Off the Beatle Track: Beatles ’65

This week, we finally move on from the Hard Day’s Night era and into some new territory… or at least, new from the perspective of Americans in 1964. Released just ten days before Christmas, Beatles ’65 was a huge seller, jumping from number 98 straight to number 1 on the Billboard album charts, where it stayed until mid-January 1965.

Musically, ’65 is the American equivalent to the unfairly maligned Beatles For Sale, containing eight of that album’s 14 songs. It also includes the forward-thinking singles “She’s A Woman” and “I Feel Fine,” the latter of which is one of my all-time favorite Beatles songs ever

Relatedly, while I don’t usually rate the American album covers particularly highly, (since most of them are just a stock photo and some very 1960s graphic design) I do like the picture Capitol used on this album: the four lads holding umbrellas and looking serious… except Ringo, who’s smiling. Because he’s Ringo! What else would he do? I love Ringo!

Let’s break it down:


No Reply: Based on the song “Silhouettes” from 1957, this is a song in which the narrator tries to contact his unfaithful girlfriend, failing repeatedly. Despite the bossa-nova rhythm of the backing track, it’s a grim opening to the album, but given how exhausted they are after a whirlwind of a year, it makes perfect sense. (I dare you, however, to listen to this song the same way again after hearing one of the early takes from Anthology, where they forget the words and sing “your face” at the end of every verse.)

I’m A Loser: A straight break-up song in which the narrator reflects on his mistakes when dating this particular girl, whom he thought the world of, and still does. And I’ll tell you what, nothing hits you quite so hard as listening to this after… well, a break-up.

Baby’s In Black: This might sound weird considering the dark lyrics, but this is genuinely one of my favorite Beatles songs, entirely because of the vocals: John and Paul singing into the same microphone, harmonizing together in a way that only they were able to do, and it really comes alive in stereo. It’s fucking gorgeous.

Rock And Roll Music: John does a Chuck Berry cover, and he does a really great job with it! Kind of reminds me of “Twist and Shout,” though his vocal performance here is a bit more restrained here than in that earlier song. (For a given definition of “restrained” anyway.) Also note the way in which the piano drops out at 1:45.

I’ll Follow the Sun: Another great Beatles ballad, but even here, it presents a somewhat more negative view of love than we’ve come to expect from the boys so far. In other words, this is the gentlest break-up song you could hope to have, though I’ll always associate it with footage of the band in Miami during their first American tour.

Mr. Moonlight: Yeah, no, I’m sorry, the critics are right. This one just sucks. They almost used “Leave My Kitten Alone” (available on Anthology 1) and if you slipped that into place, “Kitten” is obviously a better song. This is just cheesy and awful.

Honey Don’t: Ringo’s song on the album, and it’s a cover of Carl Perkins. I don’t rate it especially highly, but that might just be because I’ve never been the biggest fan of country music. They do a pretty credible job, and it’s certainly better than “Mr. Moonlight.”

I’ll Be Back: John and Paul share lead vocal duties on this acoustic-guitar driven track – it fits like a glove on the somewhat more downbeat mood of this album, compared to its British placement on their Hard Day’s Night album. It’s a surprisingly downbeat ending to what has otherwise been their most energetic record yet, something that speaks to their rapidly increasing maturity as musicians.

She’s A Woman: Another great Paul song where he gets to do his rock and roll voice again, I love any song where he gets to sing about how awesome his woman is. He’s head-over-heels for this chick, and you can tell! This mix of the song, along with “I Feel Fine,” contains additional compression and reverb, added by Dave Dexter Jr. when he remixed the song for its release here. This gives the song a more crisp vibe than the original UK masters.

I Feel Fine: Another song with a particularly notable beginning, the start of “I Feel Fine” happened when Paul McCartney plucked an A note on his bass while it was pointed in the vicinity of John’s guitar amp, causing feedback. Doing this technically violated EMI’s recording rules, but as so often happens in the story of this band, sometimes you have to break the rules to get the sound you want.

Everybody’s Trying to Be My Baby: Poor George, getting no vocal time until the last track on the album. It’s another Carl Perkins cover, and this one is pretty successful. George always really liked Carl Perkins, and you can hear that love in his performance on the track. I have to admit I really like the echo on his voice here – a good slap-back echo never hurt anyone.


Considering that the majority of the tracklist here comes from what is, until Let It Be, their most gloomy album, (even though I rate it quite highly) I actually find ’65 to be a somewhat brighter listen than its British equivalent. I’m not really sure why, but maybe it all just comes down to vibes. There’s just something charmingly innocent about the cover, which lends some relief from the pessimism of some of the music.

And of course, I’ll go to bat for any song that contains “I Feel Fine.” That song is fucking great, it’s always been one of my favorites.

As the album’s sleeve notes say, “Some said it couldn’t really be happening; that it was just publicity. And the fabulous Beatles proved them wrong. Others said they couldn’t last more than a month or two; that nobody could hang onto that kind of fame. The Beatles, of course, proved them wrong too. Then when their first movie was released, and even the critics liked it, people began to wonder if all those Beatle fans hadn’t really discovered something after all.”

“But you, the Beatles’ fans, knew all along. You knew that the Beatles really do have a style and a sound like there’s never been before. And it’s simply because you like them (and they like you) that this fantastic success story has happened, and continues to happen more and more all the time.”

Even now, 60 years after they first came to America and took us all by storm, we still love them. Just look at “I’m Only Sleeping” winning the Grammy for best music video, or the “War is Over” short winning the Oscar for best animated short film. Or, hell, the fact that “Now and Then” hit number 7 on the Billboard charts, and number 1 on the UK singles charts.

Which all just proves one thing: the Beatles are eternal.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑