Captain’s log, stardate 79519.3: The Enterprise encounters a strange intelligence known only as Nagilum who makes it clear he intends to kill a third of the crew. Picard is force to enter into a battle of wits in order to save them.
With this episode, we reach the first true original story of the season, and our first example of what’s called a “bottle show,” an episode that takes place on a small number of sets, with an equally small number of crew. Most of the episode, thus, takes place on the bridge – they even reuse the set to represent the Yamato, but with darker lighting, to emphasize how creepy and unsettling the other ship is.
Director Winrich Kolbe makes his TNG debut here, and immediately establishes himself as one of the show’s more cinematic directors. He would go on to direct some classic TNGs, including “Allegiance,” “The Bonding,” “Darmok,” and the series finale, “All Good Things…”
As regards “Where Silence Has Lease,” he said of shooting on the bridge: “The bridge is intriguing when you step on it for the first time and you look at it for about ten minutes. Then it becomes an utter crashing bore, because it’s nothing but tan walls and a few twinkling lights. […] On something like ‘Where Silence Has Lease’ you have to keep the camera constantly moving, and that was a hell of a challenge. I spent a lot of time on that bridge on my belly, hanging down from the rafters and in any other position to try and figure out what I would do with the camera.”
The scenes aboard the Yamato are awesome. The corridors and bridge are familiar, of course, but between the darker lighting and the fact that the doors don’t open where they should, it’s a really effective way of making us realize that if they don’t escape from Nagilum, the Enterprise will end up just like her sister ship.
One thing I noticed on this watch that I didn’t last time: “The false Yamato bridge has a notable sound effect: a subtly distorted version of the Enterprise bridge background noises, indicating that things are not quite right aboard the Yamato.” (MA)
As someone who does a bit of sound design in her spare time, I love little details like this. It really enhances the uncanny strangeness of the Yamato scenes for me.
But what I find to be really compelling is the meditation on death and mortality: with no apparent avenue of escape from Nagilum’s domain, Picard and Riker return to main engineering and engage the ship’s auto-destruct mode. Picard then goes to his quarters to listen to some music as he awaits his death… and then Troi and Data show up. Or at least, we’re led to think that’s who they are:
DATA: I have a question, sir.
PICARD: Yes, Data. What is it?
DATA: What is death?
PICARD: Oh, is that all? Well, Data, you’re asking probably the most difficult of all questions. Some see it as a changing into an indestructible form, forever unchanging. They believe that the purpose of the entire universe is to then maintain that form in an Earth-like garden which will give delight and pleasure through all eternity. On the other hand, there are those who hold to the idea of our blinking into nothingness, with all our experiences, hopes and dreams merely a delusion.
DATA: Which do you believe, sir?
PICARD: Considering the marvelous complexity of our universe, its clockwork perfection, its balances of this against that, matter, energy, gravitation, time, dimension, I believe that our existence must be more than either of these philosophies. That what we are goes beyond Euclidian and other practical measuring systems and that our existence is part of a reality beyond what we understand now as reality.
I really really like Picard’s answer to that question here. While Trek has always had a reputation of being an atheism-adjacent series, there are times where it wears its atheism in such a way that you’d think the episode was being written by Richard “The God Delusion” Dawkins.
Picard’s response works for me because while it isn’t quite an admission that something like the Garden of Eden exists, he does say that our physical existence here is just one piece of something much, much greater. In fact, it reminds me of what D.J. Conway had to say about the Otherworld in her book, Wicca: The Complete Craft:
“The physical world as we know it is surrounded and interpenetrated by the astral realms, or the Otherworld. The Otherworld consists of a different type of energy that vibrates at a higher rate than anything in the physical world around us. Since we know that everything physical vibrates at different frequencies, even inanimate objects, this is a logical conclusion.”
What she goes on to describe is not quite Heaven per se, but essentially a great big celestial waiting room that souls go to after we die, whereupon they wait around before being re-incarnated. (Reincarnation is a big thing for us Wiccans.)
No one really knows what happens to us when we die – all the possible afterlives described by various world religions could be right on the money, or they could not be. And the only people who do know, obviously, aren’t in a condition to tell us. But I will say it gives me some comfort to know, insofar as I can, that this life is not the only one.
If I have any problems with this episode, it’s the sudden and uncalled for death of Ensign Redshirt. Aside from the fact that slaughtering junior officers to demonstrate how Evil the antagonist of the episode is is a tired cliche that didn’t work in the 1960s, it’s really unfortunate that the guy in question is the lone Black man in the episode, apart from Worf and Geordi. Seriously, what the fuck?
At least the next episode, “Elementary, Dear Data,” is fun. I could use some fun.
Leave a Reply