Off the Beatle Track: Rubber Soul (US)

With this album, we reach the point that is usually regarded to be the one where the Beatles stopped being a mere pop act and became the genuine artists we all know and love today. Rubber Soul is the culmination of an evolutionary process that’s been going on since late 1964, and it’s genuinely incredible how fast they turned things around. And this was an album that was rush-released in late 1965 for the Christmas shopping season.

Sonically, the American version of this album sounds more like the Beatles attempting to do their own spin on the folk rock genre, popularized by artists like Bob Dylan, the Byrds, and Simon and Garfunkel. You could put this one on after Sounds of Silence, and I imagine they’d fit together pretty well.

On to the music, then:


I’ve Just Seen A Face: Nothing indicates the fact that this Rubber Soul is going to be different from the British one than the opening track. While both versions start with a Paul song, this one originated from the British version of Help!, and given the acoustic guitar that runs throughout, it suits the folk rock vibe of this record perfectly.

Norwegian Wood (This Bird Has Flown): John’s acoustic ballad about an affair he was having, it’s still a lovely song, with lots of acoustic guitar and some great vocal parts from John and Paul. But of course, what ties it all together is George’s sitar part, the first recorded instance of his growing interest in Indian music. Just try and imagine it without it. You can’t, can you?

You Won’t See Me: A song of Paul’s about Jane Asher, this is one of my all-time favorite Beatles break-up songs, just because of how 200% done Paul is with Jane’s bullshit. It’s aggressively petty, and very cathartic to listen to after a nasty break-up. I should also direct you to a version by Dar Williams – no lyric changes, so in her hands it becomes a lesbian break-up song as well.

Think For Yourself: Another great break-up song on an album full of them, the fuzz bass on this song is kind of amazing. One of my favorite George songs, paws down – emotionally speaking, the exact opposite of “I Need You.” (George seems to have a thing for break-up songs, doesn’t he? They dominate most of his Beatles work, other than the Indian-inspired pieces of the mid-late sixties.)

The Word: The first Beatles anthem about love as a concept, this song is a forerunner of “All You Need is Love,” and as a theme, it stays with John throughout his life, all the way to “Mind Games” in 1974. It’s one of my favorites of his, and I particularly like the American stereo mix, where you have double-tracked vocals by him during the verses, something not heard on the regular UK version.

Michelle: When I first came out as trans around nine years ago (holy fuck nine years?!) I chose Michelle for my replacement middle name, entirely because of this song. I had hoped Paul might perform it when I saw him live in 2016, but he didn’t – maybe I’d’ve stuck with it if he had. (As it is, Fenrira Dukane fits me better anyway, middle name wise.)

It’s Only Love: One of only a few traditional “love” songs on this album, even here the feelings are more complex than pure puppy love. Our narrator sings about a turbulent relationship, even as he admits that he’s still head-over-heels for her. It’s far from John’s best love song, but it’s got a good melody to it. On the British Help! album, I thought it was kind of weak, but it suits this album pretty nicely.

Girl: I’ve never been overly fond of this song, mainly because of the hissing noises that come between repetitions of the title – they’re really loud on the stereo mix, so Young Lena would always get freaked out by them. Thankfully, the mono mix (which I’m listening to as I write this) has them much much quieter, almost to the point of inaudibility.

I’m Looking Through You: The best break-up song Paul McCartney ever wrote, I’ve listened to it a lot over the years, in a variety of contexts. Fun fact: my girlfriend and I talked about this song quite a bit on the day we got together. In fact, it was part of our first conversation as a couple!

In My Life: One of John’s prettiest ballads, my personal favorite aspect of this song is the piano solo – it sounds like a harpsichord, but it isn’t! It’s a regular piano played at half speed, then sped up, a technique called varispeed. I used the exact technique once in an AUDI 2000 assignment in college, and my professor was really impressed! Thanks, George Martin!

Wait: A leftover from the Help! sessions, it’s really not much to write home about. I like the lyrics well enough, and any moment when John and Paul get to swap lead vocal parts is always fun, it’s one of the few standard love songs on this album, which really accentuates the extent to which love songs are an increasingly rare breed on Beatles records.

Run For Your Life: I absolutely fucking hate this song. I understand it’s John trying to do a sarcastic Elvis song, but I don’t care, because it just fucking sucks. While this doesn’t drag my opinion of the whole album down in much the same way “You Can’t Do That” did, it’s still a bad note on an otherwise perfect album. Leave this off, and you have perfection. (Or put “Day Tripper” on instead. That would also work.)


With the exception of the last track, Rubber Soul is an otherwise excellent album, filled with songs that illustrate their rapidly-developing maturity as musicians. Even the cover art, with its stretched photograph and only the title on the front, brings home just how quickly they’re progressing. The American version, too, is worth celebrating – despite the similarities in track listings, the two changes Capitol did make with the running order completely change the album’s vibe – this is a very autumnal album, meant to be listened to on crisp October mornings while drinking pumpkin spice lattes.

Next time: we bring our Capitol Albums series to an end with a two-for-one special: Revolver, when the boys’ music drops all pretense at being standard rock and roll, and starts defying every genre convention you can possibly imagine. We’ll also look at Hey Jude, the final Capitol original album to be released during the band’s lifespan.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑