Captain’s log, stardate 79327.8: Riker, Data and Yar beam down to the planet Minos only to discover a deadly robot weapon is hunting them down. Beaming down to assist, Picard and Crusher may be the only hope for the doomed away team.
When I say that TNG’s first season is under-appreciated in the wider Trek fandom, episodes like this are exactly what I mean. There are times where the show focuses too much on one character, leaving others to be underutilized. In the first season, Tasha, Troi, Geordi, and Worf all got hit with this bolt of near-invisibility – you can’t believe they were being paid to sit around and say lines like “Hailing frequencies open, sir” or “Course laid in, Captain.”
And then there are episodes like “Arsenal,” where it’s abundantly clear someone went ahead and said, “Let’s give everyone something to do.” And even within the time-jumping context I’m working in, where I know what the future is going to be and it feels like the show is gesturing toward it, even I can’t help but be stunned that something this good exists.
It’s TNG’s most transformative episode – in my opinion, this is the exact moment where the arc of the next six seasons suddenly becomes clear. This is when the show proves it is worthy of that number.
For a start, let’s take this moment to focus on the trio of Riker, Tasha, and Data. All three of them are great: Riker tricking the Paul Rice hologram into shutting itself off is an incredible moment, ditto Data jumping down into the ravine and landing, cat-like, on both feet. But Tasha, for me, is the one who really shines. After all, Riker and Data are going to get 37 years of character development, whereas Tasha? She only gets this one episode.
Denise Crosby is absolutely on fire in this episode – she left the show because, understandably, she didn’t feel like she had enough to do. And she was right, she didn’t! There’s only a handful of times where she’s allowed the spotlight, and one of those times is the episode where she dies halfway through act two. You get the inescapable sense that if she’d had more episodes like “Arsenal,” she would’ve stayed, and we’d be talking about her in the same glowing fashion with which we talk about Riker and Data today.
This is her best episode by far, but equally, it should not have taken until the back six episodes of the season for the writers to start caring about Tasha. The ingredients for a memorable character were all there, it’s a shame that no one put them together until now.
Moving up the chain of command, let’s talk about Beverly and Picard. Obviously, given how things went in season 3 of Picard, it’s clear even at this early stage that there is something between them, but both of them are hesitant to act, since A) Picard is still Bev’s direct superior, so there’s a power imbalance, and B) this is TV in the late 1980s and the kind of serialization and character development that later Treks are famous for hasn’t been invented yet.
Beverly and Jean-Luc are just friends for now, and that’s fine, because that’s all they need to be. They’re just getting to know each other now, and that sort of relationship building takes time. They’ll reach the promised land eventually, even if it takes them a while to get there.
Also on strong form this week: Geordi and Worf. Michael Dorn is clearly having the time of his life getting to play Worf at tactical, and I’d like to think that it’s his actions here that lead to Picard recommending that he, specifically, take over for Tasha in that role after she dies.
I feel like there was a bond between Worf and Tasha, which makes a certain amount of sense. Both of them are kindred spirits, in one way or another. Turkana IV is just as hardscrabble a world as Qo’noS, she had to learn to think on her feet if she was going to survive in that hellscape, something that Worf would’ve understood immediately. After all, on his planet, hesitating for an instant can mean the difference between living to fight another day, or being brutally cut down at knife point.
Like, sure, it was Data that Tasha was canonically closest to, but I have to believe she liked Worf a lot too, and maybe would have considered bringing him on as her second had things not gone south with Armus. Certainly, I would’ve expected him to do the Klingon death roar for her. If any human deserves to go to Sto-vo-kor, it’s Tasha.
Moving on to Geordi La Forge, our guy gets his best outing all season. While he will go on to become a legendary engineer, as my girlfriend commented when she watched this episode with me, you kind of wonder why there’s never been a Captain Geordi show. You definitely get he understands the basic principles of command, not just from watching Picard, but his own intuition.
There’s something of “LeVar Burton the Reading Rainbow host” about the way he acts here, most prominently in the way he interacts with Troi during the ready room scene, but especially in the way he puts that jackass Leland Lynch (chief engineer number 4) in his place. And as for his plan to separate the ship so he can go into battle while Lynch commands the saucer section? Sheer brilliance.
As Forest of Illusions observed, “This isn’t just good with qualifiers, which is how you can describe a decent segment of this year if you were inclined to be uncharitable, it’s genuinely *great*. It’s a flagrantly experimental story that’s one of the first clear departures from the Original Series template Star Trek: The Next Generation is saddled with and is, in retrospect, probably the definitive example of the kind of risks the series only took in its inaugural year. Everything about this episode is demonstrative of a show that’s creatively energized, bold, confident and self-assured.”
This is the show that gets to seven seasons, four movies, and a spinoff. This is how you do Star Trek, people. Give me more of this, and less of the innumerable prequels and TOS era throwbacks.
Leave a Reply