This week, we go back to the movies with the soundtrack to Help!, the Beatles’ second movie. The film was conceptualized as a James Bond pastiche, albeit a very surreal one, given that it’s Richard Lester in the director’s chair. A full analysis of the movie will come later – for now, let’s stick to the music.
1965 finds the Beatles singing about far more complicated subject matter than they love songs that typified their early work, and the Help! album in particular may as well be a concept album about crumbling relationships, because that’s what most of the songs (including the film ones) are about, and that really becomes clear on the US version, since all we have are the movie songs.
Doing the non-Beatles music this time is Ken Thorne, Lester’s composer of choice. His relationship with George Martin had soured during the making of A Hard Day’s Night, and to quote Martin himself: “I produced all the tracks for the film, but I wasn’t asked to do the scoring – another guy was offered the job. Dick Lester and I didn’t hit it off too well on A Hard Day’s Night, and the fact that I got an Academy Award nomination for musical direction probably didn’t help either.” Thorne, at least, was someone Lester could control.
Musically, Thorne does a lot of things differently from Martin – while Martin’s AHDN score really was just orchestral arrangements of Beatles songs, Thorne experiments, combining Beatles melody lines with original classical music compositions. It’s an interesting shift, so now seems like a good time to go track by track:
‘Help!’: The title song, written by John Lennon. He described it as essentially being him calling out for help amidst the hurricane that was Beatlemania in the early sixties, and that really does lend the track a more anxious vibe than “A Hard Day’s Night” had. Audio nerd note: the lead vocal heard on the stereo version is completely different to the lead vocal on the mono – listen to the verses and choruses, not the intro. This version of the song opens with a James Bond-style introduction, fitting the vibe of the period.
‘The Night Before’: Paul’s first song, about a relationship that is rapidly heading toward a nasty split, the narrator’s wishes to be treated “like he was the night before” notwithstanding. One could imagine (since they’re both film songs) that the later track, “Another Girl,” is the song that comes after this, if the two narrators are the same person. Interestingly, the reverb that’s on Paul’s lead vocal on the stereo mix isn’t on the mono mix. How about that!
From Me To You Fantasy (instrumental): Somehow, Ken Thorne works in the lead vocal line of this classic Beatles single from 1963 and turns it into a tense, menacing piece of orchestral backing music that plays during the movie scene where the two competing villain groups (the scientists and Easterners) converge on the Beatles’ house to try and kill them. I particularly like the use of military-style snare beats mixed with tambura drones here. symbolizing our antagonists.
‘You’ve Got To Hide Your Love Away’: John doing another Dylan pastiche, only this time with flute rather than harmonica. No one is entirely sure what inspired the writing – John never spoke about it before he died, though some have claimed it may be about Brian Epstein, given that Brian was gay and that was illegal in 1965.
‘I Need You’: George’s first composition in two years, it’s another uneasy song about love gone sour, as our protagonist (George himself) tries to get his girlfriend (Pattie Boyd) to cone back after a separation, explaining that he can’t make it through life without her. This is one of the last pure rock songs we’ll get from George before he starts getting really into Indian music – funnily enough, while the Help! film was being made.
In The Tyrol (instrumental): An original from Thorne this time: the first part appears during the Swiss Alp scenes where Klang accidentally wins a skiing competition, while the next part appears during the big fight scene at the house.
‘Another Girl’: In which our protagonist from “The Night Before” tells his ex-girlfriend to, basically, go fuck herself for two minutes, along with extolling the virtues of his new main squeeze. Its rough equivalent on A Hard Day’s Night is probably “Can’t Buy Me Love,” given the up-tempo rhythm and the similar introduction (one line sung a cappella before the rest of the band crashes in behind him) but this is a much angrier song than “Buy” ever was.
Another Hard Day’s Night (instrumental): This is pretty clever! A short medley of A Hard Day’s Night songs played on Indian instruments, used during the restaurant sequences in the first third of the movie. The songs are “A Hard Day’s Night,” “Can’t Buy Me Love.” and “I Should Have Known Better.” It was while this scene was being shot that George Harrison got his first exposure to Indian classical music, changing his life (and the sound of the band) forever.
‘Ticket To Ride’: One of the Beatles songs of 1965, “Ticket to Ride” has been described by John Lennon as the first heavy metal song, I can kind of get why he thought that – this is a heavy song, thanks to a combination of overdubs and the drone-like, sustained A chord that runs through the main body of the track. Also, that riff is fucking great, and I really love Ringo’s drumming here.
The Bitter End/You Can’t Do That (instrumental): This track plays at the very beginning of the movie, where Eleanor Bron’s character first attempts to steal the sacrificial ring worn by a sleeping Ringo. And while I hate the original version of You Can’t Do That, I have to admit, it works pretty well when it’s used here.
‘You’re Going To Lose That Girl’: I’ve always really liked this song, mainly because of how it’s used in the movie: we join the Beatles pretending to record this song in a studio, in a haze of blue and purple light and cigarette smoke. (Because it’s the ‘60s.) It’s one of my favorite scenes in the whole movie, and the song is pretty great as well. The solo remains one of my favorite Beatles moments.
The Chase (instrumental): I’ve seen this movie pretty recently, and for the life of me I couldn’t tell you where this song appears in it. Nice sound though, Indian classical music has really neat sonic textures. I think I get why George got so hooked into it.
It’s not until you listen to this album with all the lighter tracks taken out that you realize just how fucking heavy Help! is, as a production. For all the grief people give Beatles For Sale, that still has plenty of light to balance out the darkness. Help! is far more moody, it’s just harder to see given the jangle-pop arrangements of the tracks. Then again, given the way Beatlemania was really starting to take its toll, I can’t say I’m surprised that everyone (or at least John, Paul, and George) are in a sour mood.
Leave a Reply