Across the Universe: Spirits of Ancient Egypt (The Legend of Ruby Sunday/Empire of Death)

After what could otherwise be described as the most accessible season of the show in six years, with no returning villains (kinda-sorta) and fairly light-hearted stories, RTD unexpectedly hits us with one of the darkest finales the show has done in a long time – only Dark Water quite matches it. (And funnily enough, that story also featured Kate Stewart and UNIT!)

Legit, I was not expecting series 14 to conclude with a sequel to, of all things, 1975’s Pyramids of Mars. I mean, as Hinchcliffe-era Tom Baker stories to do sequels to, it at least makes a bit more sense than The Brain of Morbius. Certainly, the twist was absolute perfection.

It’s a very Moffat-ian bit of misdirection: for the bulk of the story, we are led to believe that Doctor Who is finally Going There and bringing back Susan, last seen in 1965’s The Dalek Invasion of Earth. The Doctor promised her that he would come back for her… and then simply never did, at least on television. (Big Finish has him come back as the Eighth Doctor, and she’s appeared periodically ever since, both with and without her grandfather.)

Davies goes as far as you possibly can with that line of thinking, up to (and including) having the Doctor actually meet Susan… only for her to not recognize him. (Not because he’s Black and young as opposed to white and old, but because she’s not actually Susan – just a vessel of Sutekh.)

A Susan return story is simply never going to happen, for much the same reason it’s very unlikely that we’ll ever see Rose, Human Ten, or Amy and Rory back again – when a character is defined by their absence, as Susan is, telling a story where they come back is inevitably going to be a bit of a let-down, because then you have to figure out what to do with them next.

Sure, we got Donna Noble during the 60th, but there were extenuating circumstances at play there: the memory wipe she went through in Journey’s End was a wound that needed healing, both in terms of character and in terms of the show itself. Whereas bringing Susan back would just be ticking a box. There’s no story there. 

(Unless, of course, Carole Ann Ford has actually filmed new scenes as Susan. Which is not outside the realm of possibility, but I still think it unlikely.)

Anyway, as it goes there’s not much to The Legend of Ruby Sunday – it’s basically an extended trailer for Empire of Death, albeit with lots of fun stuff like Kate Stewart getting to do her thing, Mel calling the Doctor out on his bullshit when he has an emotional breakdown, the VHS tape holodeck sequence that goes very very wrong, and Gabriel Woolf proving he can still sound incredibly terrifying at the age of ninety-one.

In retrospect, Harriet being yet another Arbinger really should’ve been obvious, since everyone else in the meet-and-greet gave their surnames except her, but I admit I didn’t clock it until it was actually revealed.

Let’s move on, then, to Empire of Death.

As I remarked in earlier posts, I can’t escape the feeling that series 14-era RTD watched the Moffat seasons and took notes. For me, there are echoes of The Pandorica Opens/The Big Bang here – as in Pandorica, part 1 is filled with a bunch of characters, and the entire story is largely functioning as set-up for part two, with a misdirection mystery to keep you occupied: “What’s in the Pandorica?” versus “Is it really Susan?”

Then the twist hits, and suddenly your understanding of the story is turned completely upside down. All of a sudden we discover that the Pandorica isn’t hiding anything, it is in fact a prison meant to contain something: Specifically, the Doctor. 

And then, all of a sudden, everything goes horribly horribly wrong. Amy gets killed by a plastic Rory, River gets stuck in an exploding TARDIS, and the Doctor is locked inside the Pandorica. The narrative collapse that we’ve spent the entire episode trying to prevent is instead allowed to pass.

RTD’s take on this idea, beat for beat, is virtually identical to how Pandorica/Bang functions, save for the fact that the cliffhanger at the end of part 1 is not Sutekh dusting everyone. Instead it’s the Doctor about to be dusted… which is then resolved, at the start of part 2, by Mel pulling him away out of the line of fire.

Instead, the equivalent sequences in which every possible avenue of escape are removed from the board are moved to the start of part 2, when the UNIT cast are all dusted, followed shortly thereafter by… pretty much the entire rest of the world, save for the Doctor, Ruby, and Mel.

If The Legend of Ruby Sunday was overstuffing the episode with cameos and return appearances from Rose Noble to Carla Sunday in much the same way Pandorica gave us as many monsters as the budget could handle, Empire is more like The Big Bang: a small-scale chamber piece centered on the Doctor and Ruby, with Sutekh co-opting Mel to serve as his eyes and ears. The entire plot of both episodes can be neatly summarized as “the Doctor figuring out how to extricate himself from a collapsed narrative.” 

But I guess it’s cooler when Moffat does it, because when RTD does it, the response becomes, “On the one hand it’s a very tidy streamlining so that the episode can largely consist of the Doctor, Ruby, and Mel. It’s the decision that gets us the Agua Centina sequence, at the end of the day. But it’s also the end of any meaningful suspense. Instantly you know everyone is going to get restored. There’s really no stakes left,” as Elizabeth Sandifer wrote in her review of the story.

Let’s make no bones about it: Sandifer is flatly wrong here. I am frankly astounded that someone who wrote the following about The Pandorica Opens can then turn around, watch the exact same series of plot beats eleven years later, and write something as depressingly cynical as the above paragraph: “The narrative collapse isn’t threatened – it’s allowed to happen. […] Every possible avenue of escape is closed down, every possible agent who could fix things is sidelined. The narrative collapses utterly, such that, at the end of The Pandorica Opens, there’s absolutely nothing that can possibly follow it.”

How is that not an accurate description of the first ten minutes of Empire, El? Seriously, how?! This is bullshit, lazy criticism from someone who ought to fucking know better. What is the Doctor’s escape from the Pandorica at the start of part 2 the exact same beat as Mel pulling the Doctor away from Sutekh but with extra steps? If anything, Davies is cutting out the middleman!

For my money, there is functionally no difference between Moffat allowing every star and planet in the universe to go supernova and Sutekh dusting the shit out of everyone like he’s Thanos in Endgame. Like, fucking obviously we know everyone will get restored by the end of the episode, that’s not the point! The point is we don’t know how it’s undone, just like we didn’t know about Big Bang Two until the Doctor spelled it out for us! The question isn’t, “Will the Doctor get out of this?!” it’s, “How does he win?” To say otherwise is a failure of imagination!

And don’t even get me started on the resolution to the mystery of who Ruby’s mother is. The firestorm of criticism about that has been teeth-gratingly annoying. Because at the end of the day, after weeks of speculation and red herrings that Ruby must be, I don’t know, the 2020s equivalent of Rose “Bad Wolf” Tyler, it turns out…

Ruby’s mom is an entirely ordinary woman. And Ruby herself isn’t some eldritch horror from the dawn of time or something, she’s just… another ordinary woman. It’s the RTD version of Moffat’s Impossible Girl arc from series 7, minus all the nasty problematic bits that came with that arc.

But to hear Doctor Who Twitter talk about it, the reveal is really just cynical engagement bait. As Josh Snares wrote: “Why should I, as a fan, invest my time and energy into a programme if it’s just bait for engagement. To increase your reach, to get more views.

What does the audience get in return? Complete contempt. I feel like an idiot for caring about the plot threads. How dare I care?”

I mean, trying to increase viewership is kind of how television works, Josh. If no one watches your show, you get cancelled – just ask the people who made Star Trek: Enterprise in the early 2000s. Or, hell, the makers of practically every show on Netflix that isn’t Stranger Things. 

And so, if we want Doctor Who to keep going, and I do, but I’m not sure about the rest of you people, we kind of need people to watch. As many people as possible. No one wants to broadcast to an empty room. I mean, for fuck’s sake, the only reason that we have a Gatwa era in the first place is because RTD stepped in and prevented the show from being cancelled after the disaster that was the Chibnall era nearly killed it.

This is a rebuild season, trying to hook people and get them into the show as opposed to only preaching to an ever-shrinking choir. And as for the video clip that got Snares in a snit? It’s jus Davies talking about Anita Dobson and Susan Twist, where Susan is being presented as the mystery woman and not Dobson through sleight of hand, just to throw people off.

For fuck’s sake, use your head. We are obviously going to learn more about Dobson’s character in the next season, just like the answer to the question about who blew up the TARDIS in series 5 wasn’t resolved until Madame Kovarian and the Silence were introduced at the start of the next season, and then confirmed to be the perpetrators in a single line of dialogue in The Time of the Doctor. (Well, two lines and a joke.)

Intentionally not resolving a plot line at the end of the season so the viewers will spend the gap puzzling over it?! Say it ain’t so! I guess misdirection and twist endings are just “engagement bait” now, and the writers who use those tricks are hacks who view their audiences with undisguised contempt! RTD should be ashamed of himself! How dare he attempt to build audience investment so the show doesn’t get cancelled early!

For crying out loud, we saw Moffat do exactly this at the start of series six: the Doctor gets fatally shot by an astronaut, and all season we are led to believe that really was his final death, except oops it wasn’t it was a robot duplicate all along. Is that engagement bait too, Josh? Are all writers just supposed to not do twist endings? Because if so OOPS THERE GOES 90% OF DETECTIVE FICTION. SAYONARA, SHERLOCK HOLMES. AU REVOIR, AGATHA CHRISTIE. BON VOYAGE, BROADCHURCH.

What the hell has happened? Have we become so cynical, so burnt out by lesser writers who pull stunts like “An anti-Amazon satire becomes a pro-Amazon propaganda piece,” that something relatively innocent as “there are two mystery women in this show and you’ve been focusing on the wrong one” is suddenly “Contempt for the viewership?”

And this problem isn’t isolated to Doctor Who fandom either. When the last two episodes of Star Trek: Picard’s third season came out, and the final boss of the series was revealed to be The Borg, not the changelings, the whining was indescribable. I realize people got burned by Voyager’s over-reliance on the Borg back in the day, but also, Voyager was 30 years ago. Can we all move on, please? (Given the bitching is still going on a year later, my guess is we’ll just keep arguing about it until the day after First Contact Day.)

But I digress. While series 14 wasn’t RTD’s finest hour by a country mile, it’s still far, far better than recent seasons have been. Empire wasn’t perfect by any stretch of the imagination, but some of what fell flat for me is more down to various production realities than anything RTD tried to do. An attempt was made, and that’s enough for me, at this stage.

The show is making progress in becoming a better version of itself. The least we can do is thank it for trying, and hope that next time, it’s a little more put together.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑