonderland, and it’s absolutely brilliant. I wish I could’ve heard this in 1967 – it probably blew everyone’s minds.
Penny Lane: Paul’s own nostalgia piece about his childhood in Liverpool, it’s far more conventional, musically, than “Strawberry Fields,” though there is a touch of surrealism in some of the lyrics. I like it, but it doesn’t hit the spot for me in quite the same way “Strawberry Fields” does.
Baby, You’re A Rich Man: I’ve been reading Al Brodax’s book about the making of the Yellow Submarine movie recently, and one of the stories he tells in the book has him at Abbey Road one day, tending to some issue regarding the Beatles cartoon show he was making at the time, and heard this song played by the band. I’m not entirely sure I believe this anecdote, but who cares? It’s a great song all the same, the focus on the dangers of materialism, for all the world, remind me of “Imagine.” I love this song, and I swear it has to be one of the deepest cuts out there. (A lot of the Mystery Tour/Yellow Submarine songs feel like that to me, honestly.)
All You Need is Love: The quintessential Beatles song, right here. Like, if you had to distill everything that band was into one track, this would be the one you’d pick: an anthem about the power of love, and its singular power to heal divisions of all sorts. It’s a fusion of rock and classical music, it’s got a great hook, it’s thought-provoking without being too on-the-nose. It’s even got a brief snatch of “She Loves You,” a nod to the band’s roots. See what I mean? Quintessential!
I was talking with my girlfriend yesterday about the Pepper blog, and one point she made is that I tend to prefer improvising my way through things rather than working off an outline. This is true: exactly 0% of anything I’ve ever written, from fanfic to blog posts to original fiction, has come from an outline. I am a discovery writer, in that I learn what the piece is about while I’m working on it.
Pepper, as good as it is, definitely feels planned out. Magical Mystery Tour, on the other paw, is pure improvisation – this is true of the movie as well, and that improv spirit finds its way into the album too. And I think for me personally, it’s a more interesting album than Pepper. Both are great, but if I’m going to choose one album from the psychedelic era to listen to, it’s going to be the underdog of Beatles albums.
There’s some really great material here, and I think it’s a shame that it gets overlooked. Following Sgt. Pepper would’ve been a difficult task for anyone, and it’s notable that the Beatles only did it by going in the complete opposite aesthetic direction.
Magical Mystery Tour exists very much in the spirit of Pepper, and belongs to the same cultural moment. And I hope, if Giles Martin ever gets around to remixing it, that more people will come to appreciate it as much as I do.
Leave a Reply