Wolf Trek: The Child

Captain’s log, stardate 79500.1: The Enterprise’s new Chief Medical Officer Dr. Pulaski is faced with a mystery when Troi is impregnated and gives birth to a rapidly maturing child. Meanwhile, the Enterprise is forced to carry a deadly plasma plague on a mercy mission.


With this entry, we begin TNG’s second season, and are we ever in for a ride. As I wrote in the post on “The Neutral Zone,” the writers’ strike of 1988 adversely affected production on TNG, which meant the production crew didn’t have much by way of scripts to turn into episodes, once the strike ended in August 1988. So, Jaron Summers, Jon Povill, and Maurice Hurley grabbed a TOS-era script off the shelf, dusted it off, and turned it into a TNG episode.

According to Memory Alpha:

“In the original Phase II story, Ilia gave birth to a baby girl, Irska, who posed a similar threat to the Enterprise by having a weakening effect on the ship’s hull. In the first draft script, though, the alien child considered Uhura and Chekov as possible host bodies before finally settling on Ilia.”

“The Enterprise soon encountered an alien cylinder that endangered the ship and crew by creating problems that only the child, Irska, had the means to resolve. Maurice Hurley stated that his rewrites were based on the Phase II story rather than the original script, which he never read.”

And in fairness to Hurley, he does a good enough job making the script fit into the TNG era. After all, this is the episode where Worf switches to the operations division and becomes the formal chief of security, while Geordi receives his long-overdue promotion to chief engineer.

Going from helmsman to chief engineer does wonderful things for LeVar Burton’s performance. Not that he was ever bad in season one, but there’s only so much acting you can do when you’re stuck there in the helm console all day. Burton’s performance really comes to life in episodes like “The Arsenal of Freedom,” where he’s asked to command the ship.

He’s thrilled to be doing something more interesting, and that bleeds through into how he plays Geordi here. He just makes sense as chief engineer in a way that he never did as helmsman. And, as well, it means we never have to worry about the rotating cycle of chief engineers ever again. None of the others worked out, but our man La Forge certainly does!

This is also the episode where we meet Guinan – a very old friend of Picard’s, going back to his days as captain of the Stargazer. (Guinan contradicts this, but she’s clearly lying.) I love the character to pieces, but then, who doesn’t? Whoopi Goldberg plays her magnificently, and that’s before you get into her amazing hat collection.

Goldberg has been a fan of Trek since the TOS era, when she saw Nichelle Nichols as Uhura and reportedly cried, “There’s a black lady on TV and she ain’t no maid!” Come the late 1980s, LeVar Burton asked Gene Roddenberry to create a role for her, and Guinan was the result.

Speaking of debuts, Riker gets his beard, and everyone rejoices because it means Jonathan Frakes now looks like himself. Further, with the offscreen departure of Gates McFadden between seasons 1 and 2, we are instead introduced to Dr. Katherine Pulaski, played by Diana Muldaur. The general idea for Pulaski was to have a character who could serve as the TNG equivalent of Leonard McCoy, with Data serving as the Spock equivalent, and the (in)famous banter that passed between the two of them.

There are some problems with this. Quoting TV Tropes:

“Dr. Pulaski was intended to be an Expy of Dr. Leonard McCoy, and her jabs at Data were designed to recreate the Spock/Bones dynamic. However, Spock did have human emotions, he just repressed them, and was very vocal about how superior he believed himself to be to his human crewmates.”

“By contrast Data was not capable of emotions but desperately wanted to be. Despite technically lacking things like compassion, he was also a wide-eyed Nice Guy as opposed to Spock’s somewhat frosty Jerk with a Heart of Gold personality. So where Bones came across as an everyman taking an insufferably smug person down a peg, Pulaski came across as a fantastic racist bullying the sweetest person in the galaxy.”

In this episode, she does not make a good first impression, what with referring to Data as “it” and “a machine,” or when she refuses to meet with Picard personally, forcing him to go down to Ten Forward instead.

In fairness, Pulaski does improve a little over the course of the season, but she’s still not a good fit for this crew, so it’s hard not to cheer when Beverly returns at the start of season 3.

I have so far avoided talking about the main plot of the episode, mainly because it sucks. Like, I understand why they made it, but that doesn’t mean it was a good idea! The observation lounge scene where the crew are informed about Troi’s pregnancy is particularly egregious – as we watched it, Sophie yelled at the screen: “Can you please talk to someone who has actually been through a pregnancy?!”

This, for me, is the episode where TNG’s many problems with writing women come to the fore. If we get focused on at all, it’s always in terms of child-rearing and motherhood. I mean, just look at how much of Beverly’s characterization was centered around Wesley! And if you’re someone like Tasha Yar, who doesn’t fit into that box? Then Goddess help you, because you may as well be wallpaper.

Now don’t get me wrong: I love TNG, and I always will. It’s deeply personally significant for me, and of course, in terms of wider pop culture, we are all still living in its shadow: Russell T Davies could not have revived Doctor Who in 2005, and resurrected it in 2023, if TNG hadn’t done the same for Trek in the late 1980s. The science fiction cultural renaissance we’re living in started because of TNG.

But it’s also a product of its time, just as anything else is, and here I don’t mean the Hilton lobby-esque interior of the Enterprise, much as I love it, or even the fact that the sets are so brightly lit because the TV cameras of that era couldn’t work in low-light conditions, whereas now they can.

I mean in terms of gender politics. Trek has always been an exceptionally masculine franchise: even when there’s a woman in the lead role, as on Voyager or Discovery, a lot of the writers of those characters are still going to be men. This is how you get the immediately cringe-worthy exchange in the otherwise wonderful Insurrection:

TROI: And have you noticed how your boobs have started to firm up?
CRUSHER: Not that we care about such things in this day and age.

And who wrote that, you ask? Rick freaking Berman, one of the sleaziest humans alive today. He may have been responsible for the ‘90s Trek renaissance, but good goddess above, the man was an absolute slime-ball.

Anyway. “The Child” sucks. It’s as sexist as “The Naked Now,” and I’d like to never watch it again.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑