My name is Lena Mactíre, and I sure fucking wish someone was going to memory wipe me, because dear Goddess, I could go the rest of my life without watching Time Heist again. I didn’t like it in 2014 when it first came out, and I don’t like it now ten years later.
Which is pretty much par for the course where Steve Thompson is concerned – the last time I talked about him was in book 3 of Back to the Eleventh Hour, when I discussed series 7’s Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS. Back then, I wrote:
It isn’t just that Journey is a lesser TARDIS story than Wife – if anything, Journey is functionally the inverse of Gaiman’s love story. It de-personalizes the old girl, turning her into a mere machine with a penchant for lashing out at those who try to hurt her by turning them into hideous monsters.
And when we’re not doing that, we’re doing some casual sexism when the Doctor offers to put the TARDIS in easy mode so Clara can more easily learn how to fly her. He denies it, but come on. Doctor, you’re not fooling me! River Song can fly her better than you, because the TARDIS taught her herself! You’re just being an ass!
Now, okay, my praise of Doctor’s Wife reads very badly in light of recent revelations about Gaiman, but I think my basic point is sound. Thompson had exactly one hit in his short career as a Who writer: The Curse of the Black Spot from series 6, which aside from being the best of the three attempts to do a story involving pirates and the Doctor, also touched on fatherhood, greed, and love.
His second story, being About The TARDIS in the season after the home run that was Doctor’s Wife, was always going to have a rough time measuring up. What no one could have anticipated was just how bad the final product was going to be, what with the sexism and racism and the sheer pointlessness of the final twist.
You would think, then, that with Time Heist there might be some room for improvement… and then you remember that Thompson also wrote that extremely Sino-phobic episode of Sherlock, The Blind Banker, and you realize we’re all pretty much royally fucked.
Like, let’s just start with the basics. This is supposed to be the Doctor Who version of heist movies like Ocean’s Eleven, but it kind of fails to be a heist movie in much the same way The Ghost Monument failed to be a sci-fi version of The Amazing Race. I’m sorry, but taking what we thought was a heist and turning it into a rescue mission is just an abject failure to understand the assignment.
Actually, the Monument comparison is surprisingly appropriate. In 2014, the Capaldi era was big and new and interesting, but now we’re ten years and three Doctors removed from it. More to the point, the era that this episode most resembles is the Chibnall era, just with a better quality of dialogue.
I mean, look at the guest cast. Psi and Saibra might as well be called Exposition and Comic Relief, or Dan and Yaz, for all the impact they make on the script. They are transparently there to fill up holes in the plot, and very little actual work is done to make us give a shit about them. What they want and what they wish for is just said straight out, never shown, kind of like that scene in Ascension of the Cybermen where Graham and Yaz exposit about the lovely relationship they had offscreen. So when they “die,” it’s hard to care about them.
The only thing that makes this episode even half interesting is Peter Capaldi. Served with his first clunker of a script, he’s able to salvage the material with aplomb, turning in a performance that is at once classic Early Twelve, and even gestures to his series 9 characterization, with just a bit of ham and cheese when the Teller attacks him. (That said, the “sly” Malcolm Tucker references really don’t fit, I’m glad those got dropped after Dark Water.)
The episode that best manages to do what Time Heist couldn’t, hilariously, isn’t even a Doctor Who story. I refer to “Sparkle’s Seven,” the 200th episode of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic.
In the episode, Twilight and her friends are tasked with testing out Canterlot Castle’s new security system, which includes such delights as an anti-magic field made from the shards of Queen Chrysalis’s throne, giant fans that prevent getting in from the air, brick walls over the entrances to the castle’s underground tunnels, doubled and round-the-clock royal guard security, doors that only open with royal guard medals, a trap door, and an alarm system of geese. Shining Armor, Twilight’s older brother, tells Twilight that if she can get past all these defenses and steal the crown without getting caught, she will earn the title of Sibling Supreme forever.
And then everything goes horribly wrong as Twilight’s plan B (do the opposite of what Shining Armor knows Twilight would do in this situation) falls apart. She instead goes back to plan A – utilize the respective skillsets of her friends to steal the crown. But not even that works, because Shining Armor knew exactly what Twilight was going to do, and prepared for it.
In the end, the true winners of the heist are Spike and Princess Luna: Spike sensed Celestia and Luna’s disagreement regarding castle security earlier and made a deal with Luna. She deliberately appointed Zephyr Breeze (Fluttershy’s dipshit older brother) to guard the tunnels and kept Celestia out of the castle hallways, while Spike sabotaged Pinkie’s hot air balloon and made sure the Mane Six went back to Twilight’s original plan. Finally, during Shining Armor’s victorious gloating, Luna teleported the crown directly into Spike’s hands.
And that, mares and gentlecolts, is how you do a heist episode.
A bunch of empty corridors and different colored lighting gels does not an interesting story make. Characterization is what matters. “Sparkle’s Seven” works because the five voice actresses that played the Mane Six knew their characters really well, and used the 9 seasons they’d spent getting to know them to their advantage.
True, Thompson wouldn’t have been able to pack that much depth into a couple of one-off guest stars, but he could’ve at least tried instead of phoning it in. I mean shit, even the salvage brothers from his previous script had more going for them, and those are the guys who thought “Let’s trick our brother into thinking he’s an android” was a good idea.
At least next week, I get to bury Gareth Roberts.
Leave a Reply